NFS284: Carb 3 Flashcards
Carbohydrates and health
types of nutrition research
- laboratory studies
- Epidemiological studies
- human intervention / clinical trials
weakness of lab studies
Cannot necessarily apply to humans
Epidemiological studies
Determine incidence & distribution of diseases in a population
Epidemiological studies are divided into…
- cross-sectional
- case control
- prospective cohort
Cross sectional study
Collect data from a population at one specific point in time.
Aim: to provide data on the entire population sampled
Case control study
two existing groups differing in outcome are identified and compared on the basis of some supposed causal attribute
Prospective cohort study
Divide population into groups, and follow them over time to see outcome
Strengths of epidemiological studies
- suggest causes for disease
- develop new hypothesis that can be tested using lab studies
weakness of epidemiological studies
- confounding variables
- no cause/effect
Clinical trials
test effects of specific factors in humans
Clinical trials are divided into…
- mechanistic studies
- non-randomized trials
- randomized trials
Strengths of clinical trials
- control some conditions
- determine cause & effect
Weaknesses of clinical trials
- results don’t apply to everyone
- ethics
How to judge when studies show different things? How do we know who to trust?
Quality of evidence
Subdivisions of quality of evidence
Level 1A
Level 1B: not randomized experiment / great cohort study
Level 2
Level 3: not randomized clinical trial / cohort
Level 4
Does sugar cause diabetes?
Very little support
Does sugar cause high glycaemic response?
no
Does sugar cause tooth decay?
Contributing factor, along with…
Micro-organisms
Host
Time
Substrate
Does sugar cause heart attacks?
No
What factor indicates high risk for diabetes?
High GI
Does sugar contribute to heart attacks?
No
What factor indicates risk for heart attack?
higher GI = 31% increase in risk
Does sugar cause hyperactivity in children?
Maybe, but not likely
Due to other factors associated with events that require sugar intake
Does sugar cause obesity in children?
Yes
Increased sugar intake from soft drinks directly linked to increased weight & BMI
Formula: odds
P(event occurs) / P(event does not occur)
Formula: odds ratio
Odds in treatment group / odds in control group