Forensic Psychology L1 - 4 Flashcards
Why is offender profiling used?
To narrow down the list of likely suspects for a crime
What is offender profiling?
Characteristics of offender can be deduced from details of the offence and crime scene
What do profiling methods usually involve?
Careful scrutiny and analysis of evidence
Top-down approach:
1) Templates of organised and disorganised offender are pre-existing in profiler’s mind
2) Evidence from crime scene are then used to fit the offender into one of these categories
Features of organised offenders:
- Planned crime in advance
- Live in relationships
- High level of control/little evidence left at crime scene
- Often of average intelligence in a skilled occupation
Strengths and weaknesses of top-down profiling: (-5)
- Only applies to crimes involving macabre practices eg murder
- Too small and unrepresentative sample to base a typology system
- Not valid to rely on self-report data from convicted serial killers –> Canter (2004)
- Organised and disorganised distinction is too simplistic –> Holmes (1989)
- No evidence for disorganised type –> Canter et al (2004)
Why is that common offences do not lend itself to top-down profiling?
The crime scene reveals little about offender
Why is top-down profiling too small and unrepresentative to base a typology system on?
The organised or disorganised distinction was developed based on interviews w/ 36 sexually motivated serial killers in USA
What did Holmes (1989) suggest about types of serial killers?
- Visionary serial killer –> kill because God/devil directs them to
- Mission serial killer –> kill to eradicate a grp of ‘undesirable’ ppl
- Hedonistic serial killer –> kill for the thrill
- Power serial killer –> kill to have complete control over victims
Canter et al (2004):
- Analysed data from 100 murders in USA thought to be disorganised/organised killers
- Evidence suggested for organised type but not for disorganised
What is the bottom-up approach and what is its aim?
- Profile is data-driven and emerges as profiler engages in rigorous scrutiny of offence details
- Generate pic of offender
Which theory is grounded in psychological theory?
Bottom-up approach
What is the aim of investigative psychology?
Establish a statistical database of behaviours which occur at crime scene and characteristics of offenders who carry these out
What are these characteristics used to do?
Matched against a database to help determine whether multiple offences are linked and likely to have been committed by the same person
Interpersonal coherence:
The way the offender behaves at the crime scene is similar to how they would in real life
What other variable is crucial to the crime?
Time and place