College 9 Flashcards
deception
an act intended to foster in another person a belief or understanding which the deceiver considers false
> always a dyadic (consists of 2) process
entails:
1. communication of information
2. meta-communication about sincerity of that information.
self-deception
holding two contradictory beliefs, but not being aware of one of them
> not dyadic
intentionally transparent lies
deceiver wishes to be uncovered
> no intent to foster beliefs
mistaken lies
telling a “lie” because one thinks it’s the truth
> blief not considered to be false by deceiver
deception cues
cues that challenge the deceiver to convince the detector of the sincerity of their lie
leakage cues
cues that challenge the deceiver to try and protect hidden information from the detector
findings about why we lie
- manipulativeness correlates with more self-oriented beneficial lies
- higher self-control correlates with less lying
- higher empathy correlates with more other-oriented and white lies
- lower-self esteem correlates with more beneficial lies
How common is lying?
- most common: 41% self-oriented protective lies
- least common: white lies, and other oriented beneficial lies
Overall: 412 out of 2039 interactions involve lies (0.74 lies/ day)
Markowitz: romantic desirability in dating apps
faking shared interest and hobbies to “reach the ultimate goal of meeting the person face-to-face”
butler lies > availability management
lies during (dating) discovery phase to manage availability (“Sorry, I cannot make it today, my sister just called…)
Self-presentation lies
lies during (dating) discovery phase to increase own attractiveness
relevant factors for a good lie
- control: attempt to conceal deception can be suspicious
- arousal: deception is arousing, which can be visible
- affect: affect due to the deception can be suspicious
- cognition: creating a deception narrative is harder than being honest
concealed information test
people are told to hide knowledge about lie-relevant vs. control stimuli
shefflied lie test
participants instructed to lie or be truthful about a set of simuli
ADCAT: Activation-Decision-Construction-Action Theory
deception consists of four stages:
1. Activation
2. Decision
3. Construction
4. Action
> focus on cognitive processing at each of these stages
The activation phase
- we have to understand that someone is asking us for a truth (involves ToM)
- involves retrieving information from long term memory, and keeping it active in working memory
The decision phase
- we have to decide whether we should lie about that truth
- calculations bounded by rationality and motivation: we compute expected values of different outcomes (“what would happen if I get away with this/am caught”)
The construction phase
now we have to construct a plausible lie
- our ToM will predict what we think would be plausible for the detector, and what would not
The action phase
now we deliver the lie to the detector
- we try to avoid showing leakage & deception cues by controlling them
> this can be cognitively demanding and also suspicious, because of inaccurate ToM inferences
The cognitive interview technique
- ask witnesses (or suspects) to report on the critical event in four stages:
1. free-recall of the event (“report everything”)
2. context re-instatement (“imagine perspective-taking)
3. change perspective on event (“report as if you were not afraid”)
4. change order of event (temporally)