2.4 educational policies Flashcards
What was education like before 1944?
- confined to a small minority
- after the IR, many believe that a literate and numerate workforce was required to continue economic growth
What act introduced the tripartite system?
The Butler Act (1944)
What was the basic aim of the Butler Act?
- to give every pupil a chance to develop their abilities to the full within a free system of state education
- children took a test at the age of 11, which would measure their intellectual ability and determine which one out of three schools they were most suited to
What three types of schools were part of the tripartite system?
- grammar = academic education
- secondary modern = basic education
- technical = vocational schools
What are some criticisms of the tripartite system?
- secondary moderns were regarded as inferior = students received a lower standard of education
- persistence of class inequality = no real equality of opportunity, MC went to grammar and WC to secondary modern
- persistence of gender inequality = girls had to achieve a higher score in the 11+ because they were thought to mature earlier
- the 11+ determined the next 5 years of schooling = ‘late developers’ had no chance of getting an academic education
What is a positive evaluation point of the tripartite system?
- there were many children, particularly WC boys, who were given the opportunity to attend grammar school and achieve success within the system
When was the 11+ abolished and grammar and secondary moderns were replaced?
in 1965 they introduced the comprehensive schools
What did the introduction of comprehensive schools mean for education?
- there was a ‘one size fits all’ approach to education where all students, regardless of ability are educated at the same school
- education should have equality of opportunity
- students went to the school nearest to their house
What are some advantages of the comprehensive system?
- equality of opportunity
- parity of esteem = all students attend the same type of school
- breaking down class barriers
What are some criticisms of comprehensivisation?
- class inequalities were just reproduced under one roof
- there was very limited choice over where parents could send their children to = selection by mortgage
What happened in The Great Debate, 1967?
- Labour PM, James Callaghan made a speech calling for a ‘Great Debate’ on education, he emphasised how important it was for schools to do 2 things:
1. contribute to improving the state of the economy by providing training courses for young people in different areas of work = new vocationalism
2. schools needed to get back to basics and raise overall standards
What was the rationale behind the 1988 Education Act?
- the New Right believed that parents should have more say in what school to send their children to = parentocracy
What did the act introduce?
- league tables
- a national curriculum
- standardised testing
- formula funding
- open enrollment
- later on: introduction of OFSTED
What were the aims of the 1988 Educational Reform Act?
- parentocracy = because of more competition and choice, parents hold the power in the education system
- marketisation = consumer choice and competition between suppliers
- these should, according to the new right, improve efficiency in schools
What does Gerwitz argue about parental choice?
- there are class differences in the ways parents choose where to send their children:
- privileged skill choosers = MC parents use their cultural capital to take advantage of the opportunities available to them e.g moving house to better catchment areas
- disconnected local choosers = WC parents who lack economic and cultural capital
What are some general criticisms of the 1988 Education Reform Act?
- focusing on exam results and league tables causes stress
- ‘teaching to the test’ = teachers may stifle children’s creativity
- MC have more effective choice : selection by mortgage and transport costs
- schools become more selective
- inequality of education opportunity increases = the best schools become oversubscribed and can cream-skim the best pupils, meaning they can get better results
When were New Labour in power?
1997-2010