Reasoning About Design & Execution of Research Flashcards
The Scientific Method
[8]
- Generate a testable question
- Gather data and resources
- Form a hypothesis
- Collect new data
- Analyze the data
- Interpret the data and existing hypothesis
- Publish
- Verify results
FINER Method of Evaluating A Research Question
- Feasible?
- Interesting?
- Novel?
- Ethical?
- Relevant?
FINER Method of Evaluating A Research Question
- Feasible?
- Interesting?
- Novel?
- Ethical?
- Relevant?
What is a control (standard)?
Conditions that can be applied to act as a method of verifying results
What is a control (standard)?
Conditions that can be applied to act as a method of verifying results; used to correct for any influences of an intervention that are not part of an experimental model
Positive Control
Ensure that a change in the dependent variable occurs when expected
Negative Control
Ensure that no change in the dependent variable occurs when none is expected
Negative Control
Ensure that no change in the dependent variable occurs when none is expected
Placebo Effect
An observed or reported change when an individual is given a sham intervention
Placebo Effect
An observed or reported change when an individual is given a sham intervention
Independent Variable
The part of the experiment that is being purposefully manipulated; plotted on the x-axis
Dependent Variable
The part of the experiment that is being observed; plotted on the y-axis
Casual Relationship
[If-then Relationship]
When there is a theoretical or known mechanism that links the independent and dependent variables
Explain a causal relationship.
If the change in the independent variable always precedes the change in the dependent variable AND the change in the dependent variable does not occur in the absence of the experimental intervention.
Explain a causal relationship.
If the change in the independent variable always precedes the change in the dependent variable AND the change in the dependent variable does not occur in the absence of the experimental intervention.
Accuracy (Validity)
Quality of approximating the true value
Precision (Reliability)
Quality of being consistent in approximation
Why are causal relationships harder to prove in human subject research?
Causal conclusions are harder to determine because circumstances are harder to control
Why are causal relationships harder to prove in human subject research?
Causal conclusions are harder to determine because circumstances are harder to control
Types of Human Subject Research
Experimental and Observational Studies
Types of Human Subject Research
Experimental and Observational Studies
Randomization
Used to control for differences between subject groups; controls whether a subject is placed into a control group or treatment group
Randomization
Used to control for differences between subject groups; controls whether a subject is placed into a control group or treatment group
Blinding
Subject and/or Investigators do not have information about which group the subject is a part of in order to remove bias
Blinding
Subject and/or Investigators do not have information about which group the subject is a part of in order to remove bias
Single-Blind Experiments
Only the patient or the assessor is blinded
Double-Blind Experiments
The investigator, subject and assessor all do not know the subject’s group
Double-Blind Experiments
The investigator, subject and assessor all do not know the subject’s group
Types of Observational Studies
Cohort
Cross-Sectional
Case-Control
Types of Observational Studies
Cohort
Cross-Sectional
Case-Control
[Look for connections between exposures and outcomes]
Cohort Studies
Subjects are sorted into two groups based on differences in risk factors
Cohort Studies
Subjects are sorted into two groups based on differences in risk factors (exposure) and then assessed at various intervals to determine how many subjects in each group had a certain outcome
Cohort Studies
Subjects are sorted into two groups based on differences in risk factors (exposure) and then assessed at various intervals to determine how many subjects in each group had a certain outcome
Cross-Sectional Studies
Attempt to categorize patients in different groups at a single point in time
Case-Control Studies
Identifies the number of subjects with or without a particular outcome and then look backwards to assess how many subjects in each group had exposure to a particular risk factor
Hill’s Criteria
The components of an observed relationship that increase the likelihood of causality in the relationship;
The more criteria that are satisfied, the likelier it is that the relationship is causal
List of Hill’s Criteria
- Temporality
- Strength
- Dose-Response Relationship
- Consistency
- Plausibility
- Consideration of Alternate Explanations
- Experiment
- Specificity
- Coherence