LEO Essays, SOV IMM Flashcards
What is the 1st thing LG shd claim when facing 4th amendment LEO Battery + False Arrest?
Qualified immunity.
LEO Battery + False Arrest would be based on what action & under what constitutional amendment?
EXCESSIVE FORCE – BATTERY/SEIZURE, 4TH AMENDMENT
A. Protection.
1) 4th amend = s&s
2) Shooting, crash.
B. Stop w/ Qualified. Discretionary, clearly estab rt (4th A)
C.
What protection shd an arrestee get from the constitution to keep him free of LEO Battery + False Arrest?
14th amendment protects 4th amendment rt tto be free of search & seizure.
Sue via 42 USC 1983.
Lay out the 3 step analysis for a 4th amendment LEO Battery + False Arrest.
Analysis. 1. Issue LEO = reas. 2. Std. Obj reas in-the-moment. 3. Key: Arrest permits physical.
What law must you ALWAYS include when alleging a 4th amendment LEO Battery + False Arrest?
LIST:
4th = search + seizure ~crash, battery, false arrest
—
14th = life, lib w/ subst due process ~iied, no crash
—
1983 = indiff to const rts ~train/hire
What type of fact pattern triggers a 4th amendment claim?
Excessive force (beating) & seizure (shooting/car crash/false arrest)
What constitutional claim might someone make who has been in a car chase w/ police without a crash?
LIST:
4th = search + seizure ~crash, battery, false arrest
—
14th = life, lib w/ subst due process ~iied, no crash
—
1983 = indiff to const rts ~train/hire
What does ‘subst dp’ keep you free of?
1) Arbitrary (egregious).
—
2) Stop w/ Qualified. Discretionary, clearly estab rt. 4th amendmt.
—
3) Pairs well w/ State Tort – Intended to Inflict ROC to person.
What 2 laws must you ALWAYS include when alleging substantive due process?
LIST:
4th = search + seizure ~crash, battery, false arrest
—
14th = life, lib w/ subst due process ~iied, no crash
—
1983 = indiff to const rts ~train/hire
What is the 1st thing LG shd claim when facing 14th amendment subst dp?
Qualified immunity.
What are LG’s defenses to 14th Amendment, subst dp?
(1) More definite avail.
(2) Public purp, not egregious, arbitrary.
(3) Failure to assert 42 USC 1983
What type of fact pattern triggers a 14th amendment claim?
LIST:
4th = search + seizure ~crash, battery, false arrest
—
14th = life, lib w/ subst due process +
1983 = indiff to const rts ~train/hire ~iied, no crash
What might pair well w/ a 14th amendment subst. dp claim?
Why?
LIST:
4th = search + seizure ~crash, battery, false arrest
—
14th = life, lib w/ subst due process ~iied, no crash
—
1983 = indiff to const rts ~train/hire
What constitutional violation might a criminal or citizen claim vs LEO’s employer?
Under what law?
LIST:
4th = search + seizure ~crash, battery, false arrest
—
14th = life, lib w/ subst dp ~iied, fail to train, no crash
—
1983 = indiff to const rts ~train/hire
What does 42 USC 1983 protect you from?
Deliberate indifference to constitutional rts.
What kind of fact pattern triggers a ‘failure to train’ claim under 42 USC 1983?
All sorts.
Crash/shooting/welfare check/beating.
State the 5 step analysis of a ‘failure to train’ claim under 42 USC 1983, i.e., what must PL show?
2) DP under 14th - deprive L,L,P w/o dp
———–
3) 1983 - Person depriving another of constitutional rights under color of law.
————
4) LG
(a) “person” under 1983
(b) not be liab on respondeat superior.
(c) liab only when policy or custom inflicts injury.
———–
5) Policy
(a) express, widespread practice, final policy making authority, i.e., deliberate choice of LG,
(b) constructive knowledge, thus showing indifference
(c) cz of injury.
What are 2 defenses to a ‘failure to train’ claim under 42 USC 1983?
PL failed to show:
(a) Custom or policy or
(b) Delib indiff.
What are the 3 elements of a State claim of battery by LEO?
[Bat Intends Homerun for Person]
———–
1. Affirm intentnl inflict of
2. Harmful or offensive contact
3. Upon PL.