Social Policy Flashcards
what is social policy?
- plans or actions set out by the government with a specific aim
what are the two types of social policy?
- direct: compulsory education, exam changes
- indirect: benefits, family policies
Left Wing: labour
- believe in equality for all
- family diversity
- change
- modernising
- social services,
- welfare support
- reform to help disadvantaged people
Right Wing: conservatives
- believe in working hard
- looking after yourself
- capitalism
- free market
- nuclear family
- traditional values
- low taxes
- not changing too much
Nazi Germany Family Policy:
- the Mother’s Cross policy:
- rewards were offered to mothers with the most children
Back to Basics Campaign (1990’s):
- introduced by conservative government
- aims:
- herald the virtues of traditional family views
- impact:
- demonise lone-parent families
- increase social stigma attached to lone-parent families
Child Support Act (1991):
- introduced by conservative government
- aims:
- force absent fathers to pay for maintenance of their children
- impact:
- reducing welfare payments to lone mothers
Family Law Act (1996):
- aims:
- prevents couples from divorcing unless they have been married for a year
- decrease divorce
- impact:
- support the institution of marriage
- increase empty shell marriages
Supporting Families Document (1998):
- aims:
- suggested ways provided better service and support for parents
- emphasis on all families
- not to intervene in family life
- not to pressure people into preferred family type
- not to force married couples to stay together
- impact:
- supporting family diversity
- increase family diversity
New Deal (2001):
- introduced by labour government
- aims:
- help people find paid employment
- impact:
- aimed at matri-focal lone-parent families
Sure Start Programme:
- aims:
- provide health and support services for low-income families with young children
-impact:
- early start
- free nursery
- supporting family diversity
Civil Partnerships:
- introduced by the new labour government
- aims:
- new legal
- impact:
- reduced social stigma
Functionalism: Fletcher (1996)
- help families perform their functions more effectively
- argues that the introduction of health, education and housing policies led to a welfare state that supports the family
Evaluation of Functionalism:
- feminists argue that policies often benefit men at the expense of women
- marxists argue that some policies turn the clock backwards
- also assumed that some policies made family life better
e.g ‘march of progress’
The New Right:
- criticism: many welfare policies undermine the family’s self-reliance by providing generous benefits
- Murray (1984) benefits ‘preserve incentives’ regarding irresponsible behaviour
-favour cutting welfare spending
Evaluation of the New Right:
- feminists believe in the New Right views are an attempt to justify the patriarchal nuclear family = opposes women
- nuclear family is ‘not’ natural but socially constructed
New Labour:
- political perspective
- more accepting of family diversity
- introduced civil partnership act
- introduced legislation to allow cohabiting couples to adopt
-some policies can improve family life
Feminism: Land (1978)
- policies often assume the patriarchal family to be the norm
- policies act as a self-fulfilling prophecy, actually helping to reproduce this family
Marxism:
- social institutions including policies serve the interests of capitalism
- policies of the families often result form the need of capitalism
The Coalition Government (2010-15):
- conservative party division between what
Richard Hayton (2010) calls: - modernists: more diverse, willing to accept and reflect this in their policies
- traditionalist: favour a New Right view and reject diversity as morally wrong
Communist Romania:
- former gov 1980’s falling living standards decline
- introduced a series of policies to try and drive up the birth rate
Functionalism:
- see society as built on harmony and consensus and free from major conflicts
- Ronald Fletcher: 1966
- assumes there is a march of progress
- all members benefit from social policies
Donzelot: policing the family
- Jacques Donzelot (1977) offers a different perspective
- had a conflict view of society
- sees policies as a form of state power and control over family
Donzelot uses Michael Foucault’s (1976):
- concept of surveillance
_foucalt’s sees power as a diffused spread throughout society and found within relationships
social policies that effect families & households in the uk?
- divorce act (1969 5yrs & 19841 year for divorce) : only ended unless it was irretrievably broken & neither could prove ‘fault’
- civil partnership (2003 & 2004)
changes to income support for lone parents since 2014:
- Job Seekers Allowance = out of work benefit for those who aren’t working
Rachel Condry (2007):
- the state may seek to control & regulate family life by imposing
compulsory parenting orders through courts
The New Right: Brenda Almond (2006):
- argues that laws making a divorce easier to undermines the idea of marriage as a life long commitment
- civil partnership introduction makes heterosexual couples less superior to their domestic set up
- the laws discriminate against conventional families
Lone Parents Welfare Policy & the dependency culture:
- Charles Murray (1984-90) criticises welfare policy for undermining traditional nuclear families and encourages dysfunctional family types
- negative impact on boys and lead to a life of crime and lack of role-models
encourages dependency culture and a lack of self/reliance:
- the successful socialisation of the young
- the maintainable of the work ethic among men
New Right Solutions:
- place tighter policy restrictions on who is eligible for benefits
Criticism of the New Right:
- Pam Abbcott and Clair Wallace (1992) argue that cutting benefits would simply drive many poor families into even greater poverty and make men even less self-reliant
Gender Regimes:
- Eileen Drew (1995) uses the concept of ‘gender regimes’ to describe how social policies in different countries can either encourage or discourage gender equality in the families and at work = European countries encourage more individualistic regimes
Two Types of GR:
- familistic gender regimes:
policies are based on traditional gender division - Greece’s little state welfare on public ally funded childcare
- traditional division of labour
- individualistic regimes:
- where policies are based on the belief that husbands and wives should be treated the same
- Sweden, husband and wives are equally responsible for both breadwinning and domestic tasks