April 8 Review Flashcards
What type of information do you need to critique when looking at the:
Introduction
Purpose…want purpose to be clear. What the goal is. Identify the problem. Identify the particular group. Significance…want to be sure the article has a significant issue that needs to be addressed.
What type of information do you need to critique when looking at the:
Lit review
How did they handle the articles…did they mention, did they appraise them?
Relevant to the purpose.
What type of information do you need to critique when looking at the:
Methods
The procedures. Sample size. How the sample was collected. Variables? Evaluation tools: reliability and validity of these tools Design (qual/quant)
What type of information do you need to critique when looking at the:
Results
The statistics.
The findings…
What type of information do you need to critique when looking at the:
Conclusions
Reflect back…does it list limitations?
What is the difference between a research critique and a rapid critical appraisal?
Critique: scientific merit. “Good” article
RCA: practice merit. usefullness
cohort studies and case studies are simliar in that both look at correlations and both can be retrospective or prospective. what is the difference.
Cohort: risk for the disease
case studies: who actually has said disease.
Name a type of evidence that is usually thought of as a high level evidence.
Systematic review
Name a type of evidence that is usually though of as low level evidence.
Expert opinion
What is the difference between levels of evidence and grades of evidence?
Level tells us what type of study it is.
Grade tells us the quality of the study.
What information would you put into a recommendation chart?
Chart, left hand side has variables of interest. number of articles across the top. Each box signified what (if any) the effect was.
What is a clinical guideline
This is the evidence, this is the way you should do things.
“a unit of knowledge derived from the basis of a review of the current state of sciencetific evidence
GENERAL, not SPECIFIC
what is the agree-II tool
standard format for developming guidelines
what is knowledge creep?
lag time.
what is roger’s theory of diffusion of kowledge and integration?
how a new idea is pushed through