Alternatives To Medical Model + Treatment Flashcards
What was the aim of Szaszs (2)
To challenge the medical concept mental illness
Reject psychiatric treatments justified but this approach to mental illness
S - key points from mental illness is a metaphor (2)
Mental illnesses are undiagnosed bodily illnesses
New unusual behaviours are discovered and referred to as new mental illnesses rather than a physical illness with behavioural symptoms - ever increasing list of disorders
S - 50 years of change in us mental healthcare key points (1)
Mental healthcare is now the responsibility of the government and is through medical and political
S - mental illness a medical or legal concept (3)
Mental illnesses are defined by political and economical criteria - since what is classed as mental illness was has changed so much (homosexuality)
Mental illness is not a real phenomenon because if it was it wouldn’t change so readily
Mental hospitals are like prisons to control people’s behaviour - they are placed there incorrectly and treated like prisoners rather than receiving treatment for their illness
S - mental illness is in the eye of the beholder (2)
Mental illness aren’t medical illnesses because medical treatment of a physical illness requires consent whereas when mental illness treatment deprives parents of their liberty - violation of human rights
Diagnosis of mental illness is based on a doctor making a judgement - it can the measured the way physical illnessses can like temp
S - having an illness doesn’t make someone a patient (3)
Mental illness is a myth and a metaphor
Psychiatry is a pseudoscience
Old religious humanistic perspective has been replaced by the modern pseudomedical one
What can be used in defence of sz (2)
People with labels subjected to interventions like being sectioned or forced to take drugs
Rosenhabd - diagnosis lacks validity anyways
Behaviours out of norm being labelled as abnormal
What can be used against sz
He is wrong - help those who are suffering
Drugs actually work
Gottesman - genetics - it’s actually a thing inherited
Individual / situation szasz
Individuals should be treated according to their mental illness with drugs etc
Situational - sz society’s reaction to those with mental illness causes incorrect diagnosis and treatment
Holistic or reductionist (sz)
Holistic - medical model is reductionist
Mental illness can’t be viewed in that specific way
Free will / determinism sz
Free wlll - they should be active players in their treatment etc
Deterministic - medical model
Which mental illness is used with the behaviourist explanation
Phobias
3 key concepts of behaviourist explanation
All behaviour is learnt therefore what can be learnt can be unlearnt
We are products of our environment
Blank slate at birth
What are the 2 main concepts of the behaviourist explanation
Operant conditioning and classical conditioning
What is classical conditioning and what study is associated with it
Watson and Rayner
Making an association between 2 unrelated things
What was the Watson and rayner study
Little Al - unconditiones stimulus was life and ucr was fear and crying
UCS and neutral stimulus (rat) introduced leading to ucr of fear and crying
Then conditioned stimulus rat let to conditioned response fear
How does classical conditioning explain phobias
Suggest phobias are a result of an association with something else - mental illnesses are learnt from environment
How does operant conditioning explain phobias
Negative reinforcement - the happiness when avoiding phobia encourages you to continue avoiding it
How can the behaviourist explanation be considered reductionist
How can it be holistic
Only looks at the effect of association and no other factors
When combining classical and operant conditioning