Memory Leading Qs Affecting Accuracy Of EWT Flashcards
Memory
Factors affecting accuracy of EWT
Leading Qs
Misleading info is
Incorrect info given to EW usually after the event
Includes anxiety,post even discussion,and leading Qs
Memory
Factors affecting accuracy of EWT
Leading Qs
A question cus of way its prhased suggests certain answer eg
“How old wad the youth in phot”
“How old was man in photo”
Memory
Factors affecting accuracy of EWT
Study
45 participants students
7 films of diff traffic accidents
In lab
All watched same films
After ,each given questionare
N asked to describe accident then answer Qs including “how fast were cars going when they________ each other?
Students in 5 conditions, 9 participants in each ,only in one of them each
Every condition had diff verbs to fill the gap- smashed,collided,bumped,hit or contacted
Memory
Factors affecting accuracy of EWT
Leading Qs
Results
Smashed =(all estimated) speed of 40.8MPH
Collided=estimated 39.9MPH
Hit=34.0MPH
Contacted=31.8MPH
Memory
Factors affecting accuracy of EWT
Leading Qs
Conclusion
Change in term material proves alters memory recall n makes less accurate
Memory
Factors affecting accuracy of EWT
Leading Qs
High control
Standardised instructions
IV CAUSE DV
Memory
Factors affecting accuracy of EWT
Leading Qs
Low ecological val
Not conducted in realistic n meaningful way
Watched a video of accident, very diff to seeing irl
Low stress
Also not generalisable to real life cus testimony could lead somone to prison
Important to be right
Irl not waiting to witness car accident -expected it coming
Memory
Factors affecting accuracy of EWT
Leading Qs
Low ecological val counterargument
Yuille n Cutshawl found leading Qs didn’t effect accuracy in real life research
So even when ecological val high don’t make EWT less accurate
Memory
Factors affecting accuracy of EWT
Leading Qs
Practical application
Lead to cognitive interview
Which reduces opportunities for leading Qs to be used in police
-extensive application So less incorrect convictions
So less appeals so more money saved in criminal justice system