Religious experience Flashcards
What is a religious experience?
Religious experiences are a phenomenon that have been recorded for thousands of years and takes a variety of forms; different from ordinary experience as they are subjective, not verifiable and life-changing.
What happens in visions?
Mystic may believe they have seen or heard someone or something that no one else can. Appears to be sensory. Caroline frank Davis cals it quari-sesnory
What is quasi-sensory?
resembling a sensory experience, but not having all the usual features of one
What is a sensory experience?
Sometimes called corporal, st Bernadette
What is an intellectual experience?
Brings knowledge and understanding that can’t be gained in any other way, seen with the mind rather than the eye. Brings a message; st ignatisu of Loyola
What are dreams?
Occur sleeping, meditative state. Jacobs ladder to heaven, generally individual/
What is conversions?
Where a person changes from one standpoint to another, life changing. William James wrote the conversion of the sick soul.
What is mysticism?
By nature, hard to define. ed miller- Transcendet, ineffable noetic, ecstatic and unitive. A mystical experience includes a temporary removal of the sense of self or ego so that the person feels no separation between themselves and the divine.
What does kataphatic?
Making positive claims about the divine
What is prayer?
Communication with the divine, contemplative prayer of st teresa of avilia.
What were William James’ 4 features of religious experience?
(PINT)Had another pragmatic approach, passive, ineffable, noetic and transcient. realises most people who have experiences believe them and say they have a istive outcome.
What did Rudolf Otto propose?
Admired James’ work developed a new schematisation. Used the term numinous (supernatural/divine)
What were Rudolf Otto’s 4 features?
Creature consciousness, vast presence of god
Wholly other, completley different from us
Sense of dread or terror, requires person to kneel or protstrate
Simultaneous fascination, we fear/awe of god
Experience ends in a bliss/confusion
What does mysetierium tremednudm mean?
Mysterium- wholly other
tremendous- Awe, fear, dread
Fascians- pull or attrition of experience, can’t pull yourself away
What was William craigs quotation about religious experience?
“Mystics are very aware that what they experience could be the devils deception… mayor test is the an experience which generally produces love cannot be self-deceptive”
What does Catherine Davis believe?
Doesn’t try to dissprove religious experiences but tries to challenge them, they can be used to suggest god exists.
What are Frank Davis' categories of religious expereicn?
the interpretive (paranormal events), quasi-sensory, revelatory, regenerative, numinous, and mystical.
What does franks Davis say about the chapter reductionist challenge?
Sorts through research of cognitive psychology of religious experiences like hyper-suggestibility, deprivation, sexual frustration. Warns that relgious experiences can do little on their own, any argument which claims they have had one must take complexity into account (link to James effable)
What is a cumulative case?
Arguing for theism
what are the positives about James’ adequacy of experience?
All lists from other scholars are based upon the work of James, his 4 features retain the flexibility to describe faith in context, can be understood by all (st teresa of avilia). James takes a psychologically approach rather than a religious approach of describing the events (contradiction to Caroline Davis)
What are the inadequacy for James’ experiences?
Miller have suggested other additional features “the pursuit of a transcendent, unitive with absolutely realty”- Argument for the belief in God (transcendent figure). No account can be adequate if cant describe it with normal language. Only describes a hallucination not a real event
Are religious experiences valid as challenges?
So many other testable explanations that are mire believable. NO one can experience the wholly other, experience is only in the empirical world. Hard to trust, too much VARITEY
How are religious experiences not valid?
Inspiration has led to scientific discoveries such as the benzene ring, impossible t interpret
How are religious experiences valid?
Verification is the only way of producing any kind of certainty about truth
Inspiration must be tested to overcome scientific discovery
So unusual we could test their integrity
How are franks’ davis challenges persuasive?
we automatically have reason to doubt someone’s claims as it is not universal or usual
Our senses are often fooled
Different ways we can challenge accounts
How are franks’ davis challenges not persuasive?
lists these as inadequate against religious experiences
Principle of credulity- if something happened it probably did
Principle of testimony- prevents descent into a sceptical bog.
Description related challenges are limited because those who are describing it are describing something beyond religious experience (linguistic precision)
What does Swinburne propose?
In his book existence of God there are 5 types of religious experiences; public and private