Lecture 2: Leadership Overview & Keohane Flashcards
what are the challenges of leadership?
- Representing everyone’s wishes as much as you can
- Jurisdiction
- Knowing when to step down
- Compromise
- Stereotypes
- Keeping your weaknesses in check
- Motivating others
we take leadership for granted until there is:
- Failure of leadership
- Absence of leadership
- Lack of leadership
Nannerl Keohane
- A leading political theorist, the first woman president of Duke University, and former president of Wellesley College
- Examines what leaders do, how and why they do it, and the challenges they face
- Provides a useful set of considerations for understanding and assessing leadership
Keohane argues that leadership:
- Occurs in many contexts
- Has some relationship with power, but not a synonym for holding power
- Involves exercising authority, but not necessarily formal authority
- Can be performed in a variety of ways, from the admirable to the deplorable
- Central to almost all collective social activity
Joseph Rost
argues that leadership as we know it is a 20th-century concept as the word itself did not appear in dictionaries until the 19th-century
counterarguments to Rost’s notion of leadership
many ancient and modern languages have words that can easily be translated as leadership or some synonym
leadership and context
the character of leadership can vary significantly with context
family resemblances and leadership
- Keohane employs Ludwig Wittgenstein’s idea of family resemblances when discussing leadership in a different context
- It allows for “meaningful general statements about leadership as an aspect of human social life”
Kehone’s two parts of leadership
- Putting forward ideas for accomplishing group goals
- Bringing together members of the group to act on these suggestions
Leaders must:
- Make decisions
- Devise and implement strategies
- Compromise to achieve goals
- Listen to proposals or petitions from others
- Adjudicate conflict
- Assemble resources and deploy incentives
- Give voice to vision
- Seek counsel and issue statements
- Take stands
- Persuade, require, or force
Max Weber
- Famous 19th-century German sociologist
- Argued for the distinction between power, authority, leadership, and legitimacy
Weber on leadership
Leadership requires the use of power but is also limited by existing power structure and relations (the institutional context)
Weber on power
the probability that one actor within a social relationship will be able to carry out his actions without resistance
Weber on authority
the probability that a command given within a specific context will be obeyed by a given group of people
examples of contextual factors
culture, geography, history, etc.
three leadership styles
- founders
- fixers
- sustainers
founders
establish new organizations
fixers
repair or radically transform existing institutions
sustainers
develop or sustain existing institutions
public vs. private leadership
Private leadership is more concerned with making a profit