Issues and Debates Flashcards
in animal research guide lines how should animals be cared for
- animals must be housed when they are not being studied
- animals must have companions if appropriate to their species
how do animal ethics guidelines minimise impact on animals
- should should use the minimum amount of animals that is required
- when possible alternatives must be used such as videos rather than live animals
Ethical issues in research - Social
-obedience research carries the risk of causing psychological harm
- however, issues of ethics were essential for the results
- social psych in the 50s and 60s would be considered wrong, for example lack of right to withdraw
Ethical issues in research - Cognitive
- brain damage patients concern for protecting right to privacy and memory of consent
- cognitive psych rarely goes against BPS Guidelines
- use of filed experiments causes difficulty in gaining informed consent
Ethical issues in research - Biological
- as tech has improved, access to models of brains an animals are more accessible
- can be argued that Pps leave a study with more knowledge that might change the way they think of themselves
- invasive surgeries on animals
Ethical issues in research - Learning
- skinner used food deprivation to encourage animals to do tasks
- pavlova dogs were immobilised which could lead to excessive stress
- OP can lead to learned behaviours that can change someone
Ethical Issues in research - Clinical
- in new drug treatments, Pps may be subjected to side effects
- Sz patients are vulnerable and should be cared for to not cause unnecessary harm
Ethical issues in research - Sherif
- children were not allowed to call home causing stress
- prizes of pocket knives were given to adolescents (unnessecary risk)
- parents were not informed of the study
Ethical Issues in research - Baddeley
- Baddeley used necessary deception to avoid demand characteristics (they did not know the full aims), which would have affected informed consent. - - he did gain their consent to take part.
- overall highly ethical
Ethical issues in research - Raine et al
- the murderers were taken off their meds 2 weeks prior which could reduce QOL
- they were injected with a radioactive substance which can cause harm
- all Pps provided consent to take part in the study
Ethical issues in research - Watson and Rayner
- the mother withdrew Albert showing that alberts was subjugated to high levels of stress
- Little Albert was unable to give his consent and didnt know what was happening
- Researchers did not know how long effects would last
Ethical issues in research - Rosenhan
- Pseudo patients had no way out of the hospital which could be stressful
- The patients were subjected to harsh treatment from the staff and witnessed abuse
Practical issues - Social
- Burger, had a standardised procedure which was controlled which lead to similar results
- Milgram, lacked generalisability
Practical issues - Cognitive
- case studies can not be generalised to the population
- Bartletts war of the Ghost cannot be replicated as Pps were retested at random times
Practical issues - Learning
- Pavlovs Dogs have both low generalisability and ecological validity
- Bandura has standardised procedure
Practical issues - Biological
- Leve et al, had high generalisability as he used 360 families
- Brendgen had ecological validity and inter rater reliability
Practical issues - Clinical
- Goldstein, longitudinal study
- Williams et al had set procedure
For practical issues what do you use to evaluate?
G
R
A
V
E
What is reductionism?
breaking something down into parts to study. then the findings from the ‘parts’ are put together.
What is Holism?
when something is studied as a whole
Reductionism - Social
- Latane in social impact theory reduces obedience to an equation and ignores interactions and other individuals
- Milgram reduces obedience to authority
Reductionism - Cognitive
- studying memory in the Lab is not the same as in real life, it ignores the environment
- the WMM divides the STM into slave systems without recognising the connections. this can be also be said about the MSMM
Reductionism - Learning
- Skinner explains behaviour as an outcome of previous behaviour
- Operant conditioning explains learned behaviour as a result of stimulus - response connection
Reductionism - Biological
- focusing on aggression when studying the brain means reducing behaviour to individual structures
- there are cultures that show higher levels of aggression which suggests SLT
- animal studies reduce what is being studied to a small peice of brain function
Reductionism - Clinical
- Simplifies a complex behaviour by purely focusing on biological factors
- the dopamine explanation over focuses on the biological explanation
- Family therapy is a good treatment plan as it considers multiple components
Reductionism - Sherif et al
- didn’t look at factors that could affect prejudice such as culture
- only looked at competition as instilling prejudice
- simplified aggression to verbal and physical
Reductionism - Baddeley
- there is more to memory than recall, for example the emotional meaning to words and memory
- was a lab study so did not account for environment
Reductionism - Raine et al
- Ignored environmental factors such as SLT
- Jim Fallon said trauma and trigger is needed
Reductionism - Watson and Rayner
- only looked as CC as a way to induce a phobia
- only looked at a simple specific phobia not complex
Reductionism - Rosenhan
- Symptoms of Sz was simplified to three words
- objective data was used more than subjective experience
Psych as a science - Social
- the intention for social psych was to become more scientific by using experiments
- milligram controlled variables to carefully manipulate
- however social psych cannot be said to be generalisable to the real world