Arch. Final Section VI Flashcards
issues in Archaelogy and politics (2) (WW)
1) who has the right to interpret the past?
2) who owns the material remains of the past?
what did the case study of who owns the past include (2) (NR)
1) Native rights in N. America
2) Repatriation
is Repatriation simple or complicated?
very complicated
federally funded legal process for returning cultural items to native groups
NAGPRA (Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act of 1990)
what items were protected under NAGPRA? (2) (HS)
1) Human remains
2) sacred object
what does NAGPRA balance?
Scholarly concerns with ethical treatment of living descendents.
what does NAGPRA apply to
existing museum collections (before 1990)
how did museums comply with NAGPRA?
must catalouge items and contact possible living heirs
what did NAGRPA protect in museums?
1) Human Remains: 40,000
2) Associated funerary objects: 1 million
3) other sacred objects: 6000
What is NAGPRA applied to?
newly discovered remains (after 1990)
what type of newly discovered remains are found?
both “inadvertent” and “planned”
what does newly discovered remains require?
consultation with native groups
what does NAGPRA allow for?
short time for analysis
according to NAGPRA if remains are determined to be American Indian what can happen?
analysis can occur only with documented tribal consent.
problems with NAGRPA
1) only applies to public land
2) defines remains as “Native American” if can be related to a culture that IS indigineous to the US (not WAS)
what is an example of NAGPRA?
Kennewick Man
what is Kennewick man?
a skeleton discovered in Kennewick, WA in 1996
according to C14 dating how old was Kennewick man?
8400 years old
what did 5 tribes claim to be to the Kennewick man?
an ancestor, but it was disputed by researchers
when did the Kennewick man case go to court?
a 2002 ruling
what did the ruling of the Kennewick man conclude?
doesn’t qualify because of his age; permits analysis
what did the skeletal anaylsis show about the Kennewick man?
that he was unlike modern Native Americans
what did the DNA of the Kennewick man show?
Ainu SE Asia (old world pop)
what were issues with the Kennewick man? (2) (SG)
1) Should cultural value outweigh scientific value?
2) Given his age, is he Native American/indigenous?
How can archaeological remains and interpretations impact politics and vice versa?
1) Destruction of cultural heritage as an act of war
2) archaeological remains used to justify war with conquest
how did Nazi Germany show use of Archaeology and politics?
Archaeology to justify racism and political expansion