Medical ethics Flashcards
What is consequentialism?
The moral worth of an action is determined by its outcome
What is deontology?
Duties, “right + wrong” actions, absolute values
What is Utilitarianism?
Look at benefits and harms to individuals + society as a whole
Looks at consequences
What are the duties of a doctor?
Make care of patient first concern
Respect right of patients to be involved in care
Reconise limits of own professional competence
Act quickly to protect patients from risk if you have reason to believe you or another may cause harm/be unfit to practice
Avoid abusing position
Be honest & trustworthy
Listen & treat equally
Protect confidential information
What are the four principals of medicine?
Respect for autonomy
Non-malfeasance
Beneficence
Justice
What is autonomy?
medicine of self-determination
Confidentiality
Informed consent
Promote capacity
What is non-malfeasance?
Avoidance of harm
What is beneficence?
To do good
What is justice?
Fairness/equity
Individual vs population
Recognise give one person super drug or 1000 people normal drug
What is consent?
Any adult with sound mind has absolute right to determine what is done with their own body
Doctor performing surgery without consent is commiting assault or battery
Patient must be given enough information to come to a decision whether they wish treatment to be carried out
What does a negligence claim require?
Causation with forseeable damange
The burden of proof on claimant
Requires failure of duty
What does a lack of consent claim require?
Failure to gain consent - requires burden of proof on claimant plus demonsatrion of valid process by defendant
Does not need causation
Does not matter if correct procedure/carried out correctly
What are the prinicapls of the mental capacity act (england)
People assumed to have capacity until prooved otherwise
Only treated as unable to make a decision if all steps have been taken without success
People not to be treated as unable to make decisions if they make unwise decisions
Any decisions under act must be done in their best interest
What is the process for gaining consent?
Adjudge competency if any doubt
Must give patient sufficient information in a language they understand so they can come to a rational decision
Do not have to give so much information they would not have treatment
Must obtain consent for treatment AND delivery method
How do you judge competency?
Need evidence that patient can undeerstand both the information given and the consequences it heralds
Evidence that they can make reasonable choices based on rationality (not randomness)
Under the Scottish adults with incapacity act, when will there be intervention?
When the person responislbe is satisfied that the intervention will benefit the adult
AND cannot be reasonably achieved without that intervention
Must be least restrictive
Whos views should be taken into account in an adult with incapacity?
Past/present wished of adult
Nearest family members + primary adult
Any guardian/legal representative
What is the function of the mental welfare commission?
Exercising protective function in respect of adult
Visit adult and bring attention to relative authorities
Whar is Gillick (fraser) competency?
That children can consent as long as they can show the maturity and intelligence to understand the nature of treatment, options, risks involved and benefits
Parents cannot overrule this
What is professionalism?
A set of values, behaviours and relationships that underpins the trust the public has in doctors
What are the five times you can break confidentiality?
Consent and patients Court order Statutory obligation Public interest Best interest
What is public interest disclosure?
If you think that not disclosing information would lead individuals or society to a risk so serious that it outweighs patient + public interest in confidentiality
You should tell patient first if it’s practical and safe to do so
What are the problems with social media?
Confidentiality Denigration Defamation Crime Pt making negative comments of facebook
What are the roles of the GMC?
Setting standards for doctors
Overseeing doctors education/training
Managing the UK medical register
Investigating and acting on concerns about doctors
Helping to raise standards through revalidation