Debates Flashcards
RvsH - Reductionism
- Breaks complex things down into smaller parts
- Behaviour explained by 1 factor
- Testing 1 variable at a time; an IV
- Scientific
RvsH - Holism Includes
- Looks at a list of complex factors to understand behaviour
- Sum of the Parts = the Whole
- Reduce Parts =/ the Whole
RvsH - Biological Reductionism
Behaviour explained by genetic inheritance and biological activity
RvsH - Environmental Reductionism
People, Culture, Role Models, Reinforcement
RvsH - Holism +
- More Generalisable
- Higher Ecological Validity
RvsH - Holism -
- Role of Culture, Environment, & Context in Shaping Behaviour
- Multiple Factors
RvsH - Reductionism +
- Breaking things up can make them understandable
- Other sciences do it, so Psychology wants to do it too
RvsH - Reductionism -
- Too simplistic or limited
- May ignore important factors
- Low Ecological Validity
- Low Generalisability
RvsH - Blakemore & Cooper
- Environmental Reductionism, all boiled down to - or | stripes
RvsH - Lee
- Environmental Reductionism, lied or not depending on Culture
- Holism, some didn’t lie
RvsH - Milgram
- Social Reductionism - Situational Factors; scientist w/ lab coat, prestigious Uni
Individual vs Situational
Unique Individual character VS Factors Affecting you
IvsS - Individual
Behaviour is due to a Unique characteristic in you
- Biology
- Upbringing
- Personality
> Internal Locus of Control (ID^)
> Authoritarian Personality (Follow Orders)
- NeuroDiversity
IvsS - Situational
IvsS - Casey
Individual
- Biology Argument
IvsS - Situational Factors
- Closed Environment
- Legitimate Authority (Professional)
- Buffer (between consequences)
- Peer Pressure
- Diffusion of Responsibility
- No relation/attachment Learner
- Gradual Increase in Task
- No Allies to Help Encourage Disobedience
- Demand Characteristics
- Money Incentive
Sperry - Individual
Natural reaction due to Biology
Sperry - Situational
Ppl would have turned their head so both sides could see information, unlike the experiment
S&C - Individual
Some ppl Noticed Gorilla; more observant
S&C - Situational
Distracted with other task, so less likely too see unexpected event
Maguire - Individual
Biology dependant
Maguire - Situational
- Would focus more in test conditions
- Demand Characteristics
Lee - Individual
Depended on Culture
Lee - Situational
Less inclined to lie in the presence of an adult (Legitimate Authority)
Individual - Strengths
Individual - Weaknesses
Situational - Strengths
Situational - Weaknesses