Procurement and Tendering (Level 1/2/3) Flashcards

1
Q

Define Procurement?

A

The acquisition of construction work or services

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

How do you develop an effective procurement strategy?

A
  • Clearly define the projects objectives and requirements
  • Select the appropriate procurement route.
  • Identify and analyse risks andopportunities
  • Conduct market analysis and supplier selection.
  • Contractual arrangements
  • Implement cost control measures.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

Main types of procurement route? Benefits / Drawbacks?

A

Traditional
+ Client controls design, better quality & cost certainty
- Longer programme due to no design & construction overlap
Management Contracting
+ Shorter programme, with overlapping design & construction
- Little incentive for the main contractor to reduce costs
Design & Build
+ Single point of contact for Client
+ Early start on site & early price certainty
- Requires a comprehensive brief & little design control

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

When would you advise the use of two-stage tendering? And what are the benefits?

A

Advise it on high value, complex projects with uncertain requirements.
- Early contractor involvement
- Risk mitigation – contractor capabilities.
- Cost certainty
- Time efficiency – shortlisting preferred contractors early and focus on detailed negotiations.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

How do you identify a client’s approach to time, cost and quality?

A

Communication and engagement with Client to understand their priorities
Priorities often reflect by the Form of Contract/EWI
- Contract Type
- Bonus for completion - Time is priority
- Fixed Price - Cost is priority

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

How does management contracting differ from construction management?

A

Management contracting is when the client appoints a contractor to manage the construction works on their behalf, including letting of packages etc.

Construction management is when the client hires a CM to provide project management services and acts as an advisor to the client, but does not construct the works.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

When would construction management be appropriate?

A

Complex projects which require expertise in project management

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

What is your understanding of PFI as a form of procurement?

A

PFI means Private Finance Initiative.

In a PFI arrangement, a private sector consortium typically designs, builds, finances, and operates a public infrastructure project over a long-term period

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

What are the factors that would be considered in deciding the most appropriate procurement route for a project?

A

The route needs to align with the project’s objectives, constraints and characteristics:

o Project complexity
o Time constraints
o Budget and cost considerations
o Risk allocation and management.
o Quality

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

What sources of guidance do you use when you are procuring and tendering contracts or packages of work?

A

RICS Tendering Strategies
- Summarises what tendering is and review different strategies
Key Takeaways
- Main types of tendering procedures
- Difference between procurement & tendering
- Reasons for a robust tendering strategy (Accountability/Auditability/Reduce Conflict)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

How do you determine which pricing document to use with a sub-contract (NEC Option)?

A
  • Complexity of works
  • Scope definition
  • Subcontractor experience/level of auditability
  • Design Control
  • Contractual framework
  • Risk allocation
  • Resource
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

Outline the contents of the invitation to tender for a sub-contract package on a project you have compiled

A

Invitation to tender (ITT)
Instructions (Date for retrun, to whom, scoring matrix)
Form of Contract (incl. any amendments)
Drawings
Specifications
H&S Documents
Company Policies
Pricing Document
Form of Tender

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

How do you choose the tenderers?

A

The Client has an approved list of Subcontractors whom we can choose from
We have our own internal Subcontractor scoring database, which highlights good performing and bad performing subcontractors
I also run D&B reports prior to issuing tenders to ensure they are financially stable

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

How did you respond to queries at tender?

A

Technical query - Liaise with the relevant person who is best to answer, ensuring their bid is most accurate.
Commercial query - I would respond in a quick time frame and offer further help if required

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

How did the tendering queries work their way into the sub-contract?

A

Queries were usually surrounding each parties’ obligations with the works. If the tenderer had priced for the contractor to provide something for them, this would be written into the works information such that it clearly aligns with their bid.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

How did you analyse the tenders received?

A

Tender Recommendation Report for the Clean Water Pipework package at Oswestry:
- Narrative on package tendering strategies (Why was required in line with the EWI - New Pipework from RGF1 to RGF2, ISPS)
- Bidder List (Approved UU Suppliers - Good Supplier 360 Feedback, Good D&B)
- Tender Summary
- Commercial Compliance (Any T&C Amendments, Agree to X Clauses, Payment Terms, etc)
- Technical Compliance (Designers/Engineers comments, Quality procedures, Testing)
- Programme Compliance (Ensure Subby programme aligned with Cl32. Resource Chart/Organogram)
- Bidder Selection (Based on the above, why I chose who I did)
- Cost v Budget (Explain any variances, design changes, etc)
- Risks and Opportunities with the package

17
Q

How did you deal with errors & omissions from the tenders?

A

Errors
- Advise them on the error once known
- Allow time for the error to be corrected
- Entering a contract with known errors can often lead to disputes
Omissions
- If a tenderer is unwilling to take on a requirement, this would be noted in the report
- An allowance for the omission would be made, to ensure like for like prices
- Depending on the omission, this could effect the decision

18
Q

Can you outline an agenda for a review meeting you have held with tenderers?

A
  • Assigning roles and aligning communications
  • Discussing scope in detail
  • Technical and design obligations
  • Key dates and programme
  • Commercial (form of contract, payment terms, X clauses etc.)
  • SHEQ
  • Attendance schedule
19
Q

How did you conclude the tender negotiations?

A

Following my tendered recommendation report, senior management agreed with decision and I arranged a Pre-award meeting, held with tenderer. This finalised any remaining items.
I also notified the unsuccessful tenderers, advising on strengths and improvements in their bid such that they can reflect on this feedback

20
Q

How did you satisfy yourself that the successful tenderer’s submission was correct?

A
  • Technical Compliance (Ensured Designer and Engineer reviewed and agreed on specs and works)
  • Programme Compliance (Ensure Subby programme aligned with Cl32 and works sequencing)
  • Commercial Compliance (Any T&C Amendments, Agree to X Clauses, etc)
20
Q

On what ground would you re-tender?

A
  • Not enough tender returns
  • Tendering procedure was compromised somehow
  • Significant design changes since issue
21
Q

If a tender was returned on time, but the project delayed, what would you do?

A

1 - Check the form of tender, understand how long the quote was valid for
2 - Check if there have been any design changes
3 - Ask for a re-validated offer if required

22
Q

Different methods of competitive tender?

A

Open Tendering - Request for tenders to be submitted on an open market
Selective Tendering - Pre-selected list of tenderers
- Single
- Two-stage
Serial - Contractors are able to bid for future works if they perform well on first

23
Q

Weighting on cost, programme etc, when comparing tenders?

A

Depends on Contract - Oswestry NEC3 Option E - Programme is key

24
Q

Why did I advise on single sourcing the SI package of works?

A

It was mainly from a design perspective, it is not practical to have multiple SI contractors developing a SCADA system simultaneously
UU have a list of SI Framework Suppliers.
Only one FW Supplier with the resource capabilities to deliver the whole project themselves
Therefore single source was advised

25
Q

Oswestry WTW Project - Did you advise the client on the risks of single source tendering of the SI package?

A

Yes, however the risks of not single sourcing outweighed the risks of single sourcing
- Risk of supplier going into liquidation - Supplier turnover £29b (very low risk)
- Risk of uncompetitive - Supplier can outsource design work to India, cheaper than any competitors. Proven to be competitive across the framework
- Risk of multiple SCADA systems not integrating - Massive programme and cost risk, NEC Option E, therefore these would be the Client’s risk as well

26
Q

Oswestry WTW Project - How did you advise the client about ensuring a single source tender was not going to be uncompetitive?

A

Supplier can outsource design work to India, cheaper than any competitors
Reviewed all SI packages let across the Framework, TCS proved to be competitive across the framework

27
Q

Can you provide an example of where you have managed the tendering and negotiation process on a project?

A

On Verulam Rd, I managed the tendering and negotiation process with pre-cast suppliers for the Detention tank. I issued them the tender information, containing:
- ITT
- Tendering Rules
- Form of Contract (Incl any amendments)
- Drawings
- Specifications
- H&S Documents
- Company Policies
- Pricing Document
- Form of Tender

During the tender period, I held a mid-tender interview, to review any Commercial or Technical Queries
I then held post tender interviews with all tenders, reviewing their submission.
I also gave all tenderers the opportunity to submit a BAFO
Once received, I completed a Tender Recommendation Report and then held a pre-award meeting with the selected Supplier, to agree any final clarifications