Theories of Female Victimization Flashcards
Week 3
Explain how victims can be turned into offenders through the system.
- if they’re subpoenaed to court and don’t show, they can be prosecuted
- mandatory arresting in domestic violence cases
Are victims treated as active participants in their case?
No, they are often treated like witnesses to their own victimization.
- don’t have autonomy in case
- don’t have control over having the case dropped
- must be informed of the staying of charged but not involved in the decision process
What crimes have really low rates of reporting?
sexual violence and intimate partner violence
What are the closure rates for formally prosecuted SA/IPV?
30%
What percentage of reported cases of SA/IPV get prosecuted?
5%
What are some reasons why reporting is especially low for victims of IPV or SA?
- hostility from friends and family who they tell
- fear of not being believed
- fear of revictimization in CJS
- not understanding that they were really victimized bc it was someone they know
- not wanting to hurt the offender if it was someone they knew
- fear or retaliation of offender (esp. in IPV)
- self doubt
- embarrassment
What is the message of the start by believing initiative? (3)
If someone discloses their victimization to you, you should believe them. You should let them lead and ensure they know they are in control.
What are some exceptions that would affect your ability to let the victim lead?
Mandatory reporting and duty of care.
What is the rule around child abuse reporting in Manitoba?
It is everybody’s legal obligation to report suspected child abuse.
Who is most likely to seek help outside the formal legal process?
women
What are some examples of informal services?
Family, friends, therapists, clergy
What is the relationship between positive informal support and reporting?
The more positive informal support a victim receives, the more likely they are to submit a formal report.
What is the victim bill of rights? What is the main focus?
Introduced in 2003, it codefies certain rights for victims. It is mostly focuses on the right to information.
What is femicide? What does it usually involve?
Killing of a woman because they are a woman. Often involves dismembering and severe genital mutilation.
Where is femicide an issue in Mexico? What are the rates of femicide out of all homocides?
Rampant in Mexican boarder towns (ex. Ciudad-Juarez and Chihuahua), 3% of all homocides are femicides.
What are the main theory behind the phenomenon of femicide in Mexico?
Backlash theory: women are starting to be more independent and empowered which goes against traditional societal roles so the oppressor wants to keep them contained and in control.
Is femicide classified as its own crime?
No, but they can use the hate crime sentence enhancement to harshen the penalty.
What is victim blaming?
Shifting blame from offender to victim.
What is the relationship between victim blaming and reporting?
Victim blaming is a deterrent for people to report sexual violence.
What crimes are victim blaming most associated with?
SA and IPV, less so but also sometimes with property crimes.
What is the basis of a lot of victim blaming claims?
Implies that the victim is responsible for their victimization because they were engaging in risky behaviour and should’ve known better not to put themselves in that situation.
What part of the legal system does victim blaming come from? What concept?
The private legal system. Comes from the concept of contributory negligence, did the person do everything they couldve or shouldve to avoid the civil legal outcome?