Task 7 Flashcards
Theory of Mind
Understanding other people as people who have desires, their own beliefs and interpretations of the world that can differ from our own.
Mental representation
Persons set of beliefs about the world.
False belief task
Test of understanding mental representations.
Children hear a story about a child putting chocolate into a blue box and then leaving the room the mother changes it to a green box. Then they’re asked to guess where the boy is going to look for the chocolate.
Four year olds will say that he will look into the green box proving that they not understand that:
Boys beliefs about the world are different from how the world really is.
Boy will act on basis of his beliefs and not the actual state of the world
Sally Anne task
Simpler version of the false belief task with more salient features making it easier for children to succeed.
Children are presented with two dolls, Sally and Anne almost same procedure than false belief task.
4 year olds succeed while three year olds wouldn´t
Smarties task
Children are shown a box of smarties with pencils within once all this is shown to them they are asked to wonder what another child may think there is inside
younger than for year olds replied ´pencils´
Young infants seem to be unable to have any insight into their own minds and aknowledge that before they were shown what was inside they thought they were smarties
Distinguishing mental states in language with children of 2 and 3 years old
2: Children use internal words that refer to internal
states of perception or emotion such as I see or I want
3: Children use cognitive terms such as know think or remember.They can distinguish between menbtal states and external reality
Understanding the relationship between seeing and knowing ages 2 3 and 4
2: Children understand relationship between seeing and knowing.
Demonstration/ They were asked to show a picture within a box to someone else and relaized that they needed to change the angle so that other person could see it.
3: Childre understand that different people can have different point of view of the same object.
Demonstration: A card with different drawings to each side is shown to the children one side towards them the other to another person then theyre asked to tell what the other person is seeing
4: Children realize that people may have different views of object that is equally visible to both.
Demonstration: Childs were shown a picture of a turtle flat on the bale while the experimenter sat in front of them when asked if the experimenter saw it upwards or backwards it wasn´ùt till age 4 that they did notice.
Children have difficulties in tasks that involve distinguishing appearance and reality. Ages 3 and 4
Demonstration: They were shown a sponge that from afar looked like a rock once they approached to it they were allowed to feel it within their own hands. They were asked how does it look like? and what is it really?
3: They answered both a sponge they cant understand that there´s different interpretations for an object.
also dont realize that appearance of an boject is a representation that can be changed.
4: They realize there could be multiple representations of an object but that only one is correct, thus, understanding that people can have true and false beliefs
Predicting behavior ages 2 and 3
2: They understand that poeple have desires and that this may influence the way they act.
Demonstration/ Sam wants to find a rabbit that is in ether one whole or another then sam looks into one hole and children are asked whether they think sam will look into the other hol eor not they answered he wouldnt if finds the rabbit and he would if he doesnt
3: Children undesrtand that peiple have their own beliefs about the world in addition to desires
Demonstration: Children were shown a shelf and a box with books, the character in question is looking for books and doesnt know there are some in the toy box. kids are asked where she is going to look
Though they still dont understand that people may act in innacurate beliefs
When is the Theory of Mind achieved?
Children above 4 years old pass the fals ebelief tasks whil eyounger than that still struggle.
Differences between from age 4 and before age 4.
From age 4 : Children understand false belief and that other people behaviors may be based on incorrect assumptions about the world.
Before age 4: Children (3 specially) may have some understanding of belief but are unaware of their own understanding.
At age three when confronted with the boxes and chocolate case they still although failing linger their look s a little longer on the box boy would have reallly looked at compared with 2 years olds.
Theory of mind after 4 years of age
After undesrtanding that behavior is based on representations of the world children realize also that emotional reponses are also based on a persons representation.
Demonstration: A character named Ellie only likes to drink coke, the someon eputs milk on her coke without her noticing and children are asked how sould she feel when sees the can of coke.
4 shell be sad
5 shell be happy
Understanding of surprise and deception
This can only be achieved when the understanding of false belief is achieved
It requires an understanding that representation and own beliefs about the world are about to be disconfirmed
They will also become aware of deceptive behavior
3 not understanding of deception at all
4 no idea how to deceive but perform. improved after a coupl of trials
5 pros
First and second order beliefs:
First: One that involves about having a belief about someone having a belief( i think that she thinks that)7
Second: one that involves that someone can have beliefs about a third person ( I think that she thinks that he thinks that)
Theories about development of understanding the mind
These three suggested that a childs understanding of the mind is biased on development of their representational abilities: Welman, Perner and Leslie.
Welman: mind develops in three phases:
years 2 3 and 4
Perner: Metarepresentation
Leslie: 18 months of age children start to demonstrate pretend play and assumed that for children to pretend play they have to undesrtand what is in the mind of the children they re playing with.(metarepresentation)
Harris:Children understand others minds without neccessarily understanding that others have mental representations too.( simulation theory)