Sociology Flashcards
What 3 things does medical dominance refer to?
- The profession’s authority to determine what counts as sickness
- Medicine’s dominance over patients
- Medical dominance over other health professions ( + in terms of divison of health-related labour)
Descibe the decline of medical dominance
- The rise of manageralism in the health service
- Development in nursing practice
- The increasing importace of patients voices in health
- Changing social conceptualisation (influenced by new media technologies
- Social movements e.g., disability movement challenge medical dominance
Describe the formation and role of the genermal medical council (GMC)
- Before 1858 - doctor’ professional qualifications were local (they were licensed to practice in a particular area)
- 1858 GMC formed
- Role was to take charge of medical education and professional registration; to publish a pharmacopeia
- The Formation of the GMC in 1858 led to the standardisation and professionalisation of medicine across the UK. It gave the medical profession license to regulate itself
What is the sick role model?
- It an influential model of the doctor-patient relationship that casts illness as a form of temporary deviance from one’s usual social role.
- It positions the doctor as the liegimator of illness
Describe the rights and responsibilities of the patient in the sick role
The rights:
- The sick are not obliged to perform their normal social roles.
- The sick are not considered responsible for their own state/being ‘in the sick role’
The responsibilities:
- The sick are obliged to want to get well as soon as possible.
- The sick are obliged to consult and cooperate with medical experts.
Describe the rights and resposibilites of doctors in the sick role
Rights
- To be treated by society as a professional, with a degree of independance
- To be allowed access to taboo areas, such as the sick person’s body
Responsibilities
- To be technically competent
- To be ‘affectively neutral’ and obective
a) Why may patient’s find the sick role appealing
b) What are other crtiques of the model
a)
- Devolves them of personal responsibility for the cause of their illness.
- Legitimises avoidance of the unappealing aspects of everyday life – work, chores, being pleasant to people, being active, eating healthily.
- Suggests that illness should be cured, rather than having to live with the symptoms.
- Suggests that it’s the doctor’s job to cure them.
b)
- Puts too much emphasis on work and productivity
- Lack of attention to chronic illness
- Gives doctors too much power
Describe the role of the doctors in diagnosing and legitamating illness
- In Parson’s model the ‘sick role’ doctors act as a gatekeeper to the sick role and they legitimate the sick role through naming and diagnosing illness
- Qualitative studies reveal how illnesses of different kinds are implicitely ranked in hiearchy within medical culture - this means certain illness are stigmatised e.g., psychological illness
What is the difference between sex and gender?
‘Sex’ refers to the physical differences between people who are male, female or intersex. A person typically has their sex assigned at birth based on physiological characteristics, including genitalia and chromosome composition.This assigned sex is called a person’s “natal sex”
‘Gender’ involves how a person identifies. Unlike natal sex gender is not made up of brinary forms and is broad spectrum. A person may identify at any point within this spectrum or outside of it entirely
Describe the term ‘trans’
“Trans” is an umbrella term to describe people whose current gender identty or way of expressing their gender differs from the sex they were registred with at birth
a) When do we use “trans woman”
b) When do we use “trans male”
a) We use “trans women” for someone who was registered male at birth and now identifies as a woman
b) We use “trans man” for someone who was registtered female at birth and now idenitifies as a man
We use “trans woman” or “trans man” in content about the particular health needs of trans people. Provide an example of this
There are screening or treatments that trans people need to be aware of like, advising a trans man about cervical and breast screening
What does being “non-binary” mean?
Being non-binary means not feeling that your gender identity fits naturally into the generic categories of male and female
When do we use “sex assigned at birth” and the “sex someone was registered with”
We use the phrase “sex assigned at birth” when we’re talking about trans health and gender dymorphia etc
In other cases, we use “the sex someone was registered with at birth” because user research shows that most people understand this better as it refers to an actual event
What are the gender-neutral pronouns we use?
“they”, “them”, “you”
When do doctors use language about sexuality? and provide an example of these languages
We use language about sexuality when it’s helpful to signpost or help people get the health information and access to treatment they need e.g., straight, lesbian, gay, bisexual, men who have sex with men (MSM includes men who may not identify as gay)
What is the favoured term for ‘race’ in health research and why?
‘Ethnicity’ is the favoured term in health research because the concept of ‘race’ does not have scientific validity
In terms of health, what are ethnic minority groups more likely to face? Provide examples
People from ethnic minority groups are more liekly to face forms of disadvantage that affect their health.
For examples, poor job security, stressful working conditions, unsocial hours, racial discrimination and harassememnt, place-based disavantage (e.g., living in poorl serviced areas)
Describe the sociological aspects of efforts to reduce inequaltities in the UK
- Larger scale quantative research and meta-analysis can demonstrate associations between phenomena
- Small-scale qualitative research can tell us about the granular and experiential aspects of health inequaltity
- Successive governmental reports on health inequality in the UK context: Black report (19890), Acheson report (1998), Marmot review (2010)
- Sociologists are usually part of a wider interdsiciplinary team in these processes - teams include health economists, social epidemiologists, policy specialists
Compare the concepts of belief and expertise
Belief is the subjective requirement for knowledge - this means belief is a biased and personal judgement
Expertise is an expert opinion or knowledge, often obtained through the action of submitting a matter to, and its consideration by, experts, an expert’s appraisal, valuation or report /The quality or state of being expert, skill, or expertness in a particular branch of study or report
Discuss ‘lay health beliefs’ over time’
In the past
- Professinal dominance
Now
- Greater weight given to lived experience of illness and disability
- Different forms of expertise, not ignorance vs expertise
- Shift from talking about “lay beliefs” to talking about “lay knowledge” and “lay epidemiology”
- Emergence of “experts-by-experience”
Describe how lay health belief can affect illness behaviours
- Illness behaviour is learned, starting from childhood
- Theory of planned behaviour - how beliefs influence behavious; attitudes + subjective norms + percieved control
- Pressure from others to consult is key trigger to consulting GP
Discuss the tensions around the need for both education and expertise
- In an era where health funding is restricted, patient expertise and patient self-management become valuable features of the health service
- Idea that patients need to be able to distinguish between what can be managed through self-care and what needs expert attention
What is the difference between structure and agency
Structure - determinsm ( we are determined by social structures, or social forces)
Agency - voluntarism (the indivudal has free will)
What is social stratification?
The allocation of individuals and groups according to various social hierarchies of differing power, status, or prestige
There are different ways of conceptualising social stratification - Marx’s, Weber’s, NS-SEC, a contemporary perspective. Describe Karl Marx’s perspective
Antagonistic polarisation between the two ‘basic’ classes:
- Capitilists (Bourgeoisie - owners of capital)
- Working class (Proletariat - wage-labourers)
Marx theorised that this class antagonism would lead inevitably to revolution
There are different ways of conceptualising social stratification - Max’s, Weber’s, NS-SEC, a contemporary perspective. Describe Max’s Weber’s perspective
- Emphasised the importance of class-based life-chances
- Emphasised other dimensions: ‘honour’ (status) and ‘party’ (political organisation for change)
There are different ways of conceptualising social stratification - Marx’s, Weber’s, NS-SEC, a contemporary perspective. Describe the NS-SEC (National statistics socioeconomic classification) perspective
- Measure employment relations
- Used in the research domain as a proxy for social class
- Differentiates occupations in terms of reward mechanisms, promotion prospectives, autonomy and job security
What is an impact of social inequality has had on health?
There has been an increase in the disparity in mortality rates between upper and lower social classes
List the mechanisms of health inequality models
- Behavioural model
- Materialistic model
- Psychosocial model
- Life-course model