Final Lecture 19: April 1 Flashcards
summarize last lecture
The GPS is a computer simulation to model well-defined problem solving. Problems with a defined problem space with a goal, constraints and operators
¤ The GPS uses the means-end analysis heuristic
¤ Considers the ultimate goal and follow production rules to get closer to it ¤ These rules can create sub-goals
¤ Verified by think-aloud protocols
What can stop creativity
‘Strong but wrong’ effect
what is the ‘Strong but wrong’ effect
The tendency to default to ‘pre-programmed’ sequences because they
don’t require a lot of conscious effort
¤ This can stop you from seeing things in a new way
¤ Example: After moving to a new apartment, when walking home from work the next day, you go to your old apartment
¤ A mental slip which can lead to faulty decisions ….
what are the Types of Reasoning
deductive and inductive
what is Deductive reasoning
¤ The mental act of testing a general statement to draws conclusions (top down)
¤ The scientific method of testing general theories
¤ The complete truth
what is Inductive reasoning
Making general conclusions from specific observations (bottom up)
¤ The scientific method of forming hypotheses from data
¤ Probably but not definitely true reasoning
Deductive or Inductive Reasoning? Person X went a park everyday and saw dogs wearing top-hats. They conclude that all dogs that visit this park wear top-hats
inductive (bottom up)
Deductive or Inductive Reasoning? All dogs have a good sense of smell. The Cog-Dog is a dog. Therefore, the Cog-Dog has a good sense of smell.
deductive (top down)
Aristotle studied logic how
by examining how people made judgments (deductive reasoning)
Logical rules that represent expressions of truth are obtained how
from
our experiences and used for reasoning (logicism)
are we born logical reasoners
yes
Infants watched animations that included two objects with similar tops
The two objects were placed behind a screen; one was ‘scooped’ up and placed in a bucket with only the top visible
The screen was lowered to show the other object
¤ Infant should use logic to infer that the non-shown object was in the
bucket
To test this, the object in the bucket was shown
¤ Infants looked longer at the object during this test phase ONLY when it was inconsistent with logical deduction
why aren’t we aways logical
We act in a conflicting manner
¤ We’re often will stand in a line that’s crowded, but not a short line ¤ Ordering diet coke with a Big Mac
¤ We can make faulty links between events
boil things down to two choices when there are more than two ¤ Do you like dogs
what is Syllogisms
Statements with premises and conclusion that you use deductive reasoning to determine if the conclusion is correct
what are Premises
are the parts of a reason that work together to support a conclusion
are premises presume to be true
yes
what are the Categoric syllogisms
- Major premise
* Minor premise • Conclusion
what is Validity
depends on whether the conclusion follows those premises (only on the logical form and not the content)
¤ Different than how we use this term in everyday conversation in which validity = truth
what are some Valid syllogisms
- AllAareB
- All C are A
- Therefore all C are B
Coffee is a beverage
Lattes are coffee
Therefore lattes are beverages
what are some Invalid syllogisms
- AllAareB
- All C are B
- Therefore all C are A
Coffee is a beverage
A milkshake is a beverage Therefore milkshakes are coffee
what are the 4 Types of premise rules
Universal affirmative:
Universal negative:
particular affirmative:
particular negative:
what are ¤ Universal affirmative:
All A are B
¤ All rocks are hard things [Does not mean all hard things are rocks]
what is ¤ Universal negative:
No A are B
¤ No rocks are soft things [Also means no soft things are rocks]
what is ¤ The particular affirmative:
Some A are B
¤ Some rocks are hard things [many ways to to interpret these]
what is ¤ The particular negative:
Some A are not B
¤ Some rocks are not hard things [many ways to interpret]
People tend to have more trouble reasoning with negative or positive information
People tend to have more trouble reasoning with negative than positive information
what is Omission bias
People tend to react more to strongly to harmful actions than to harmful inactions
¤ According to this bias, withholding the truth is not as bad as lying
¤ This is because inaction (the lack of something, negative premise) is harder to classify as wrong
what are Logical errors made with syllogisms
Logical reasoning doesn’t have to represent what we expect, but the content of a syllogism can lead to errors
Hidden premises
If we are simply logical rule followers, these assumptions should not affect reasoning