symmetrical families Flashcards
symmetrical families
equal balanced and responsibilities shared between couple
in symmetrical families , men and women…
share the instrumental and expressive roles
equalitarian marriage
more equal marriage
Willmot and young (1970)
study of London , shows that symmetrical families more popular with younger couples
march of progress view (wilmot and young)
view family as less patriarchal and more symmetrical
reasons for increase in symmetrical families
- changes in women’s position in society
- more women working
- geographical mobility
- new technology
- reduction in children
reduction in children
parents have more free time = equal jobs/chores
new technology
eg dishwashers etc
geographical mobility
living away from community they grew up in
Oakley is a
feminist
Oakley rejects…
march on progress view
Oakley argues (remain)
men and women remain unequal within family , women do most of the housework
Oakley argues (helping)
the fact that men are see as ‘helping’ does not prove symmetry –> shows responsibility of housework still on women
Oakley research findings
- 15% husbands had high levels of participation in housework
- 25% high level in childcare (but only in more pleasurable aspects)
- men take on more pleasurable household tasks
Elizabeth Batt
segregated conjugal roles
segregated conjugal roles
couple have separate roles
- male breadwinner
- female home maker
(as in Parson’s roles)
- LEISURE ACTIVITIES also tend to be separate
joint conjugal roles
couple share tasks eg housework and childcare , spend time together
Fen and Smith
survey sample of approx. 500 , 33 year old parents
- fathers held the main responsibility for childcare in >4 fans
Morns
even when fathers are unemployed , they avoid housework
R.2 Connel calls this crisis of masculinity
Ramos
contradicts morns
- in households with unemployment male + female in full-time employment do = amt of housework
(15 hours per week)
Mordsen
TRIPLE SHIFT
TRIPLE SHIFT
- paid work
- emotional work
- unpaid housework
Dune
thinks ineqs. in division of labour crises because of deeply ingrained “gender scripts”
Dune’s study
studied 37 cohabiting lesbian couples , more likely than hetero couples to
- share childcare + housework =
- sign = imp. to their careers
- view childcare positively