Nationalism essay plans

Question 1

What is a tension between nationalists regarding rationality

Answer 1

• liberal nationalists take a more rational approach on nationalism eg .. where as Conservative nationalists take a more emotive understanding of nation hood and nationalism but expansionist nationalists such as Mauras are the most irrational form of nationalism that argue that

Question 2

Evaluate the view that nationalism divides people?

Answer 2

Para 1 Liberal nationalism vs conservative nationalism . Liberal nationalists would argue that nationalism units and takes a progressive forward facing view rather than causing divisions. this is evident through … Liberal nationalists take a rational view on nationalism, it attempts to unite people which can be seen through the ideas on self- determination. Self determination is the idea that all states should rule themselves. This links to nationalism connecting people because ..is. Furthermore, Rousseaus ideas on general will reinforce the idea that nationalism is a coherent doctrine that brings people together governments are based on the collectively of the community suggest that nationalism can unite people and encourage collectivism. This differs from the conservative nationalist view. conservative NATIONALISM is backward facing ideology which is irrational due to its focus on emotional connection with ones nation. This evidently shows that nationalism is a dived doctrine because it is exclusive- this means that it takes time to become apart of nation a person must immerse themselves into there nation which shows a degree of divisions and… Furthermore, Von herders ideas on culturalism suggests that nationalism divides peoples because it isolates certain groups from nations unless they want to immerse themselves into there traditions. Therfore,..

2. Expansionist nationalism vs integral nationalism. Expansionists nationalism is a clear example of how nationalism divided people. Expansionist nationalism is highly regressive and exclusive form of nationalism which believes that their nation is unique and membership is restricted to inherence. This can divide people because it can include elements of racialism. This is where nations use this as there determining factor to be apart of the nation. Murras highlights the divide nature of nationalism through his ideas on expansionism- this is the idea that national pride is tide in military. To contrast ,Anti/post colonial nationalism also has elements of divisions that can divide people. Specifically post colonialism after interdependence was achieved they seek to reject traditions of their oppressors and create a new nation state , this can divide people because it has similar elements of exclusivity this is evident in garveys ideas of pan africanism . However anti/colonialism has similar elements to liberal nationalism where it takes a progressive approach seeking a better feature and protecting tehe righst of people. This unites people and ..
3. In addition , Mazzini favours self determination , this is a united idea which suggests that all states should have the power to rule themsleves ..

4.

Question 3

Nationalism is a recipe for peace and international order. Discuss

Question 4

Evaluate the view that nationalism is a coherent doctrine

Question 5

• Evaluate the view that nationalism is a backward-looking ideology?

Question 6

• Evaluate the view that nationalism is inherently expansionist and aggressive?

Question 7

• Evaluate the view nationalism inevitably breeds conflict and war