Chapter 17 Flashcards
Exam 2
Why Is Scheduling So Difficult in Nursing? #1
It does not fit traditional business cycle.
There is an erratic and unpredictable health-care demand.
High-level expertise is required 24/7.
Stress of job requires balanced work–recreation schedule.
Staffing mix varies with acuity
Why Is Scheduling So Difficult in Nursing?
Who is the overall responsibility for scheduling belong to?
Although many organizations now use staffing clerks and computers to assist with staffing, the overall responsibility for scheduling continues to be an important function of first- and middle-level managers.
Why Is Scheduling So Difficult in Nursing? #3
What are the two different approaches to scheduling in nursing?
Centralized and decentralized staffing are two different approaches to scheduling in nursing, each with its own advantages and challenges.
Why Is Scheduling So Difficult in Nursing? #3
In centralized staffing, where are staffing decisions made?
In centralized staffing, staffing decisions are made by personnel in a central office or staffing center.
In centralized staffing, a single department or centralized unit (often the Human Resources or a similar administrative department) handles staffing for the entire organization or facility.
Why Is Scheduling So Difficult in Nursing? #3
In decentralized staffing, where are staffing decisions made?
In decentralized staffing, each department is responsible for its own staffing.
Definition: With decentralized staffing, each unit or department manages its own staffing independently.
Decentralized and Centralized Staffing #1:
What can decentralized scheduling and staffing lead to?
*Decentralized scheduling and staffing lead to increased autonomy and flexibility,
Decentralized and Centralized Staffing #1:
Which type of scheduling is more fair to employees?
Centralized staffing is fairer to all employees because policies tend to be employed more consistently and impartially.
Decentralized and Centralized Staffing #1:
What are the pros of centralized staffing?
Consistency:
Economies of Scale:
Less Duplication:
Decentralized and Centralized Staffing #1:
Pros of centralized staffing: Consistency
A uniform approach to staffing across units or departments.
Decentralized and Centralized Staffing #1:
Pros of centralized staffing: Economies of Scale
Economies of Scale: Can be more efficient for large organizations with multiple units.
Decentralized and Centralized Staffing #1:
Pros of centralized staffing: Less duplication
Less Duplication: Reduces the redundancy of multiple units doing their own scheduling.
Decentralized and Centralized Staffing #1:
What are the cons of centralized staffing?
Lack of Unit-Specific Insight:
Delayed Communication:
Potential for Lower Morale:
Decentralized and Centralized Staffing #1:
Cons of centralized staffing: Lack of Unit-Specific Insight:
Centralized units may not have the intimate knowledge of the specific needs and dynamics of each individual unit.
Decentralized and Centralized Staffing #1:
Cons of centralized staffing: Delayed Communication:
Changes or urgent needs might take longer to process due to the added layers of communication.
Decentralized and Centralized Staffing #1:
Cons of centralized staffing: Potential for Lower Morale:
Staff may feel that decisions are imposed from “above” without considering their specific needs or preferences.
Decentralized and Centralized Staffing #1:
What are the pros of decentralized staffing
Flexibility:
Immediate Communication:
Increased Autonomy:
Decentralized and Centralized Staffing #1:
Pros of decentralized staffing: Flexibility
Units can quickly adjust staffing based on their unique needs.
Decentralized and Centralized Staffing #1:
Pros of decentralized staffing: Immediate Communication:
Faster decision-making and adjustments can occur without waiting for approval from a central authority.
Decentralized and Centralized Staffing #1:
Pros of decentralized staffing: Increased Autonomy:
Can boost morale as staff feel they have more control over their schedules.
Decentralized and Centralized Staffing #1:
Pros of decentralized staffing:
In an institution that has no human resources and no nursing recruiters, who does the hiring and what does this lead to?
no nurse recruiters, the unit manager does the hiring, this results in Greater autonomy and flexibility for the individual staff members
Decentralized and Centralized Staffing #1:
Cons of decentralized staffing include:
Inconsistency:
Duplication of Effort:
Potential for Inequities:
Decentralized and Centralized Staffing #1:
Cons of decentralized staffing include:
Inconsistency
Different units may have different staffing standards or approaches.
Decentralized and Centralized Staffing #1:
Cons of decentralized staffing include:
Duplication of Effort:
Each unit reinvents the wheel when it comes to scheduling, leading to inefficiencies.
Decentralized and Centralized Staffing #1:
Cons of decentralized staffing include: Potential for Inequities:
Some units may have better schedules or more favorable staffing ratios, leading to perceptions of unfairness.
Decentralized and Centralized Staffing #2
Centralized and decentralized staffing is not synonymous with what?
Centralized and decentralized staffing is not synonymous with centralized and decentralized decision making.
Decentralized and Centralized Staffing #2
Centralized Decision Making: What is it?
Key decisions are made by a small group of top-level leaders or a single central authority.
Decentralized and Centralized Staffing #2
Centralized Decision Making: How does information flow?
Information flows from the top down.
Decentralized and Centralized Staffing #2
Decentralized Decision Making: What is it?
Decision-making authority is distributed across various levels or units in the organization.
Decentralized and Centralized Staffing #2
Decentralized Decision Making: How does information flow?
Information and decision-making flow in multiple directions.
Common Scheduling Options in Health-Care Organizations #1
10- or 12-hour shifts
Premium pay for weekend work
Part-time staffing pool for weekend shifts and holidays
Job sharing
Common Scheduling Options in Health-Care Organizations #1
What does a written policy provide? What does it ensure?
A written policy provides a standardized approach to scheduling, ensuring that decisions are consistent across different units or departments, leading to fairness.
Common Scheduling Options in Health-Care Organizations #1
When policies are written, what does it aim to ensure?
When policies are written (not only verbal) the aim to ensure clarity, fairness, accountability,
Common Scheduling Options in Health-Care Organizations #1
Job sharing: What is it?
two people share the same position and divide the shift with each other.
Common Scheduling Options in Health-Care Organizations #2
What is a dilemma with 12 hour shifts?
Twelve-hour shifts have become commonplace in acute care hospitals even though there continues to be debate about whether extending the length of shifts results in
increased judgment errors related to fatigue and increased sick time and more care left undone.
Common Scheduling Options in Health-Care Organizations #2
Pros of a 12 hour shift?
Over time pay $$$ – increase nurse satisfaction,
fewer shift changes mean more time spent with patients and better communication because of fewer handoffs
Common Scheduling Options in Health-Care Organizations #2
Cons of a 12 hour shift?
Not cost effective to the facility, most nurses who work 12 hour shifts do not get enough sleep lack of sleep and fatigue are known to cause poor judgment and significantly higher rate of errors.
Common Scheduling Options in Health-Care Organizations #2
Lack of sleep is known to cause what?
lack of sleep and fatigue are known to cause poor judgment and significantly higher rate of errors.
In addition, drowsy driving following 12 hour night shift is persistent among nurses resulting in elevated rates of vehicle crash and crash related injuries and death.
Common Scheduling Options in Health-Care Organizations #2
What did a notable study in the International Journal of Nursing Studies find?
*One notable study published in the International Journal of Nursing Studies found that extended shifts (12 hours or longer) are linked to higher rates of errors and negative patient outcomes.
Common Scheduling Options in Health-Care Organizations #3
What is cyclical staffing?
Cyclical staffing, which allows long-term knowledge of future work schedules because a set staffing pattern is repeated every few weeks
Cyclical staffing is a scheduling method in which a predetermined staffing pattern is repeated over a specific period, typically a few weeks.
Common Scheduling Options in Health-Care Organizations #2
What did a notable study in the Journal of Nursing Administration find?
Another relevant piece of research is from the Journal of Nursing Administration, which indicates that nurses working longer hours report higher levels of fatigue, leading to decreased vigilance and an increased risk of patient safety incidents.
Common Scheduling Options in Health-Care Organizations #3
Cyclical staffing: What does it allow for?
Allowing nurses to exchange hours of work among themselves
Common Scheduling Options in Health-Care Organizations #3
Allowing Nurses to Exchange Hours of Work Among Themselves: What does this scheduling option permit?
This scheduling option permits nurses to swap or exchange their shifts or hours of work with their colleagues, provided it aligns with hospital policy and patient care needs.
Common Scheduling Options in Health-Care Organizations #4
Use of supplemental staffing- Where are they from?
Use of supplemental staffing from outside registries and float pools
Common Scheduling Options in Health-Care Organizations #4
What is shift bidding?
Shift bidding, which allows nurses to bid for shifts rather than requiring mandatory overtime
Common Scheduling Options in Health-Care Organizations #4
Shift bidding: How does it work?
- Open shifts or overtime opportunities are posted by the management.
- Nurses can then bid for these shifts, sometimes based on preferences or seniority, or even how much additional compensation they’re willing to accept.
- The management reviews the bids and awards the shifts based on the set criteria
Common Scheduling Options in Health-Care Organizations #4
Float nurses: What are they?
full time employees internal hospital employees; they receive full salary and benefits. They are those who agree to cross train on multiple units.
They can be a resource that can be used in more than one place.
Other Scheduling Alternatives
Agency nurses
Travel nurses
Flextime
Self-scheduling
Float pools
Other Scheduling Alternatives
Float pools: What must float staff be able to perform?
Float staff must be able to perform the core competencies of the unit they are floating to meet their legal and moral obligations as caregivers.
Other Scheduling Alternatives
Self-scheduling system for nurses:
**Self-scheduling systems for nurses, wherein nurses have the autonomy to choose their shifts or help design their schedules, have gained popularity as a means to improve job satisfaction and reduce burnout as it gives nurses greater control over their work environment and increases employees’ autonomy over their work lives.
Here are some issues associated with self-scheduling systems for nurses:
Inequities in Shift Distribution:
Lack of Experience Mix:
Complexity:
Potential for Short Staffing:
Lack of Consistency:
Interpersonal Conflicts:
Over-reliance on Technology:
Lack of Oversight:
Overburdening Some Nurses:
Difficulty in Long-term Planning:
Potential for Miscommunication:
Here are some issues associated with self-scheduling systems for nurses:
Inequities in Shift Distribution:
Without oversight, popular shifts (like day shifts on weekdays) might always be chosen by the same group of nurses, leaving less desired shifts (like night shifts or weekends) for others.
Here are some issues associated with self-scheduling systems for nurses:
Lack of Experience Mix:
Self-scheduling might unintentionally lead to shifts with either too many novice nurses or too many experienced ones.
It’s crucial for patient safety and mentoring to have a mix of experience levels on every shift.
Here are some issues associated with self-scheduling systems for nurses:
Potential for Short Staffing:
If too many nurses prefer and select the same shifts, there could be other shifts where not enough nurses are scheduled, leading to staffing shortages.
Here are some issues associated with self-scheduling systems for nurses:
Complexity:
While it empowers nurses, self-scheduling can also be a complex process.
Collating and coordinating everyone’s preferences can be challenging and time-consuming.
Here are some issues associated with self-scheduling systems for nurses:
Lack of Consistency:
Lack of Consistency: Patient care can benefit from consistency in nursing staff, especially in specialized units. If nurses continuously change their schedules, it might disrupt continuity of care.
Here are some issues associated with self-scheduling systems for nurses:
Interpersonal Conflicts:
Without clear guidelines and oversight, self-scheduling might lead to conflicts among nurses over popular shifts or accusations of favoritism.
Here are some issues associated with self-scheduling systems for nurses:
Over-reliance on Technology:
If the self-scheduling system is digital, any technical glitches can disrupt the scheduling process.
Additionally, some nurses might not be as tech-savvy and could find digital systems challenging to navigate.