Science as a belief system Flashcards
What is the impact of Science ?
Global Warming
Pollution
Weapons of mass destruction
What does Karl Popper put forward ?
The principle of falsification, that says a belief system should be subject to challanges
What are the CUDOS norms
Communism
Universalism
Disinterestedness
Organised Scepticism
What is meant by closed belif systems ?
The idea that religion claims absolute truth and cannot be challenged
What does Horton (1973) say ?
That science is an open belief system but religion is closed
What does Polanyi (1958) say ?
All belief systems have 3 devices that sustain them in the face of contradictory evidence:
Circulatory
Subsidiary explanation’s
Denial of Legitimacy to rivals
What does Khun say about science as a closed belief system ?
Science sets out shared assumptions based on periods of time
What does Woolgar’s ‘Little green men’ study find ?
Scientists are reluctant to publish evidence which contradicts existing knowledge