Identify the Assumption Flashcards
When answering assumption question , we must ask ourself
1) what is the missing information
2) What piece of information is unstated by the author yet must be true in order for the evidence presented to effectively support the conclusion
Assumption Question
- The argument depends on
- The conclusion above would be more reasonably drawn if which of the following were inserted into the argument as an additional premise?
- The argument depends on assuming which of the following?
- The argument above logically depends on which of the following?
- In order for the conclusion to be true, which of the following must be true?
Identify the assumption Question
1) Carefully read and undertsand the passage
2) Read the question stem and identify what it is asking you to do
3) Go back to the passage and determine exactly what the conclusion of the argument is
4) Identify how the conclusion is supported
5) Remove choices that are rather obviously not assumptions intergal to the argument
6) Choose the answer choice that is most clearly an assumption to the argument
Authors of the arugument assume that they are
correct and they assume that their aruguments are sound and logical
Authors of the arugument
have considered every varibale that could affect their arguments and that after considering those variables, they’ve reached conclusions that are supported by their evidence
Presence of malicous variable
A malicious variable is a varibale that an author has failed to consider in the constrution of her argument and that enters into the equation and spoils that argument, rendering the argument sound
–> When an author presents a plan, she assumes that there are no malicious varibales that wil cause the plan not to work
When author set forths an argument, plan, proposal or course of action
she assumes that there will be no offsetting factors that will somehow render that argument, plan, proposal or course of action invalid
When an author makes cause and effect
she assumes that her cause and effect claim is correct; she assumes there could not be an alternative explanation for the observed events
-> She posits that the cause and effect she has described as the only possible cause of the effect
When author assumes that a plan will not work or that some outcome will not occur
she must assume that there is not some other way or some other path (that she has failed to consider) via which the plan could work or via which the outcome could occur
In assumption questions, argument may depend on the assumption that an alternative path to an outcome
is not available
When author puts forth a plan
she belives that the plan or course of action will work as planned
The argument about topics such as plans, predictions, or explanations can include
- elements that are from different time periods
- when author uses data from one time period to support a conclusion about a different time period, she assumes that data can actually be used to support her conclusion. She assumes that things have not changed or will not change over time in a way that would invalidate her conclusion
Assumption is a piece of information that must be true for the logic of an argument to work, if we were to find an assumption upon which an argument depends to be false
the argument could no longer work
-> If we think that something is necessary, then try to get rid of it. If the argument falls apart in its absence, that thing was necessary for the argument to be sound
Negating technique to check if the assumption is true or not
1) Break down the argument
2) Write down the negation of each answer
3) Eliminate the choices that do not hurt the conclusion
4) Choose the answer that most specifically hurt the argument
When answering an assumption questions
key to avoid choosing a trap choice that is connected to the argument is to keep in mind that we are looking for, an unstated piece of informations necessary in order for the evidence to support the argument’s conclusion.