Sept 23 Flashcards
time horizon in studies
how many times data are collected from the same participants for the same variables of interest
cross sectional time horizon
one off measurement
or measurements at multiple times, but diff variables
longitudinal time horizon
multiple surveys of same participant for same variable
same sample and same variable of interest
cross sectional design benefits
- compare cohorts of DIFF AGES to one another at a GIVEN TIME
- relatively CHEAP and PRACTICAL
cross sectional design drawbacks
- can’t learn about how INDIVIDUAL PEOPLE CHANGE with age (effects are BETWEEN-PERSON)
- age effects are confounded with cohort effects
cross sectional designs can only elucidate _________-person effects
between-person
can’t learn about how individual people change with age
what effects are confounded in cross sectional designs?
age effects and cohort effects
can we conclude from a cross sectional design that discrimination increases across time?
no
because we didn’t measure the passage of time
longitudinal design benefits
- can make WITHIN-SUBJECTS COMPARISONS
- no cohort effects
longitudinal design drawbacks
- subjects drop out
- may be effects of repeated testing
- requires foresight (and funding!)
- time consuming
- age effects confounded with time measurement effects
what effects are confounded in longitudinal designs?
age effects are confounded with time of measurement effects
longitudinal designs can make _________-subjects comparisons
WITHIN-subjects
because real change over time is being examined
are there cohort effects in longitudinal designs?
no
because we’re only looking at one cohort (everyone being sampled is the same age)
weaknesses of both cross-sectional and longitudinal designs
- often RETROSPECTIVE report
- recall bias
- recency bias - snapshot or long-term follow ups DON’T SHOW us what’s happening in the DAY TO DAY
- how do I feel now, right after facing discrimination today?
- do effects linger?
- do effects not show up until tmrw?
recall bias
ie. if asked how you’ve been feeling over the past 4 months, will have more trouble remembering 4 weeks ago than 4 days ago
ability to accurately recall over a time window makes responses less accurate
recency bias
we might be more likely to report on how we’ve been feeling recently
what can overcome the 2 commonly shared issues of longitudinal and cross sectional designs?
experience sampling measures (ESM)
experience sampling
measure people repeatedly across short time span
ie. everyday for 21 days
reduces retrospective and other biases
intra-individual change
ESM: types of sampling
- fixed time sampling
- but Ps may adapt daily habits to fit around sampling
- results in behaviour change - random time sampling
- lowers reactivity and behaviour adjustment - event sampling
- good for events like smoking a cig or interacting with a child
ESM: 3 types of Qs we can answer
- “on days when I face more discrimination than I normally do in a 2 week period, do I report more negative affect and less positive affect?”
- do those effects last?
- how long do they last? - “do people seek more support from friends and parents on days when they face discrimination?”
- “do I report more discrimination on days I’m more aware of my racial or gender identity?”
what are the 2 most commonly reported daily instance of discrimination? (when measured by daily diary studies)
- weight
- gender