Issues and Debates L4 - 7 Flashcards
Determinism:
Idea that traits and behaviours are outside of out control due to either internal or external factors that we have no control over
Hard determinism (fatalism):
View that internal and external forces are outside of our conttol
What are the 3 types of hard determinism?
- Biological determinism
- Environmental determinism
- Psychic determinism
Biological determinism:
Idea that all human behaviour is innate and determined by genes
Environmental determinism: (2)
- Idea that behaviour is determined by forces outside the individual
- Behaviour is caused by previous experience learnt through classical/operant conditioning
Psychic determinism:
- Idea that traits and behaviours are governed by unconscious instincts and drives
- Cause of behaviour rooted in childhood experiences
Give one example of a theory that shows psychic determinism:
Internal working model, where future relationships are based on childhood attachment type
Soft determinism and who was the first to come up with this:
- James (1980)
- Behaviour is constrained by environmental or biological make-up but only to a certain extent
Which approach did soft determinism become an important aspect of?
Cognitive approach
Which 3 approaches did hard determinism become an important aspect of?
- Psychic
- Biological
- Behavioural
Free will:
- Individuals are free to choose their behaviour and are self-determined
- Does not deny influence of biology and environment
Which approach advocates for free will and why?
- Humanistic approach
- Without self-determination, self-actualisation is not possible
Strengths and weaknesses of free will in an approach: (+3, -1)
+ Face validity –> everyday experiences seem like we are constantly exercising free will
+ Research support for locus of control (Rotter)
+ Application to legal system –> all citizens responsible for actions at age of 10 onwards
- Neurological counter evidence –> Siong Soon et al (2008)
How does research support for locus of control show the existence of free will?
- Rotter says that those who have an internal locus of control believe that they can change their behaviour
- There has been research supporting this, which shows the existence of free will
Siong Soon et al (2008):
- Researchers found that decision to press a button w/ either left or right hand was made in the brain 10 secs before pp was aware they had chosen
- Shows decisions are determined