Levine et al (2001) Flashcards
background
- mainly all studied investigating differences between communities in helping based on only the population size
- only measured from a maximum of 3 countries + didn’t look at explanation through personalities
experimental design of this study
independent measures
describe the sample
- 23 different countries
- countries Levine et al had academic contacts with
- collected from largest or major city in each country (pop over 230,000)
- e.g. Rio de Janeiro, San Jose, Kuala Lumpur, New York
describe the conditions the study was conducted in
- 2 or 3 locations
- main city center district
- during main business hours
- clear days
- during summer months of 1 or 2 years between 1992 and 1997
describe the confederates
- male, college age, dressed neatly and casually
describe the conditions the study was conducted in
- 2 or 3 locations
- main city center district
- during main business hours
- clear days
- during summer months of 1 or 2 years between 1992 and 1997
who wasn’t tested on
children (under 17), physically disabled, very old, carrying heavy packages (people who could not be fully capable to help)
describe the procedure
- confederate, during conditions required would
- drop a pen whilst walking home
- drop a pile of magazines whilst walking with a limp and wearing a clearly visible leg brace
- act like a blind person needing help to cross the road
tested to see whether they would be helped in these scenarios
describe the pen drop test
- confederates walk towards solitary pedestrian 10-15 feet away
- walk at a pace of 10 paces per 15 seconds
- at a distance, reached into pocket + accidentally drop pen in front of participant, continued waling
- helped if: called back that pen was dropped, picked up pen and gave it to him
describe the hurt leg test
- confederate walk with heavy limp, wear large + visible leg brace
- drop pile of magazines and struggle to reach for them when within 20 feet of participant
helped if: helped pick up magazine, offered to help
describe the blind man test
- confederate dressed in dark glasses, carrying white cane
- before light green at crossing, step up to corner, holding onto cane + wait for someone to help
- helped if: offered to help, helped without asking or informed that light was green
which two tests were not included and why
- asking for change (shortage of small value coins and notes in Calcutta)
- Mislaid letter on floor by post box (Tel Aviv afraid letters contained explosives, lack of post boxes in less developed countries)
describe the results
- Rio de Janeiro (93.33% helping behaviour)
San Jose (91.33% helping behaviour) - New York (44.67% helping behaviour)
Kuala Lumpur (40.33% helping behaviour)
describe the conditions the study was conducted in
- 2 or 3 locations
- main city center district
- during main business hours
- clear days
- during summer months of 1 or 2 years between 1992 and 1997
describe the procedure
- confederate, during conditions required would
- drop a pen whilst walking home
- drop a pile of magazines whilst walking with a limp and wearing a clearly visible leg brace
- act like a blind person needing help to cross the road
tested to see whether they would be helped in these scenarios
describe the conclusions
- no correlation between helping and population size of the city
- negative correlation between helping + purchasing power (helping behaviour up as purchasing power down)
- no correlation between helping and where they sit on a 10 point rating scalar of how individualistic or collectivist the country is
- a correlation but no significant negative correlation between pace of life and helping behaviour (inc pace of life, less helping)
mean level of helping in simpatia countries compared to normal
simpatia:83% (e.g. Brazil, Costa Rica, Mexico, El Salvador, Spain)
normal:63%
describe the procedure
- confederate, during conditions required would
- drop a pen whilst walking home
- drop a pile of magazines whilst walking with a limp and wearing a clearly visible leg brace
- act like a blind person needing help to cross the road
tested to see whether they would be helped in these scenarios
describe the conditions the study was conducted in
- 2 or 3 locations
- main city center district
- during main business hours
- clear days
- during summer months of 1 or 2 years between 1992 and 1997