Ab Week 4 Flashcards
The labeling model
- Abnormality depends on context.
2. Effects what you and others do who label you.
Dsm v article
Dsm v lowers prevalence slightly of autism. Definition changed again, unlikely to influence trend up. Minor results for geo’s and controls.
Can’t rely on individual, poor introspection. Study. Of feedback
And felt good or better, payed attention to them. Frequency increased. Bad decreEzed. Positive conditioning, B So who's healthy or sicker? Depends on definition, Problem with personal labeling Statistical labeling, way from norm. Abnormal intellectual functioning. Iq, treat either end differently,
Statistical labeling problems
Not always normal.
Definitions and predictability
Poor procedures
Consequences of labeling
Patients and others effected.
Those labeled, spend longer in hospital, less likely to seek help or help themselves. Profound detrimental effects of labeling. Abnormal transiet, label is permanent.
Blind, partially sighted. Do better,
Why label?
Comfort, think we understand
Scientific reasons: description, prediction, measurement control
Related to validity: do something about it very particularly
Rio to clinically label
1 High reliability in label use, different dr same results. R should be .90 but do not come close
- Advantage must exceed disadvantages, cost benefit analysis.
Cancer cost not diagnosing quite high,
Has to be done for all interventions. Not just side effects.
Diagnostically
Account for the lawfulness of the behaviour, the WHY it is happening being done
Account for the label,
Labeling means. Classification.
Is classification an imperialistic, control freak of dsm
Repackaging human sorrow, with billable disease,
Answer is it is both
The psychiatrist bible
Now since 2013, dsm v
Should have red ink, not to be taken literally.
“Billable bible”
Definition of a mental disorder
- Clinically significant disturbance which mens
Drawn to attention of a physician,
Conseq of syndrome,
Note: majority are not treated! Uh oh
Therfore, shows that we control the problem, - A syndrome
Collection of things, series add to problem.
Physical and operational definitions. Therefore can be used. - Dysfunction
Problem IN the individual def. circular reasoning, what is dysfunction in individual. How do you know. - Significant distress
Almost all have distress, has to have consequences -ve effect life, personal, interaction,occupation etc, - Death loved one not mental disorder, grief. 2 weeks limit, from 2 months. Jeeze child grief is years!
- Not socielral Deviant behViour, not disorder, unless dysfunction in individual
Due to the simple illness model
Mental health vs legal business but heads.
History of dsm
Classifications not new, Composition of fluids phlegm, Dsm 1 Myers, Ppl reacting to stress more vulnerable Ditch dsm 1. In favor of psychoanalysis. Iii physical and operational.
Why develop new dsm?
1. Tmi Change warranted Problems with the system Reliability Competition with who Tried to harmonize the two in dsm v Extend role of psychiTry, problems living, to billable hours More disorders created, natural behaviour called mental illness.
Shifted disorder
Disrupted mood, temper tantrum disorder now!
How to develop dsm
Trustees, chair person and guiding comittee sub comittee, assigned each chapter heading, meets extensively, make proposed changed, reviewed task force, edit, board can change, sent to other groups. Draft 25 000 comments, filed tests, reliVility, newsletter,reviewed, published.
Dsm IV 5 million
Dsm v 25 million dollar cost
Issues of c of I , x = 69% financial ties to pharmaceutical industry
Committees psychiTry and big pharma, rgue same thing