History vs. Hollywood - Unit 1 Test Flashcards
Film as a reflection of society
Learning focus:
Visual media such as film and television, have the power to influence people in many different ways.
Films have the power to influence society
On a surface level,
..films have influenced fashion and catchphrases
Ie. Breakfast at Tiffany’s, 7 Year Itch, Saturday Night Fever, Clueless, Friends
Films have the power to influence society
This also means that …
film has the power to influence how we view people
Ie. Indigenous Stereotypes
Noble Savage
In literature and film, the noble savage is an idealized concept of an uncivilized man, who symbolizes the innate goodness of one not exposed to the corrupting influences of civilization.
The Noble Savage was a dominant theme of the 18th and 19th centuries when colonialism was at its height.
The Ecological Indian
Ecological Indian is a stereotype often applied to Indigenous cultures as being idealistic and living in perfect harmony with nature, having a genetic disposition to mystical ecological knowledge, and feeling remorse for the necessities of life such as hunting due to a spiritual Interconnectivity of all things.
Today, we understand Indigenous knowledge relationships to the land and environment better as being shared through story, tradition, and spiritual practice as traditional ecological knowledge.
There are 5 common types of Indigenous Stereotypes in film and television
- Beautiful Maidens
- Stoic Indians
- Medicine Men
- Bloodthirsty Warriors
- Wild and on the Rez
- Beautiful Maidens
ie. Pochahontas
Beautiful Maidens
How might the way Indigenous women are depicted in these clips impact the way in which non-Indigenous peoples perceive Indigenous peoples?
Non-indigenous people may get the impression that indigenous women freely live outdoors like “savages” and are always dressed that way and appear provocative to European settlers
How might they impact the way in which Indigenous peoples perceive themselves and how society views them?
Society as a whole may believe that Indigenous peoples are always dressed are such and “forage” for food and etc, in the wild
Indigenous people may struggle to grapple with the dissonance between their own perceptions (regular human beings who do live in homes etc) and how society views them
Potentially leading to Indigenous people feeling disconnected from who they are “supposed” to be
- Stoic Indians
Unsmiling Indigenous peoples who speak few words can be found in classical cinema as well as in cinema of the 21st century.
This representation of Indigenous tribal members paints them as one-dimensional people who lack the ability to experience or display a similar range of emotions as other racial groups.
- Medicine Men
Indigenous males are often portrayed in film and television shows as wise men with magical powers. Usually performing as medicine men of some kind, these characters have little function other than to guide White characters in the right direction.
- Bloodthirsty Warriors
Hollywood has traditionally portrayed Indigenous peoples as tomahawk-wielding savages, ready to attack White characters and their families. These problematic representations also often have Indigenous characters engage in barbaric practices such as scalping people they have killed and sexually violating White women.
- Wild and on the Rez
In Hollywood films, Indigenous peoples are typically portrayed as living in the wilderness and on reservations. In reality, considerable numbers of tribal members peoples live off reservations, including major cities and just about everywhere else across Canada and around the globe.
What is authentic representation?
Like what we talked about with other misrepresentations in film and television, authentic representation involves people from the culture - actors, directors and writers who know and are a part of the filmmaking process.
The lack of gender and racial diversity in Hollywood, as highlighted by zero female director nominations at the 2020 Oscars and the dominance of white male perspectives, contributes to …
societal inequalities by perpetuating stereotypes and limiting representation.
This imbalance not only affects how women and minorities perceive themselves but also influences …
broader societal attitudes and behaviours.
Efforts to address these inequities include promoting inclusion riders, implementing policy solutions, focusing on off-screen roles, and advocating for gender-balanced representation in film scripts to …
create a more equitable and inclusive industry
Women
How are they represented?
Dumb Blondes
Man Stealer
Attractive Secretary
Love-obsessed best friend
Damsel in distress(when women are portrayed as needing a man to come and save them)
Women with kids are just seen as mothers(made to seem that they need to give up their lives for their children.
Used as sexual objects(gain attention)
Women
What is dangerous about this representation?
These representations create flawed ideas about what women are/can do/etc
The “dumb blonde” narrative makes it difficult for women to be taken seriously and obtain an education
Representing women as needy and eager to be in relationships creates beliefs that suggest women’s only role is to be defined by their relationship with a man
Sexualizes a woman down to merely an object
Women
What narrative are they presenting? Why?
The narratives presented by these representations of women perpetuate patriarchal ideologies, reinforcing male superiority and female inferiority. They depict women as subservient, intellectually inferior, and dependent on men for validation. These narratives serve to justify existing power imbalances and restrict women’s autonomy, reinforcing traditional gender roles and hindering progress toward gender equality.
Men
How are they represented?
Films presented in today’s society depict men as being strong, self-sufficient, emotionless, and physically capable people.
Men
What is dangerous about this representation?
Men who don’t fall into these categories placed on them by society question themselves as being “true men”. This can lead to many mental health issues that arise from the feeling of being an outcast, as well as Body Dysmophria, negatively reinforced gender roles and stereotypes, and alexithymia (difficulty expressing emotions, inability to recognize them).
Men
What narrative are they presenting? Why?
The narrative presented by the representation of men as strong, self-sufficient, emotionless, and physically capable individuals in today’s films reinforces traditional gender norms and stereotypes. It suggests that men must conform to narrow standards of masculinity, prioritizing traits like strength and stoicism while devaluing vulnerability and emotional expression. This narrative persists due to societal expectations of what it means to be a “real man,” but it can be damaging by limiting men’s emotional expression and perpetuating harmful stereotypes.
Asian
How are they represented?
Asians in film are commonly represented as…
weak, incompetent, impolite etc. or geeky, arrogant, sly etc.
Model minority
Tiger mom