French Revolution, Points Test 11 - Rise of Napoleon Flashcards

1
Q

How long did Napoleon rule over France, as Consul and then Emperor?

A

Established himself as consul (1799-1804) and in turn, Emperor (1804-1815).
• Forced to abdicate in 1814, returned to power for 100 days in 1815.
• Defeated at Waterloo and exiled to St Helena.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

Where was Napoleon born, and what was his background?

A
  • Born in Corsica just one year after the French were given the island by the Genoese.
  • Father’s family (Buonaparte) of ancient Tuscan nobility, brought up as one of 8 children, speaking Italian.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

In what circumstances did Napoleon come to France?

A
  • In 1778, 9-year old Napoleon (and elder Joseph) gained admission to the Collége d’Autun, where they learned to speak French.
  • Spent 5 years at military college of Brienne.
  • One year (1784) on a scholarship, at Ecole Militaire in Paris.
  • Became 2nd lieutenant of artillery.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

How did Napoleon become involved in the French revolution?

A
  • Played no part in early revolution, although he read Voltaire and generally favoured reform.
  • In 1791 he joined a Jacobin club in Valence, in SE france, where he was based.
  • Later that year, the NG in Corsica.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

When did Napoleon’s career truly begin to become noteworthy?

A
  • However, his career really took off with the coming of war and his need to fight counter-revolution within France.
  • Between August and December 1793, he helped drive the British from Toulon.
  • In recognition of his success, rewarded by promotion to Major in September.
  • Made adjutant-general in October and brigadier-general in December, still only 24.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

Why did Napoleon nearly perish during the terror?

A
  • Napoleon’s career briefly threatened by the fall of Robespierre.
  • Robespierre had appointed him commandant of the artillery in the French army of Italy in 1794.
  • He was a close friend of Robespierre’s brother Augustin, and was tried for conspiracy and spent a month in gaol.
  • Spared the guillotine, though he lost his position.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

How was Napoleon able to take advantage of the Vendémiaire rising of Oct 1795?

A
  • Was able to take advantage of being in Paris at the time of the royalist Vendémiaire Rising (Oct 1795).
  • As reward for saving the republic, made commander of the army of the interior and adviser on military matters to the Directory.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

Why did Napoleon then leave France after the Vendémiaire rising?

A
  • Appointed commander-in-chief of the army of Italy in March 1796.
  • This was seven days before his marriage to a 33 year-old divorcee, Josephine Tascher de la Pagerie.
  • Two days after the ceremony, the ambitious 27 year old left for Italy.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

Why did Napoleon become involved with Josephine?

A
  • In 1795, Napoleon became involved with Josephine.
  • She was the widow of General Alexandre de Beauharnais, guillotined during the Terror.
  • The mother of two children, and experienced in love affairs.
  • A friend of Barras (with whom she had had an affair), known for her beauty and charm.
  • Though six years older than him, Napoleon fell madly in love and married her on 9 March 1796.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

Why was Napoleon not expected to do much in Italy?

A
  • His appointment given in recognition of his talent.
  • However, as a young and inexperienced general, hadn’t been expected to take the main thrust of the attack against Austria in spring of 1796.
  • Hoche was given that honour in Germany.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

Why did the failure of the Rhine Campaign of 1796 help Napoleon?

A

• In campaigning in the north along the Rhine in 1796, Jourdan and Moreau succeeded in crossing the river and advancing into German states.
• Jourdan advanced as far as Amberg in Late August.
• Moreau reached Barvaria and the edge of Tyrol by September.
• However, Jourdan defeated by Archduke Charles, Duke of Teschen.
• Both armies forced to retreat back across the Rhine.
(Made Napoleon’s victories in Italy more significant and crucial by comparison).

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

What was the Directory’s plan with the Rhine and Italian campaigns?

A
  • Directory authorised a drive by Moreau and Jourdan north of the alps along the Rhine.
  • Meanwhile Napoleon would have the limited objective of holding back the Austrians in Italy by way of a diversion.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

Why was the Army of Italy not expected to achieve much, and what did Napoleon do to change this?

A
  • According to the propaganda which later exalted Napoleon’s achievements in Italy, the ambitious young general transformed the army of Italy.
  • Found them demoralised, poorly-equipped, under-nourished and unpaid.
  • From 1792, it was true that it had been confided to the mountains and coastline, with little opportunity for glory.
  • In 1796, it numbered c.7,000, against Austria and Piedmont-Sardinia’s c52,000, and it was poorly provided for in comparison to more prestigious areas where French armies fighting.
  • Supposedly, Napoleon made them courageous and capable fighting force, which rapidly won military glory.
  • The truth probably less impressive: he did arrange for troops to be paid in silver (rather than paper money), the soldiers’ confidence boosted by some rapid victories against Austrian’s allies the Piedmontese, which gave opportunities for spoils.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

How did Napoleon knock Piedmont-Sardinia out of the war?

A
  • The Montenotte Campaign had begun after the Winter.
  • Lasted only from 10th April 1796 to 28th April.
  • In April 1796, Piedmont-Sardinia withdrew from the 1st Coalition, by the Armistice of Cherasco.
  • Brought a boost to the republic, and to Napoleon.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

What did Piedmont-Sardinia surrender to France as a result?

A
  • Confirmed in Paris, the following month, it gave Savoy and Nice, along with some lesser territories, to France.
  • It also provided France with supplies and munitions and the guarantee of safe passage through Piedmont for French troops.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

How did Napoleon begin to seize the treasures of Italy?

A
  • Indeed, tales of napoleon’s exploits persuaded the Pope and King of Naples to sign rapid treaties with the French.
  • This involved them paying indemnities (protection money) to avoid French conquest.
  • The seizing of artworks (as plunder or in treaties) became the norm as Napoleon’s armies swept across Italy, and later Europe.
  • Napoleon even established the first official military division dedicated to the seizure of cultural objects, with trained personnel to record, pack and ship art.
  • These acquisitions filled the Louvre and also added to the personal collections of officers and Napoleon himself.
  • The Treaty of Tolenine (June 1796) with the Pope provided innumerable artworks, Laocoon the Apollo Belvedere and Raphael’s Transfiguration.
  • The Pope also paid an indemnity of 21 million livres ($60million today) and 800,000 livres shipping costs ($2.3 million today).
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

Describe how Napoleon drove the Austrians out of Italy.

A
  • Napoleon went on to face the Austrians at Lodi in May.
  • Although this was essentially a fight with the Austrian rear-guard, Napoleon’s bravery well-publicised.
  • Milan occupied and its art treasures pillaged.
  • Napoleon continued his run of spectacular success as he advanced southwards into the ‘quadrilateral’ framed by Mantua, Peschiere, Verona and Legnago.
  • These 4 fortresses commanded the southern end of the Austrian supply line over the Brenner pass.
  • He captured three of them easily, but struggled to take Mantua.
  • The Austrians sent 4 successive armies against him as he besieged the city.
  • Showing his skill as a military tactician, Napoleon won victories at Arcola (November 1796), and Rivoli (January 1797), and Mantua fell.
  • By May 1797 Napoleon’s forces occupied Venice.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

How did Napoleon reorganise Italy politically?

A

• Napoleon dominated Italy and enjoyed creating a new French republic out of his conquests.
• Initially, in May 1796 after the Battle of Lodi, established 2 client states.
- The Cispadane Republic, south of the Po.
- The Transpadane Republic, north.
• Later, after further victories, these extended and merged to create the Cisapline Republic of June 1797.
• Capital in Milan, where he created a Directory, appointed ministers and set up a two-chamber legislature of his own nominees.
• Also established the Ligurian Republic in June 1797, based around Genoa in NW Italy.
• It too had a republican constitution and directory.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

How did Napoleon knock Austria out of the war?

A
  • Napoleon’s next step to advance into the Austrian Empire itself.
  • Took his armies as far as Leoben (within 96km of Vienna).
  • Here, in April 1797 and with tired men and dwindling supplies, he dictated terms to the Austrian CnC, Archduke Charles.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

What were the terms of Campo Formio?

A

• Terms formed the basis for the Treaty of Campo Formio of 17 October 1797.
• Negotiated by Napoleon without seeking the prior authority of the Directory.
• The final treaty, signed by Napoleon and Count Philipp von Cobenzl, representing the Austrian Monarchy, agreed…
1. Recognition of French control over former Austrian Netherlands (renamed Belgium after annexation in 1795).
2. Austrian acceptance of French Cisalpine and Ligurian Republics, in return for recognition of Austrian influence over parts of the Venetian Republic (divided between the two countries).
3. Recognition of the French Rhine Frontier (with provision for further congress to negotiate a peace for the HRE).
4. French possession of several islands in the Mediterranean and Venetian Islands in the Adriatic.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

Why was the Italian campaign so beneficial to Napoleon’s career?

A
  • Napoleon returned to Paris, where he formally presented his treaty, in triumph.
  • It reshaped the map of Europe to French design.
  • It also ended the War of the 1st Coalition, leaving only Britain to fight.
  • It marked a major step in Napoleon’s fame.
  • However, in practice it proved only a respite in the course of the wars.
  • No final peace between France and the HRE was reached.
  • The War of the 2nd Coalition broke out in 1799.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

Why were the Directors now nervous of Napoleon after the Italian campaign?

A
  • Napoleon’s ambitions frightened the Directors.
  • He had shown ability not only as a general but as a diplomat and state-maker.
  • His new client-republics giving him a taste of political leadership and law-making.
  • He was also steadily creating his own image with carefully worded press releases and propagandist reports which thrilled the public.
  • Furthermore, the only General to rival him, General Hoche, died in September 1797.
  • 27 year old Napoleon sufficiently confident to conduct his own foreign policy without directives from Paris.
  • Utterly convinced of his own powers of leadership.
  • Not only did he negotiate the acquisition of territory in Italy, in direct contradiction to the Directory’s policy, at Leoben.
  • He then went on to sign a peace treaty with the Emperor’s envoy in October without any reference to his political masters.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

How did Napoleon save the Directory during the coup of fructidor?

A
  • Furthermore, he again came to the rescue of the Directory during the Coup of Fructidor, sending Augereau and troops.
  • Such actions made Napoleon a hero within France and showed the power of the army in internal politics
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
24
Q

What new role did Napoleon receive and why did this planned invasion never come to pass?

A
  • In October 1797, Napoleon appointed to command an army to carry out an invasion of England.
  • However, Napoleon had good reason to shelve this enterprise.
  • Hoche’s attempts to invade Ireland to destabilise England in December 1796 had had to be abandoned.
  • Moreover, the strength of the British Navy made any seaborne invasion extremely difficult, particularly since the fleets of the French allies, Spain and the Batavian Republic (formerly United Provinces) had been defeated at Cape Saint Vincent (February), and Camperdown (October) in 1797.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
25
Q

What alternative plan of invasion did Napoleon then propose and why?

A

• Instead, he approached the Directory in early 1798, with a proposal for an invasion of Egypt.
• The proposed expedition offered some tempting prospects. It would…
1. Protect French Trade interests.
2. Attack British Commerce in the Eastern Mediterranean and possessions in India.
3. Undermine Britain’s access to India and the East Indies.
4. Distract the British Navy and make an invasion of England possible.
5. Establish a French presence in the Middle East.
6. This could allow a link-up with the French ally, Tipu Sultan, the ruler of Mysore in India.
7. Win easy success (the Mamluk rule being vulnerable due to internal dissension).
8. Export the Enlightenment to the Egyptians –‘walk in the footsteps of Alexander the Great’.

26
Q

Why did the Directory agree to the Egyptian plan?

A
  • The Directory agreed to the plan in March 1798.
  • Despite their concerns about its cost and scope.
  • They didn’t want to turn down the opportunity to send Napoleon far away from Paris.
  • Concerned he was too popular and overly-ambitious.
27
Q

How did Napoleon initially triumph in the campaign?

A
  • He set off in May 1798, in command of the ‘Army of the Orient’ with 35,000 troops.
  • Took Malta (from knights Hospitaller, enraging Russians) and though pursued by Nelson’s Naval squadron, managed to reach Egypt in July.
  • The French armies advanced through the desert from Alexandria, defeating the Egyptians in the Battle of the Pyramids, near Cairo, in July.
28
Q

How did the Egyptian campaign begin to fall apart for Napoleon?

A
  • However, simultaneously, Nelson cut off the French fleet at anchor in Aboukir Bay in August, cutting Napoleon off from France.
  • Nevertheless, Napoleon set about subduing the Egyptians, apparently unperturbed.
  • He behaved at times as an ‘absolute ruler’, though French faced repeated nationalist uprisings in addition to a British Naval Blockade.
  • Napoleon couldn’t fulfil his original intentions of moving on to Constantinople and India.
  • He did venture northwards into Syria with small force of 13,000.
  • He took Jaffa in March 1799, where he shot 2,000 prisoners.
  • Jaffa was Syria’s main mercantile centre and trading port.
  • Protected by high walls and towers.
  • As Bonaparte’s armies mounted a siege, it is said French messengers delivering ultimatum were tortured and castrated and their heads impaled on the city walls.
29
Q

How did Napoleon act brutally at the siege of Jaffa and why did his campaign in Palestine fail?

A
  • Whether as retaliation or out of vindictiveness when the city fell, Napoleon executed the Turkish Governor, shot prisoners and allowed his soldiers two days of slaughter and rape.
  • However, had to abandon a siege of Acre (Palestine) commanding the route between Egypt and Syria.
  • Despite surrounding the city in March, underestimated the resilience of the defenders and the ability of the British (under Sir Sydney Smith) to land men and guns to help the Turks there.
  • Napoleon retreated in May after two months, and returned to Cairo in June.
30
Q

Why did the War of the 2nd Coalition break out?

A
  • Between October 1797 and March 1799, following treaty of Campo Formio, peace.
  • However, Napoleon’s expulsion of the Knights of St John from Malta in 1798, en route to Egypt, infuriated Tsar Paul of Russia, the honourary head of the Order.
  • Austrians took advantage of Egyptian campaign to form 2nd coalition with Britain, Russia, the Ottoman Empire, Portugal and several of the german and Italian states (including the Papal States and Naples).
  • In 1799, these allies mounted several invasions, including Italy, Switzerland and an Anglo-Russia invasion of the Batavian Republic (the Netherlands).
31
Q

What was Napoleon’s reaction to the 2nd coalition?

A
  • In Egypt, Bonaparte received reports that Russians and Austrians had won victories in Italy and Germany, and were on France’s borders.
  • Keen to see action, probably sensing political opportunities, August 1799 he left Egypt.
  • Left bulk of army and evaded Nelson’s patrols, hurried to France with small group of men.
  • By time he arrived in October 1799, enemies had been repelled and Russians had withdrawn from the coalition.
32
Q

Why was Napoleon presented with a great political opportunity when he returned from Egypt?

A
  • However, the Directory was in a weak position and heavily discredited.
  • After the coups and purges of 1798-1799.
  • Scale of Napoleon’s failures in Egypt and Syria was, at this stage, still unknown.
  • Consequently, Napoleon once again greeted as a saviour, untainted by the politics of the last two years.
33
Q

Why did Napoleon begin to develop a reputation as a military genius throughout the late 1790s?

A
  • Rapidly established himself as an intelligent strategist, applying a high level of calculation to the winning of battles.
  • Tactics and strategies which he employed in Italy he would later refine to win his great battles of later years.
  • Speed and manoeuvrability key to his success.
  • He therefore improved army organisation in Italy, developing a self-contained and relatively small army corps of 10,000-30,000 men, each composed of infantry, artillery and cavalry.
  • This was different than most contemporary practice of using the traditional divisions of types of soldiers.
  • Not entirely original (Moreau also developed this), but Napoleon used it to particularly good effect.
  • Moved troops along different routes to deceive the enemy, ‘march divided, fight united’.
  • Furthermore, with cavalry and artillery allocated to each army corps, he kept reserve corps of both back under his own command.
  • This enabled him to decide when in a battle these could be best put to use (a ‘tactical reserve’).
34
Q

Why was the ‘forced march’ so vital for his tactics?

A
  • Coupled with this, Napoleon developed the idea of the ‘forced march’.
  • Used speed to take his men across large distances to surprise the enemy.
  • During the Italian campaign, Augereau’s corps marched 80 KM in 36 hours.
  • He also insisted that the troops ‘live off the land’ rather than wait for lumbering supply wagons.
  • This improved speed and enabled him to take superior battle positions and fragment the opposition (dividing Austrians and Piedmontese).
  • He liked to keep his enemies guessing, making misleading moves to place them in a weaker position, lure them into the open, or attack where/when least expected (often from rear).
  • Deployed tactics to good effect in repulsing the enemy and taking mantua.
35
Q

How did Napoleon’s personality as a general help improve the army and gain him political popularity?

A
  • Napoleon’s leadership also benefitted from his sheer force of personality.
  • Deliberately cultivated his men, speeches, bulletins.
  • Also by leading by example: travelling with his troops and at least appearing to share their privations.
  • Napoleon took pains to ensure his troops were well fed, paid and supplied.
  • He was respected for his charm and capacity for hard work: he was sometimes known to put in 18-20 hours a day.
  • This was important, given his young age when he took command of the army of Italy.
  • It has even been suggested that his recent marriage to Josephine supplied some of his drive: he was out to impress.
36
Q

How did Napoleon benefit from the officer corps underneath him?

A
  • Of course, Napoleon had the benefit of commanding officers promoted by talent, rather than the aristocratic generals of his enemies.
  • Also had soldiers fighting for a cause they believed in and were endlessly reminded of.
  • They could win promotions if they served well, unlike their adversaries.
  • Psychological effect of his early victories must have also helped motivation. While not undefeated, he genuinely seems to have inspired affection from the ranks and officers.
37
Q

What weaknesses did he show as a general?

A
  • He took risks that could have led to disaster.
  • Had little understanding of naval matters.
  • His ignorance of weather and climate meant he lost men needlessly in his Egyptian and Syrian campaigns.
38
Q

What was Napoleon’s character like?

A
  • Often described as a contradictory character.
  • Exhibited variety of personality traits.
  • This during a rapid rise to power, in a tumultuous time, at a very young age.
  • Through a career during which he had to command in war and in the state.
  • He had to deal with exhilarating highs and debilitating lows.
  • However we judge it, many of his responses (we need to understand) conditioned by times in which he lived.
  • Some of his less appealing traits were not unusual in those who exercised power at the time.
  • His personality also changed over the course of his life and career.
  • From 1795 to 1799, still a young man trying to establish and advance his career by winning fame and the notice of those who counted.
  • He then became a ruler, needing to promote himself and his country to win gloire.
  • Perhaps his greatest characteristic his ability to adapt to changing circumstance, responding to situations in different ways according to need, and exploiting whatever opportunities came his way.
39
Q

Why did Sieyés wish for a political change to the Directory in 1799?

A
  • Abbé Sieyés had never supported the 1795 constitution.
  • He had initially refused to serve in it.
  • However, when its failure to maintain its stability seemed to vindicate its views, he finally accepted a position as Director in May 1799.
  • He played a significant part in the coup of Prairial in June.
  • He called on the army to enforce changes of personnel.
  • Sieyés wanted to go further.
  • He felt that there had to be a change to the constitution to allow a strong government to emerge.
40
Q

How had Sieyes tried to engage army generals in a plot, prior to Napoleon?

A
  • He appears to have engaged in talks with General Jourdan to bring about a coup.
  • However, Jourdan killed at Novi in August 1799 as Austro-Russian forces attacked French in Piedmont.
  • Moreau approached, recommended Napoleon for the role!
  • Return of Napoleon from Egypt therefore appeared fortuitous.
41
Q

Why was the Directory so weak at the time by late 1799?

A
  • By then prospect of invasion had receded, pro-peace royalist faction gaining strength.
  • Ironically, both Jacobin and royalist sides though Napoleon a potential saviour.
  • Napoleon himself had his own ambitions.
  • Directory government very unpopular.
  • Commanded little authority, fears of a Jacobin resurgence and a royalist restoration led to instability.
  • Economy in poor shape, with soaring inflation, high taxation and widespread unemployment.
  • Bourgeoisie, who had profited from the early years of the revolution, desperately wanted internal security.
  • Directors in Autumn of 1799 were Paul Barras. He was regarded as corrupt, rumoured to be planning a royalist restoration. Moulin, a general and Barras’ protégé, Gohier, a lawyer of Jacobin views but intimate with Josephine Bonaparte. Abbé Sieyés, who had no faith in the constitution, and Roger Ducos, his protégé, who had only become a Director in June.
42
Q

How did they prepare for the Coup of Brumaire?

A
  • In preparation for a coup, Sieyés bribed council members.
  • On 23rd October, arranged for Napoleon’s brother, Lucien, to be elected as President of the Council of 500.
  • Troops were also deployed around Paris, ready for action.
43
Q

What was the plan of the coup?

A

• The plan was…

  1. To persuade the Directors to resign.
  2. To persuade the two councils to appoint a commission to draw a new constitution.
44
Q

How was the coup initiated?

A
  • On the morning of 18 Brumaire, members of council of ancients sympathetic to the coup warned their colleagues of a (supposed) Jacobin conspiracy.
  • With Lucien leading the Council of 500, both assemblies persuaded to leave the centre of Paris.
  • They went to the Palace of Saint-Cloud to the west, away from pro-jacobin mobs.
  • Napoleon promised to ensure the safety of the two councils, took command of Parisian Troops.
  • His trusted commander, Joachim Murat, moved 6,000 men into position around Saint-Cloud.
45
Q

Who was Murat?

A
  • Joachim Murat (1767-1815) a cavalry soldier who helped Napoleon suppress the Vendémiare Oct 1795 rising.
  • Served as Napoleon’s aide-de-camp in Italy and Egypt.
  • Supported coup of Brumaire, married Napoleon’s sister Caroline.
  • Fought at Marengo, made a marshal in 1804.
  • Distinguished himself at Austerlitz, Jena and Eylau.
  • Made Grand Duke of Berg and Cléves.
  • Acted as Napoleon’s lieutenant in Spain.
  • Made king of Naples in 1808.
  • Took part in the 1812 Russian campaign.
  • Led the Grand Armée in its retreat.
  • In 1813, failed to save kingdom of Naples from Austrians, fled to Corsica.
  • A further attempt to recover Naples virtually unaided failed in 1815, and he was killed.
46
Q

How did Sieyes, Ducos and Talleyrand help break the Directory?

A
  • The same morning Sieyés and Ducos resigned as Directors (in accordance with the plot).
  • Under pressure from Talleyrand (another plotter), Barras also persuaded to step down.
  • This virtually destroyed the Directory government.
  • Remaining Directors, Moulin and Gohier, put under house arrest.
47
Q

Who was Talleyrand?

A
  • Charles-Maurice Talleyrand Périgord, friend of Lucien Bonaparte, and Jospeh Fouché both involved in coup. Financed by the banker Jean-Pierre Collot.
  • Talleyrand given 2 million francs to bribe the corrupt Barras to resign if required.
  • In the event, he didn’t need to: and pocketed the cash.
48
Q

How did the Coup nearly fail horribly?

A
  • However, Councils continued to meet.
  • By 19 Brumaire (10 November) most deputies realised they had been duped.
  • They feared attempted coup by the army, not the Jacobins.
  • Napoleon (who mistakenly thought they would declare in his favour without force) lost patience and stormed into the Council of Ancients.
  • He was only accompanied by a small force of grenadiers.
  • As far as Sieyés was concerned, this ‘coup within the coup’ had not been planned.
  • Exactly what happened next has been told in various versions…
  • It would seem that Napoleon first went to the Council of Ancients.
  • Having failed to make much of an impression, he moved to the council of 500.
  • There, he was met with threats.
  • These may, or may not, have been violent.
49
Q

How did Lucien Bonaparte save the situation and how did the coup end?

A
  • Lucien Bonaparte saved the situation by getting the palace guards to intervene (probably suggesting that some deputies were trying to assassinate Napoleon).
  • As the guards moved into the hall, many deputies left (some even jumped out of windows).
  • When Murat’s Grenadiers marched in, the remaining deputies were forcibly expelled from the chamber.
  • Lucien managed to find a few deputies from the Council of Ancients (rumour had it they were hiding in the park).
  • They were prepared to obey his orders and appoint three Consuls to run the government until a new constitution could be prepared.
  • The government of the Directory thus came to an end.
50
Q

How did Napoleon develop a position of dominance early on?

A
  • Of the three Consuls – Ducos, Sieyés and Napoleon – there was little doubt who was in charge.
  • Sieyés had totally underestimated Bonaparte, believing him a pawn.
  • In practice, this would prove untrue.
51
Q

How did Napoleon manipulate the process of the 1799 constitution?

A
  • Sieyés mounted the coup to establish an executive, to supply strong leadership.
  • Much of the work for the constitution which followed conducted by Sieyés.
  • Napoleon’s friend, Pierre Daunou, a former Girondin, also played a part.
  • By balancing the ideas of both, Napoleon ensured a constitution that served his ambition.
  • It was adopted on 24 December 1799.
  • It became known as the constitution of Year VIII.
  • This constitution, although subsequently modified, became basis for French Consulate of 1799-1804.
52
Q

What powers did the First Consul have in the Constitution of Year VIII?

A
  • Shared executive power with two others.
  • All held office for ten years.
  • Appointed ministers.
  • Acted as director of policy and initiator of all legislation.
53
Q

What powers did the Council of State have in the Constitution of Year VIII?

A
  • Chosen by the 1st Consul.
  • Acted as an advisory body.
  • Nominated officials and prepared draft legislation.
54
Q

What powers did the Senate have in the Constitution of Year VIII?

A
  • Comprised 80 members nominated by the First Consul.
  • Appointed for life.
  • Duty to ‘protect the constitution’: advised first consul on draft legislation.
  • Selected deputies for the two bodies of the legislature (Tribunate and legislative body).
  • Could override decisions made by the legislature through senatus consultum.
55
Q

What powers did the Tribunate have in the Constitution of Year VIII?

A
  • The lowest chamber of the legislature.
  • Comprised 100 members.
  • Would discuss legislation but not vote.
56
Q

What powers did the Upper Chamber have in the Constitution of Year VIII?

A
  • Comprised 300 members.

* Would vote on legislation, but not discuss it.

57
Q

Explain the 4 stages of voting that the Constitution of the Year VIII/1799 laid out?

A

1st Stage:
• All Frenchmen over 21 (6 million citizens).
• Required to have lived in same house for one year.
• Voted for 10% of themselves to form a communal list.

2nd Stage:
• 600,000 citizens (communal list).
• Members selected 10% of themselves to form a departmental list.
3rd Stage:
• 60,000 citizens (departmental list).
• Members selected of 10% of themselves to form the notables.
6000 Notables
• The Senate selected deputies to form the legislature from these notables.

58
Q

How did Napoleon prevent Sieyés from becoming the head of state and instead make himself dominant?

A
  • Napoleon vetoed Sieyés’ original idea of having a single ‘Grand Elector’ as supreme executive and head of state.
  • Sieyés had intended to take this position himself.
  • Napoleon had other ideas.
  • Sieyés also favoured a system with two consuls, each with separate powers, one exclusively with internal affairs, one for external matters.
  • His idea had been for Bonaparte to take the latter role.
  • However, Napoleon insisted that there needed to be a ‘First Consul’.
  • Needed to act as head of state, and that two others should have an advisory role
  • NOT equal consulships.
  • Napoleon did not, however, object to Sieyés insistence on the establishment of a Senate to ‘protect’ the constitution.
  • He soon found a way to use this to his own advantage.
59
Q

What were the strengths of the Constitution?

A
  • The new constitution vested great power in the First Consul.
  • He would appoint and dismiss ministers.
  • He would make legislative proposals and control foreign policy.
  • Sieyés, disappointed with the outcome of his work, chose to step aside.
  • He, together with Ducos, entered the new senate.
  • The two replacement Consuls, found in December 1799 to work alongside Bonaparte, were Jean-Jacques Régis de Cambacérés (appointed Second Consul thanks to his legal knowledge and reputation as a moderate republican) and Charles-Francois Lebrun, a man of royalist sentiment who was made Third Consul.
  • Both were intensely loyal to Napoleon.
  • The constitution provided for strong ‘top-down’ control.
  • This, to some extent, is what Sieyés had sought.
  • It was the first constitution of the revolutionary period not to be accompanied by a declaration of rights.
  • Whilst it gave the vote to all adult males, this was diluted through various electoral rounds.
60
Q

What were the weaknesses of the Constitution?

A
  • From a total electorate of approximately 6 million, only 6,000 ultimately eligible to serve in the legislature of 400.
  • This legislature, in any case, had no right to initiate legislation.
  • The constitution was undoubtedly complex.
  • 1/5th of the members of the two bodies of the legislature were to be replaced annually.
  • No clear provision made as to how those who would step down would be replaced.
  • This, together with the provision for adding to the number of senators annually, gave plenty of scope for the First Consul to intervene.
  • The decree of Senatus Consultum also offered the First Consul a way of by-passing opposition in the legislative body.
  • Moreover, his right to choose members of the council of state ensured that his legislative directions were regarded favourably.
61
Q

What was the wider reaction to the coup of Brumaire?

A
  • News of the coup greeted with apathy more than enthusiasm on streets of Paris.
  • Some outright opposition from the Jacobins in the provinces.
  • The constitutional arrangements clearly worked to Napoleon’s advantage.
  • However, in midst of economic crisis and general insecurity, there was undoubted anxiety from ruler and ruled to what 1800 would bring.
  • Some see the 1799 coup as the end of the revolution.
  • Napoleon always claimed he was ‘the heir to the revolution’ and that he set out to fulfil its principles.