Cause and Effect Flashcards
A cause-and-effect relationship
one event causes another event to occur
When an author makes a cause-and-effect claim
she assumes that her cause-and-effect claim is actually correct; she assumes that there could not be an alternative explanation for the observed events
-> Assume that there is no other alternative explanation
Correct answer in cause and effect
highlights a piece of information that must be true in order for the logic of the argument to work
perceptions of patterns and relationships are not
always accurate: humans often make incorrect assumptions about cause-and-effect relationships
always accurate: humans often make incorrect assumptions about cause-and-effect relationships
So, we must be very careful any time we encounter a question dealing with cause and effect.
We’re apt to make an error in reasoning any time we notice that one event, X, occurs before another event,
Y, and, on this basis alone, we conclude that the first event, X, must have caused the second, Y.
The fact that some event X occurred before some event Y
does not necessarily indicate that event X caused event Y.
Cause and Effect Weaken the argument
When there is an alternative explanation
When the subject in the sentence is really broad and doesn’t give us the name of the subject we are looking at
We can’t really pick it because it’s not specific enough
Cause-and-Effect Reasoning Error Two: Co-Occurrence
two or more events occur simultaneously, and we conclude, on this basis alone, that they are causally linked.
Cause-and-Effect Reasoning Error Two # Fixing the error
1) There might be a third variable explaining this
2) The simultaneous occurrence of two events does not necessarily indicate that one causes the other.
Cause and Effect - Alternative Solution
any time we provide an alternative cause of the effect mentioned in a cause-and-effect argument, we are weakening that argument.
-> When you negate the argument and get a weakening argument then the sentence strengthens the argument
Correlated
change in one variable accompanies a change in the other.
Cause and Effect - Strengthen and argument
You can provide that there is no alternative explanation
If there was an alternative explanation then that would weaken the current statement
Weakening a Cause-and-Effect Argument by Reversing the Relationship
It is possible to weaken a cause-and-effect argument by showing that the cause-and-effect relation could be reversed. That is, if the argument assumes or concludes that that A caused B, showing that B may have caused A would successfully weaken the argument.