JL Ch. 5- Child Endangerment Flashcards
Reckless Endangerment to Child:
Elements: (2)
The suspect must have
- Action: Recklessly engaged in conduct that created a substantial risk of serious bodily injury, or sexual abuse to a child under the age of 18
OR
- Inaction: Recklessly failed to take reasonable steps to prevent a substantial risk of serious bodily injury, or sexual abuse, to a child under 18- provided that the suspect had a legal duty to act on behalf of the child.
The suspect must have
- Action: Recklessly engaged in conduct that created a substantial risk of serious bodily injury, or sexual abuse to a child under the age of 18
OR
- Inaction: Recklessly failed to take reasonable steps to prevent a substantial risk of serious bodily injury, or sexual abuse, to a child under 18- provided that the suspect had a legal duty to act on behalf of the child.
Reckless Endangerment To Child Ch. 265 sec 13L.
ROA: Complaint
Reckless Endangerment to a Child:
ROA:
Arrest for breach of peace. Otherwise, Complaint.
Note: This crime often occurs in conjunction with other arrestable offenses involving domestic violence, sexual assault, etc.
In almost all situations where this crime applies, officers should file a 51A.
Moreover, it may be necessary for DCF to initiate a Care & Protection.
Reckless Endangerment to Child:
Age of the child:
Under the age of 18.
Reckless Endangerment to a Child can be committed in two ways. What is the 1st?
- Action: Recklessly engaged in conduct that created a substantial risk of serious bodily injury, or sexual abuse to a child under the age of 18
Reckless Endangerment to a Child can be committed in two ways. What is the 2nd?
- Inaction: Recklessly failed to take reasonable steps to prevent a substantial risk of serious bodily injury, or sexual abuse, to a child under 18- provided that the suspect had a legal duty to act on behalf of the child.
*Remember, the failure to act may only be the basis for this crime when the suspect has a legal duty to protect the child (parent, teacher, babysitter, camp counselor, etc.)
(Blank) occurs when a person consciously disregards a substantial and unjustifiable risk that his acts or failure to act will result in serious bodily injury or sexual abuse to a child under 18. Disregarding the risk must be a “gross deviation” from reasonable conduct.
Reckless Behavior.
Reckless Endangerment to Child
The failure to act may only be the basis for this crime when the suspect:
has a legal duty to protect the child (parent, teacher, babysitter, camp counselor, etc.)
(blank) results in permanent disfigurement, protracted loss or impairment of a bodily function, limb, or organ, or substantial risk of death.
Serious bodily injury
Sexual abuse encompasses: (7 charges):
- Indecent A&B on a Child under 14
- Indecent A&B on a person 14 or Over
- Rape
- Forcible Rape of a Child under 16
- Statutory Rape
- Assault with intent to Rape
- Assault of a Child with intent to Rape
Operation of a motor vehicle MAY be child endangerment:
2 examples (1 of each)
Yes- Leading police on a wild chase
No- Unsecure in child seat (based on the example in the book)
The defendant was involved in a multi vehicle accident in which her two nephews- 4 year old Dylan and 16 month old Jayce- died. The defendant and her four year old son were seriously injured. At the time of the accident, Dylan was on the rear middle seat of the defendant’s 4 door sedan with a seat belt on but not a proper child safety seat. Jayce was in the rear passenger area in a front-facing seat with the straps set too high. He should have been secured in a rear facing seat.
Did this constitute Reckless Endangerment of a Child?
No.
The SJC acknowledged this terrible tragedy, but felt that the failure to properly restrain a child, while negligent, did not amount to the type of reckless behavior required for the crime of endangerment. To be reckless, an offender must consciously disregard an obvious risk of serious injury or death.
John Soares was living with Miriam Oliveira and their 10 month old son. Soares was angry that the baby began crying while he was trying to nap. He pinched the baby’s feet and hit him in the head to make him stop. He then threw the child against the wall. When Oliviera pick the baby up, Coares threw a chair against the wall, breaking it into pieces.
Which act by Oliveira constituted Reckless endangerment to the child?
Throwing the chair was reckless endangerment: the chair was medium weight and was thrown with enough force to break it into pieces. Oliveira, who was holding the baby, had to move away from it’s falling piece.
While the child’s mother was holding the one year old, the defendant punched her in the face.
By punching his wife, what are the two ways the defendant risked endangerment to the child?
- He could have struck the baby
- His wife could have dropped the baby
A father is shitfaced and walking on the railroad tracks with his 11 year old son:
Was this child endangerment?
Yes.
Father exposed his son to a risk that no reasonable person would permit. Walking on a trailroad track creates a substantial risk of bodily injury. The father exacerbated this risk by being so intoxicated that he fell down. Had a train approached, the son would have risked his life trying to move his father to safety.
10 month old child died after his foster parents failed to seek medical treatment for him. The symptoms persisted for over two weeks. Foster parents were aware of his condition. They were also aware that as foster parents they could seek medical treatment for him at no cost to them. Based on security footage in the house, the child can be seen gasping for air as the foster father puts another child to bed in the same room. 10 month died an hour later.
Was this Reckless Endangerment to Child?
Yes.
the foster parents knew, or reasonably should have known, the child was at risk of substantial harm without medical treatment. They had a duty to act, but failed to do so.
**Note: the foster parents were also properly charged with involuntary manslaugter
Not providing timely or proper medical care to a child may be:
Reckless Endangerment to Child (under 18).
Reckless Endangerment to Child:
Examples:
Was leaving hot curling iron in a place 3.5 year old child could reach it, while knowing the child like to play with the straightener, reckless endangerment of a child?
Yes.
foster mother also did not take child to the hospital immediately after the burn incident, but instead waited for foster father to discover the injuries 8 to 24 hours later.
True or false:
The fact that another person has legal custody of the child does not absolve other caretakers of criminal liability for their actions in relation to the child.
True.
Other persons may also have a duty to prevent harm to a child.
ex. grandmother refuses to drive teenage daughter and baby with a skull fracture to the hospital, in order to prevent mothers boyfriend from getting in trouble, because he had dropped the baby.
May drunken or drugged behavior in front of children amount to Reckless Endangerment of Child?
Yes.
ex. father passed out in his car after taking painkillers and drinking booze. His children- 5, 3, and 8 months- were left unsupervised. Next to him int he car, was a loaded, cocked gun. Surely their father’s presence in the car could have easily drawn the children to find the gun. The empty beer cans and bottle of liquor in his car showed he spent a substantial amount of time drinking there.
Can permitting children to consume alcohol or drugs (including marijuana) amount to Reckless Endangerment of Child?
Yes.
Ex. parents drinking with children at an underage party. One of the guests becomes extremely ill. the next morning, mother injects this girl with “medicine” she took from her job at a nursing home. Father acknowledged that his wife had made a mistake, and said he would lie to police to cover it up- Both parents properly charged with Reckless Endangerment to Child; Mother also charged with ABDW for administering the syringe of “medicine”.
Reckless endangerment to child:
Was overwhelming marijuana smoke, that caused an officer to get lightheaded, in an apartment with small children Reckless Endangerment to child?
Yes.
EMS was called to transport the children to the hospital to be evaluated for marijuana exposure.
The potential harm to these children constituted reckless endangerment.
Is Drug distribution in a home, by itself, Reckless endangerment of child?
NO. Ex. father was the leader of a drug distribution organization. Children were present on a number of occasions where an undercover bought heroin in the home, and saw heroin being packaged by adults in the home.
Still, no evidence the father or anyone else possessed a gun or dangerous weapon in the home, or that any violence occurred there, or that drugs were left unattended in reach of children.
The endangerment law does not criminalize everything that creates a risk to children. It does not evebn criminalize the use of a child to aid in the distribution of drugs absent a substantial risk of physical or sexual harm to the child (although Inducing a Minor to Distribute Drugs would apply)
Possessing drug paraphernalie is NOT, by itself, endangerment. The child must be able to:
reach the paraphernalia.
ex. presence of bloody used needles in a diaper bag was not endangerment because 11 month old baby was strapped into a car seat and not close enough to the bag to reach it.
Presence of drugs and potential access by child must be (blank and blank) for endangerment.
known, and disregarded
Ex. child found one suboxone tablet in fathers car- child was being supervised, and father promptly brought child to the fire station- NO endangerment
Compare ex. mother kept unsecured prescription drugs in a drawer where she knew her daughters would likely find them. Daughters had gained access to the drawer multiple times while they were alone= This was Reckless Endangerment
Leaving child alone briefly is not typically endangerment. But what is?
Failing to search after the child wanders away.
Mother left child alone in front of the TV. This was not endangerment, even though the child had previously wandered from the home. After the first incident, the family had installed a deadbolt (which had been left open by their teenage son )
Mothers conduct after she discovered the child missing DID amount to endangerment: she onlt searched 10 minutes, did not call police, and had no immediate plans to continue searching. Mother failed to take reasonable steps to alleviate a substantial risk of serious bodily injury to the child.
True or false:
In all cases, be sure to correctly charge endangerment.
True.
ex. husband and wife adopted 2 children, 10 and 8. On regular basis,husband touched the 8 year old, penetrated her vagina and anus, and made her touch his penis. Wife was charged with Reckless endangerment (Inaction). Unfortunately, the indictment stated that she had recklessly exposed the 8 year old to “substantial bodily injury” instead of “sexual abuse”. Because there was no evidence of serious bodily injury in this case, the wife had to be acquitted of the improperly drafted charge.
A&B on a Child with Substantial Injury and Reckless endangerment of a Child are:
2 separate charges.
A&B on a child with substantial bodily injury is distinct from reckless endangerment of a child. A defendant may be charged with both since each offense requires proof of an additional element that the other does not.
Ex. defendant hit child with a belt and caused serious injuries to the child’s anus that required surgery. At the same time, child endangerment occurred because the defendant purposely disregarded the risk of injury when he used a belt in this manner. While actual injury is not required to prove child endangerment, the presence of and injury does not eliminate this charge either.
True of False?
Police departments may not disseminate information until SORB classifies an offender after a hearing.
True.
What is the purpose of the Sex Offender Registry Board?
to counteract the danger of recidivism posed by sex offenders.
Sex Offender (SO): A person who resides, works , or attends and institution of higher learning in Massachusetts, and who has been: (3)
- convicted, or adjudicated delinquent, of a sex offense; or
- Released from incarceration, parole, probation, or DYS; or
- Adjudicated a sexually dangerous person
- Sex offender classification must be by clear and convincing evidence
What is the standard of evidence for sex offender classification?
Clear and convincing evidence.
(which means 75% certainty)
A person who has been convicted or adjudicated of a sexually violent offense AND suffers from a mental abnormality making the person likely to engage in sexual violence.
Sexually Violent Predator:
Sexually Violent Predator:
A person who has been convicted or adjudicated of a sexually violent offense AND suffers from a mental abnormality making the person likely to engage in sexual violence.
Sexually Violent Predator:
A person who has been convicted or adjudicated of a sexually violent offense AND suffers from a (blank) making the person likely to engage in sexual violence.
mental abnormality
Is knowledge an element of: Failure to Register; Failure to verify his registration information; Fail to provide notice of change of address; Provide false information?
Yes.
“An SO must knowingly…”
Sex Offender Registration Offenses:
Sex Offender must knowingly: (4)
- Fail to register
- Fail to verify his registration information
- Fail to provide notice of change of address (home, employment, institution of higher education
- Provide false information.
Arrest on Probable Cause
Is there a statute that says an officer may arrest a sex offender on probable cause for ANY violation of the sex offender law?
Yes.
Although they are mostly (not all) felonies anyway, statue provides this authority on probable cause for any sex offender law violation.
Misuse of Registry Information:
Information from the SO registry shall not be used to commit a crime against a sex offender, or to engage in:
illegal discrimination or harassment.
-misdemeanor
Any person placed on probation for a sex offense listed in 178C must:
wear a GPS device for the length of his probation.
*This requirement does not extend to defendants whose cases are continued without a finding.
Any person placed on probation for a sex offense listed in 178C mustwear a GPS device for the length of his probation.
This requirement does not extend to:
defendants whose cases are continued without a finding.
True or false:
Criminal Parole Supervision for Life is unconstitutional because it improperly gives the parole board judicial powers to impose sentences.
True.
Sex offender Registration Offenses:
Fail to register;
Fail to verify his registration information;
Fail to provide notice of his change of address; or
Provide false information
ROA:
All felonies.
Sex Offender Operating an Ice Cream Truck:
What levels of sex offender does this apply to?
1, 2, and 3.
All 3 levels.
Arrest on PC.
Sex offender registration offenses:
ROA:
“Whenever a police officer has probable cause to believe that a sex offender has failed to comply with ANY registration requirements, the officer shall have the right to arrest the SO without a warrant and the keep the SO in custody”
also these are felonies anyway
Misuse of registry information:
ROA:
Complaint
(unless breach of peace in presence)
Sex offender operating ice cream truck:
ROA:
Arrest on Probable Cause.
Sex Offender Registration violations:
Venue:
Violations may be prosecuted in any county where the sex offender knowingly:
- Failed to register
- Failed to verify registration
- Failed to provide notice of a change of address; or
- Provided false information
Ex. defendant moved from
Barnstable to Yarmouth and failed to appear in either place to verify his registration data; Barnstable police had authority to arrest him even though he no longer lived there.
Sex Offender Registration Duties:
All information is sent to the:
SORB
From outside Massachusetts:
SO from outside of Massachusetts shall:
Register by mail within (blank) days of moving into the Commonwealth.
2 days.
Sex Offender Registration Duties:
An incarcerated SO must register (blank) days before release.
2 days.
From outside Massachusetts:
SO from outside of Massachusetts shall:
Notify the board within (blank) days of beginning employment here.
2 days.
From outside Massachusetts:
SO from outside of Massachusetts shall:
Register by mail within (blank) days of attending or transferring to an institution of higher learning within Massachusetts.
2 days.