French Revolution, Points Test 4 – The Downfall of the Absolute Monarchy Flashcards
- When did the Assembly of Notables meet?
- When did the Assembly of Notables meet?
February-May 1787.
- When was it last used, and of many many people did it consist?
- When was it last used, and of many many people did it consist?
Consisted of 144 men, included 7 princes of the blood.
Last used 1626.
- Why did the Assembly not simply rubber-stamp Calonne’s reform package, as he/Louis had hoped?
- Why did the Assembly not simply rubber-stamp Calonne’s reform package, as he/Louis had hoped?
• Louis XVI chose same composition in 1787, despite Turgot and Necker’s reform attempts (neither of the two new provincial assemblies sent body).
• Also all senior judges from the parlement, important ‘notables’ representing provincial estates, and 14 representatives of the church.
• Turned out to be far from a docile rubber stamp, as Louis and Calonne had hoped.
• When presented with Calonne’s proposals, threw up obstacles.
The clergy hostile to plans to tax the church, led by Etienne-Charles de Loménie de Brienne, the archbishop of Toulouse.
Other notables not convinced the situation was bad enough to warrant reform.
When Calonne revealed the Comte Redu was in error, it only made matters worse.
Necker responded by publishing an attack on Calonne, and the assembly accused Calonne of incompetence and trying to shift blame to others.
- What aggressive and unfair action did Calonne take which infuriated the Assembly further, and why was it unfair?
- What aggressive and unfair action did Calonne take which infuriated the Assembly further, and why was it unfair?
- Calonne foolishly swept aside legitimate criticisms and published articles accusing the notables of allowing self-interest to stand in the way of change.
- This was untrue. Many (including Brienne) were ready to have a fairer tax system.
- They had been influenced by the enlightenment.
- However, they distrusted Calonne (seeing him as an e.g. of ‘ministerial despotism’).
- How did Louis initially act when Calonne faced opposition, and why was Marie-Antoinette influential in ensuring he changed his mind?
- How did Louis initially act when Calonne faced opposition, and why was Marie-Antoinette influential in ensuring he changed his mind?
• Louis briefly tried to support Calonne.
• In April 1787, under pressure from Marie-Antoinette, he decided Calonne had to go.
• The Queen constantly sought to advance her favourites’ interests with her husband.
• Her success in doing so demonstrated Louis’ dependence on her in these difficult years.
• Her friendship with the duchess de Polignac, whose family were hostile to Calonne, led her to seek Calonne’s dismissal. Her support for Brienne helped ensure his advance.
- Who was Brienne?
- Who was Brienne?
- Came from a noble family.
- Had entered the church as a career.
- Intelligent and a good administrator.
- 1763, became Archbishop of Toulouse.
- Had been friend of Turgot and sympathetic to philosophes.
- Resigned August 1788.
- He then became Archbishop of Sens and a cardinal.
- Took oath to the CCC.
- Imprisoned for his aristocratic background and died during the terror.
- What were Brienne’s proposals for reform?
- What were his proposals for reform?
- Changes affecting the army, navy, administration of the royal domain and central government put forward.
- Extended tolerance to Protestants, deregulated the grain trade, changed the corvée royale into a tax and extended the provincial assemblies.
- He gave local taxpayers the right to vote for these.
- Supported the spread of education, the codification of the law.
- Proposed the abolition of tax-farming and the establishment of a central treasury.
- Indeed, Brienne headed what became the last great reforming ministry of the Ancien Régime.
- Why did Brienne’s reform efforts fail?
- Why did his reform efforts fail?
- However, his plans overshadowed by a need for money.
- Attempted to carry out Calonne’s land tax, with some modifications to meet earlier criticisms.
- This failed.
- The assembly had almost become too used to challenging the king’s representative.
- The publication of accounts to convince the notables of the need for action led to more accusations of incompetence.
- What demands did the notables begin to make that led Louis to dismiss them in May 1787?
- What demands did the notables begin to make that led Louis to dismiss them in May 1787?
- The notables took up the cry ‘no taxation without representation’.
- They called for the ‘Estates-General’ to meet, to provide fully scrutiny of the proposals.
- Louis dismissed the Assembly in May 1787.
- Who was Brienne forced to do the Assembly was dismissed?
- Who was Brienne forced to do the Assembly was dismissed?
- Again, Brienne had to resort to a loan to keep the country afloat.
- Without the assembly to endorse tax changes, Brienne turned to the parlements.
- What did Brienne ask of the Paris Parlement, and what was its reply? Why was this hardly surprising?
- What did he ask of the Paris Parlement, and what was its reply? Why was this hardly surprising?
- He asked the Paris Parlement to register his proposals for a land tax and higher stamp duties.
- In July, it declared that while supportive of reform in principle, it wasn’t competent to endorse such changes.
- This wasn’t surprising, given a number of notables sat in this body.
- In its response, what else did the Paris Parlement claim to Brienne’s requests, and why was this supported widely in France?
- In its response, what else did the Paris Parlement claim, and why was this supported widely in France?
- Indeed, the Paris Parlement (followed by others) asserted its rights to speak for the nation and protect citizens’ rights against despotism.
- Such views, stemming from enlightenment principles, popular in country at large.
- Ever since Assembly of Notables summoned, discussion of ‘power-sharing’ dominated talk among the educated in the town and country.
- Therefore only natural that they should see the parlement as their champions, protecting the people from sinister royal plans.
- This attitude reinforced when Brienne tried to force the registration of the tax proposals using the lit de justice.
- What was the response of the Paris Parlement when Brienne tried to force through his reforms, using a Lit de Justice?
- What was the response of the Paris Parlement when Brienne tried to force through his reforms, using a Lit de Justice?
- The Paris Parlement refused to accept this.
- In July they petitioned the King for an Estates-General.
- Who was the duc d’Orléans?
- Who was the duc d’Orléans?
- Philippe, duc d’Orléans, was a Prince of the Blood and Louis’ cousin.
- He developed liberal ideas and was an outspoken critic of the Ancien Régime in both the Assembly of Notables and the Paris Parlement.
- His Paris home, the palais-royal, became a centre for revolutionary speeches.
- He joined the national assembly after being elected to the Estates-General as a 2nd estate deputy.
- He voted for Louis’ death in 1793.
- He changed his name to Philippe Egalité.
- His son (Louis-Philippe, the future king) defected to the Austrians.
- He was arrested and guillotined afterwards.
- How had Duc d’Orléans defied the king?
- How had Duc d’Orléans defied the king?
• The duc d’Orléans had already spoken out vociferously against Louis in the Assembly of Notables.
- How did Louis XVI emulate his grandfather in responding to the defiance of the Parlement?
- How did Louis XVI emulate his grandfather in responding to the defiance of the Parlement?
• Such hostility provoked Louis to react as his grandfather had done: in August, the Paris Parlement were banished to Troyes (to get it away from the baying crowds).
- How did the provincial parlements support the defiance of the Paris Parlement?
- How did the provincial parlements support the defiance of the Paris Parlement?
• However, the provincial parlement unanimously declared their refusal to register the edicts.