Week 14 Flashcards
Discourses of Extinction
- Writing in the West talking about the “doom” of primitive races caused by interactions with civilization
- invented contruct
Civilized vs Primitive
- Invented construct
- primitive did not concentrate power/ rule over other beings
civilizations
societies with highly stratified structures
Horicultural/ pastoral societies
Hunter Gatherers
(Historical ideas which formed development)
extinction discourse (branched from?)
- branches of imperialism and racism
- Imperialism: extending nations control over other nations
- Racism: belief that groups of humans possess behavioral traits corresponding to their physical appearance
extinction discourse characteristics
found in European expansion
- uniformity across ideologies and among different groups (Different groups of people coming to same conclusion)
- potent
- worked towards the outcome it predicted and opposed
Celebration and Mourning (extinction discourse)
- sentimental racism
Steep declines in populations (causes)
1- colonial violence, warefare and genocide
2- imported diseases
3- belief that “savage customs” led to their own decline
- savagery was self extinguishing
- shifting blame from them to the people ( victim blaming)
- created a temporal “limit”
Race scientists
- believes that savage races lived in the past (studying them = study past)
- stone age (could not progress to civilization)
- indigenous = archaic = doomed
Self-exterminating savage
opposed to noble savage
- avoid blame of global decimation
- excused and encouraged violence to them
- doomed to fall
- no amount of work can save them
- Also used to criticize colonialization
concept of race
- gave scientific legitimacy to discrimination
- homogenized people into one molded group
- this alongside extinction discourse ignore the many paths to civilization and the different types
Extinction discourse as sad
poetry
- mourning loss of people before they actually die
- sad at the “inevitable”
- mourning to people would not try to “help” them
- as a whole is preformative
Examples of Extinction Discourse
Indian Removal Act (America)
- lead up to by Extinction discourse
- moving Indigenous people east of Mississippi river to the west side
Australia (declaration of Tasmanian Aborigines Extinction)
- led to more colonies and militia (got stronger)
Darwinism
- natural selection (evolution)
Salvage Ethnography
- sciences of mourning
- saving information of disappearing people/ artifacts but not trying to save them
Extinction Discourse Timeline
- peaked in 1800s - 1930s in British Empire and NA
- mantra advocated british imperialism and american Manifest Destiny
3 Scientific Discourses Dealing with Extinction of Primitive Races
1- Natural History: Taxonomies for human races
2- economics: primitive societies having too many children leading to food shortages then population crash
3- anthropology: move away from humanitarianism to science
all supported view of savagery to be weak and exterminated by their own actions