Criminal Procedure (Sentencing) Flashcards
Purpose of Sentencing Adults?
The purpose of sentencing adults includes punishment of offenders, reduction of crime, reform and rehabilitation, protection of the public, and making reparation to those affected by the offences.
What are the types of courts with sentencing powers?
- Magistrates’ Court
- Youth Court
- Crown Court
Where can a summary only offence be sentenced if D pleads guilty in Magistrates?
Only in the Magistrates’ Court; it cannot be committed to Crown Court.
Where is a defendant sentenced if they plead NOT guilty to an either-way offence in Magistrates, and the case is sent to trial and found guilty in the Crown Court?
Cannot be sentenced in the Magistrates Court.
D must be sentenced by the Crown Court
Where is a defendant sentenced if they plead guilty to an either-way offence in Magistrates?
The defendant can be sentenced in Magistrates’ Court or be committed to Crown Court for sentencing.
What occurs if a defendant is found guilty of an indictable only offence at PTPH in Crown Court?
The defendant must be sentenced by the Crown Court.
Where is D sentenced if they are found guilty aat trial in Crown Court?
D must be sentenced by the Crown Court
When is a Newton Hearing required?
When the defendant pleads guilty on a different factual basis that may impact the sentence and the court needs to establish the facts.
(Simply, following a guilty plea to establish a fact that may impact the sentnece)
What happens if the Crown accepts the defendant’s basis for a Newton Hearing?
The sentence is passed on the defendant’s basis unless the judge disagrees, in which case a Newton Hearing may be needed.
What happens if the Crown reject the defendant’s basis for a Newton Hearing?
The question is asked whether the judge things the basis is absurd…
- if the basis is absurd to the judge, the sentence is on the prosecution basis
- If the basis is not absurd, the question is whether it will make a material difference to the sentence…
If no, the sentence is on the defence basis
If yes, a Newton hearing will be required.
What happens at a Newton Hearing?
Evidence is presented by prosecution and defense to determine facts, without a jury, and sentencing is based on the determined facts.
What is the principle of totality in sentencing?
When sentencing for multiple offences, the court considers the total sentence…
- Concurrent sentences for related facts
- Consecutive for unrelated
What is meant by deferring sentence?
The court may defer sentencing up to six months to assess changes in the defendant’s behavior before passing a potentially lighter sentence.
What is the procedure for an indiciation of sentence in the event of a guilty plea in the Magistrates?
If the offence is either-way and the court accepts jurisdiction, D can ask for an indication should the case remain in the magistrates following a guilty please.
The court does not have to give an indication.
If it does, it can only say whether it would be custodial or non-custodial. It is binding if D does in fact plead guilty.
What is the procedure for an indiciation of sentence in the event of a guilty plea in the Crown Court?
D can ask for an indication either before PTPH or at any stage before the jury verdict.
Before asking, D must (i) accept the prosecution facts or a written basis plea must be agreed; and (ii) give clear instructions that they wish to ask for an advance indication of sentence.
Note, it is discretionary and remains the decision of the judge.
What is a pre-sentence report?
A report used by the court, often from the Probation Team, to help decide an appropriate sentence for a custodial or community sentence.
It is not binding on the court.
What should the prosecution remind the court of during a sentencing hearing?
- Previous convictions
- Ancillary orders the prosecution seek
- Relevant sentencing guidelines
- General sentencing issues
- Victim impact statements
What are the four stages when passing sentence?
Step 1: Determining Seriousness
Step 2: Determine which category of sentencing guidelines applies
Step 3: Adjust the starting point according to aggravating/mitigating factors
Step 4: Reduce sentence to credit any guilty pleas
What does culpability mean in determining seriousness?
Culpability assesses blameworthiness based on role, intention, premeditation, and planning by the offender.
What is harm when considering seriousness?
Harm is the assessment of the damage caused to the victim
What are the three categories in sentencing guidelines?
Category 1: Greater culpability and harm
Category 2: Mixed culpability and harm
Category 3: Lesser culpability and harm.