Matt - Valuation - Level 3 Flashcards
What is the definition of market value in the Red Book?
The estimated amount for which an asset or liability should exchange on the valuation date between a willing buyer and a willing seller in an arm’s length transaction, after proper marketing and where the parties had each acted knowledgeably, prudently and without compulsion.
Where can the definition of market value be found within the Red Book?
VPS 4
What does VPS 4 cover in the Red Book?
Bases of value, assumptions and special assumptions
What is a basis of value?
It is the expected transactional environment and objectives of the parties for which an asset or liability may trade
Can you name any other bases of value detailed within VPS 4?
- Market Rent
- Investment Value
You mention that you helped prepare Terms of Engagement as per VPS 1 of the Red Book.
Why do we prepare Terms of Engagement and why are they important?
We prepare Terms of Engagement as it details the extent of the work that is to be carried out, detailing what will be done and what won’t be done.
They are important as it can help protect professionals in the event of a misunderstanding that could lead to a complaint or a negligence claim.
What does VPS 1 of the Red Book detail?
The minimum terms of engagement required.
What were some of the minimum terms of engagement?
- Identification of Client
- Purpose of instruction
- Identification of property
- Valuation date
- Confirmed standards to be applied (e.g. Red Book, Property Measurement and Code of Measuring Practice)
- Agreed departures
- Basis of value
- Assumptions and Special Assumptions
- Identification of Valuer
- Sources relied upon
- Validity period
- Restrictions on disclosure
- Fee basis
- Currency
- Complaints handling procedure
- Conflict of interest
What were some of the minimum final report headings?
- Identification of Client
- Purpose of valuation
- Identification of property
- Valuation date
- Confirmed standards to be applied (e.g. Red Book, Property Measurement and Code of Measuring Practice)
- Agreed departures
- Basis of value
- Assumptions and Special Assumptions
- Identification of Valuer
- Date of inspection
- Extent of investigation
- Property description and tenure
- Floor area / accommodation
- Defects and repair
- Services
- Planning
- MEES
- Valuation methodology, approach and reasoning
- Opinion of value
- Market commentary
What would you find in the final report that isn’t in the terms of engagement?
- Property information
- Tenure
- Defects and repairs
- Services
- Planning
- Equality Act 2010
- MEES
- Environmental factors observed
- Valuation method, approach and reasoning
- Opinion of Value
- Market commentary
What does VPS 2 of the Red Book detail?
Inspections and extent of investigation.
Were there any assumptions or special assumptions for this particular valuation?
There were no special assumptions.
There were assumptions that the properties were in a reasonable state of repair and had all the appropriate services.
What value significant factors did you observe on your inspection?
- UPVC windows
- Modern fit out internally
- Off street parking
- New build estate
- Good transport links close by
You mention that you used sources such as Rightmove Sold and your organisations Central Database to find comparable evidence.
What helped you determine which was the best comparable evidence?
Comparable evidence which had transacted close to the valuation date, on the open market, and that are similar in specification to the subject property.
Was there any RICS guidance you considered when choosing your comparables?
Yes, “RICS Comparable evidence in Real estate” volume 1, 2019
What does RICS Comparable evidence in Real Estate detail?
It details the hierarchy of comparable evidence and has them in 3 categories which are A, B and C.
What is Category A evidence?
Direct comparables (e.g. recent, completed transactions of similar properties)
What is Category B evidence?
General market data (e.g. information from public sources like indices and historic evidence)
What is Category C evidence?
Other sources (e.g transactional data that is hearsay or background data like interest rates or stock market movements)
The comparable evidence that you chose, what category would it fall in?
Category A. The evidence obtained was similar new build properties that sold close to the valuation date.
You say that you inspected the locality and other comparable properties to inform your opinion of value. Why was this important?
- VPS 2 and VPGA 8 detail that this is an important step to take when producing red book valuations.
- It also allows me to confirm the factual details of the comparables are correct also, as otherwise I’d be relying on old data.