the secularisation thesis Flashcards
secualrisation?
- loss of infulence of relg
how does sec take place 5 ways
- decline in practice
-people no longer believe - lpse of infulence of relg organisaitons
- churches undergone internal sec
- relg diversity or pluraism
decline in practice
decline in people practising their religion by attending religious services etc.
people no longer believe
people no longer believe in God, spirits, good and evil etc.
infulence of relg organisations decline
they are no longer involved in the day to day running of society
churches undergo internal sec
watered down beliefs e.g sex b4 marriage
religious pluraism and diversity
range of beliefs to choose from now
issues with measuring decline
The evidence from the past lacks representativeness – historical records often only reflected the views of the privileged as they are the ones who could read and write
The evidence from the past lacks validity – there were no opinion polls or interviews conducted
lacks reliability – we are not aware of how data was actually collected
problems with interpreting evidence
High participation does not mean strong belief! Some may attend due to social obligation or support. Aldridge – American way of life.
Low participation does not mean no belief Believing without belonging. (Davie)
Quantitative Vs. Qualitative data – Quantitative data may suggest a decline in religiosity but qualitative data may suggest otherwise
problems with asking qs ab relg
Some may exaggerate when asked about religious activity
There is more than one way of defining religion
Some questions can be misleading or operationalised differently.
issue with yougov census in 2011
YouGov survey had a different outcome than the 2011 Census. Some believe this was due to the wording: “Are you religious?” / “What is your religion?”
problems with measuring membership and attenedce and practice
- “Practice” varies between individuals and religious groups. Some sects demand high participation
2.Information about smaller religious groups is often unavailable. Some may overestimate their membership.
3.Some religious practice is not recorded at all. E.g. worshipping at home.
4.Different denominations use different criteria of membership.
why has sec happened
- rise in fem= womens careers
-growth of media- choice of beliefs
-church less infuelnce over state - less stigma of not being relg
- parsons struc diff
-emergence of scientfic ideas
-disenchantment weber - intro of NRMS
-people have busier schedules
-some grps dont feel marginalised
-globalisaiton(spirtual shopping, brough more chocie)