wildlife trade Flashcards
bownan 2013 reasons for CITES to continue to exist
-sustainable utilization
-criticism driven by emotion, not reality
-forum articulates variety viewpoints
-has authority to adress cons problems
-didn’t have= extinction
-other treaties deal habitat conversion problem to its aim
-flexible treaty
-imperialism and lack sovrienty not true
bownan reason CITES shouldn’t continue
-individualistic, materialistic liberalisation views dominate = not effective
-can be counterproductive
-not fulfilling brief
-corruption in implementation
-should focus habitat destruction not trade
-preservationist approach= imperialist
-lacks strong enforcement
-bans trade inless proven otherwise
-conserve own sake not trade
bownan 2013 conclusion should we keep CITES?
balanced approach have most chance success, interdisciplinary work can ensure sucess. CITES best treaty have must work to ensure its success don’t have a second option
rosen ,smith 2010 how many wildlife seizures 1996-2008
967
rosen ,smith 2010 where does most wildlife trade originate what does this mean
Se asia= hotspot disease
rosen ,smith 2010 how many seizures mamal
51%
rosen ,smith 2010 why illegal wildlife trade difficult to enforce
-remoteness poaching,
-lack infrastructure
-corruption
-shortage wildlife enforcement officers
example infectous disease spread wildlife trade rosen , smith 2010
2003 monkey pox virus transferred to usa through shipment infected rodents
rosen , smith 2010 how to solve illegal wildlife trade
-more regulation
-education reduces demand
-improve economic stability of countries
-port officer training to ID species
-DNA forensic help enforcement and sanctions
Taylor et al 2017 how much rhinoe horn could be sustainably obtained in south Africa
5319-3356kg per yr
Taylor et al 2017 why did they want to work out how much rhino horn could be sustainably obtained?
provide evidence that could be used in the debate on whether to make the sell of rhino horns legal or not
Taylor et al 2017 where could you obtain rhino horn from
-natural mortality
-dehorning
-trophy hunting
-stock piled horns
what issues surround farm rhino horn farming Taylor et al 2017
-change pop dynamic
0need increase intensive breeding
-wild rhino less common = cons concern
-need more security farmed rhino easy target poaching
pears 2003 are brazil nuts being harvested sustainably
no not enough juvenile or recruitment new trees so if not managed pop collapse
pears 2003 how can we make harvest brazil nut sustainable
-increase juvinile
-reduce intensity tree harvest
-plant nursery
-manage viable juvinile seed
-protect seed disperser
-protect natural habitat
silvertown 2004 are brazil nut biologically sustainable
no- not enough juvenile not regenerating
silvertown 2004 are brazil nuts socially /economic sustainble
-don’t create sufficent income
-money brazil nuts then used buy chainsaws to deforest
silvertown 2004 how could sustainably manage brazil nuts
create a ethical trade in brazil nuts- pay premium for s.
why is wildlife traded
-sustaining livelihood
-fuel
-fodder
-construction materials
-clothing and ornamental
-pets
-sport
-health care
-religion
-collections
example traded items wildlife
-mahogony
-hyancith macaw
-spix macaw
TRAFFIC how much legal wildlife trade worth
US$323 billion
TRAFFIC what aremost important items trade volume and value
timber
fisheries
TRAFFIC what percent vertibrate species are traded
24%
2011 how much illegal timber trade worth
$7-8 billion
2019 how much illegal wildlife trade owrth
$8-$21 billion
how large illegal wildlife trade
4th largest criminal market
what are key features of the illegal wildlife trade
-sophisticated outlets- linked organized crime and drug smuggling
-low risk detection and low penalties relative to high value wildlife products incentivize criminals to engage in trade
why illegal trade so hard to deal with
-hard to tell difference between whats legal and illegal
-less weight to stories finding illegal animals compared to drugs
what rating helmeted hornbill
-near threatened now critically endagered trade = move CITES apendix 1
-
why helmeted horn bill traded
recent resurgence demand casque carve red ivory