Lecture 2 Readings Flashcards
how do people find strength and safety?
in others
Desert Island thought experiment
given a group of strangers stranded on a desert island, someone will emerge as a leader
what is leadership about?
providing solutions to common problems or offering ideas about how to accomplish collective purposes, and mobilizing the energies of others to follow these courses of action
why do some members feel that they have the right to lead?
based on their age, gender, or experience, or because they think they would make better decisions than other people
what is the goal of leadership?
solving collective action problems
leaders
determine or clarify goals for a group of individuals and bring together the energies of members of that group to accomplish those goals
why is leadership necessary?
its goals are out of reach for individuals acting singly or randomly
how do collectives respond to leadership?
they act almost exclusively by accepting leadership
leadership in animals
- There is evidence of leadership in chimpanzees
- Other social animals like insects demonstrate primitive forms of leadership by determining the timing and direction of their movement (ex. Bees’ waggle dance)
can groups have more than one leader?
yes
requirement of a group
Groups must be bounded and recognizable as such
size & complexity of groups
Groups range in size and complexity
Tucker on leadership
to understand leadership, we should start with the question of what it is that leaders do, or try to do, in turn, capacities as leaders
leadership and decision-making
- Leaders make decisions
- Each new decision sets a precedent, which presents them with new decisions
how do leaders achieve their goals?
implementation strategies
examples of implementation strategies
thinking ahead, assessing what is likely to happen, and weighing the importance of multiple factors
Heresthetics
the strategy of decision
responsibilities of leaders
- Leaders have to compromise to achieve their goals
- Leaders set priorities among issues that confront the group
- Leaders also listen to proposals or petitions from others and adjudicate conflicts among subordinates
- Leaders assemble resources and deploy incentives
- They give voice to vision in articulating goals
- They seek counsel and issue statements about decisions they have made or problems they must confront
- Leaders take stands by staking out positions and advocating for them
- They attempt to persuade, require, or force others to follow a course of action they have determined is desirable
leaders and power
Leaders direct the activities of others which is a basic form of power
Max Weber’s distinction of power & leadership
divides power into macht & herrschaft
Macht (power)
the probability that one actor within a social relationship will be in a position to carry out their own will despite resistance
Herrschaft (authority or leadership)
the probability that a command given within a specific context will be obeyed by a given group of people
Janda on leadership
leadership can be distinguished from power when members of a group believe “that another group member may, with reference to their group activities, legitimately prescribe behaviour patterns for them to follow.”
do leaders enjoy the exercise of power?
- Power is often one of the appeals of leadership
- Many leaders with a range of backgrounds, experience, and temperament enjoy the exercise of power
limits of the scope of leaders’ power
- Their personal capacities
- The institutional context
- Inclinations and preferences of other actors
continuum of the methods of leadership
There is a continuum ranging from the coordination of an enthusiastic group of followers to an autocratic ruler
can leaders be successful if they use threats?
yes! coercion, threats, or sanctioning form part of the repertoire of some successful leaders
how are goals that have been collaboratively determined carried out?
through persuasive leadership
range of leadership methods
- Leadership methods range from active and visible to subtle
- In some circumstances, lowkey leadership can be more effective than aggressively visible leadership
what kinds of goals do leaders focus on?
collective goals that touch on the interests of their group
what is necessary for leadership to be effective?
some members must share the leader’s goals or at least be willing to support the leader in pursuing them
lieutenant-leader relationship
Leaders require lieutenants to help ensure that other members of the group follow the goal the leader has decided upon
lieutenants can act out of:
Principled commitment
Traditional loyalty
Fear of reprisal
Personal gain
do goals have to be intrinsically valued by followers?
no
can goals be pursued where individuals have no motivation to do with the ultimate goal?
yes, they might converge from different starting points in support of the collective action directed by the leader
do followers engage in group activity if they don’t agree on the collective goal?
yes, if they see their interests satisfied in goals set by a leader, they may willingly engage in group activity, even if the collective goal isn’t one they would have chosen
what is needed for leadership to occur?
a certain amount of voluntary submission
what is the most common motive for leaders?
Ambition
motives of leaders
Leaders have a complex cluster of motivations, some that have personal dimensions, and others that have collective dimensions
Ideal types (Weber)
leaders with a purely selfish or a purely common purpose
formality of effective leadership
Effective leadership varies in its formality
importance of context of leadership
Culture, geography, ethnicity, history, and the character of the goal pursued make a difference in what leadership is effective
does having a leadership position make you a leader?
not necessarily
three types of leadership (Plamenatz)
- management
- government
- leadership