Forensic Flashcards
defining crime
dynamic construct dependent on historical, social, cultural and political context
any behaviour that is unlawful and punished by the state
harmful to an individual/group/society
cultural issues in defining crime
definition varies cross-culturally
social construct
socially acceptable
minority influence
age and issue with crime
age of criminal responsibility varies from country to country
uk=10
Bulger case-2 10 year olds abducted, abused and killed a 2 year old
historical issues in defining crime
laws change over tine
what is socially acceptable changes
homosexuality
child abuse
circumstance and issues with defining crime
Actus reus
Mens rea
M’Naghten rule
Actus reus
a voluntary act that constitutes a crime
the person is in control
Mens rea
the intention to do the crime
M’Naghten rule
not knowing right from wrong
M’Naghten shot and killed prime ministers secretary believing that the prime minister was conspiring against him
measuring crime
official stats
government records of the total number of crimes reported to the police
produced annually
only some crimes get through the crime funnel and reported to the police
measuring crime
strengths of official stats
allows crime prevention strategies/policing initiatives
make historical comparisons to look at trends in crime
general trends reported from stats tend to be in agreement with trend increase/decrease
measuring crime
weaknesses of official stats
unreliable-underestimate true extent of crime
not all crimes get reported
policing priorities may distort official figures
measuring crime
victim surveys
British crime survey, England and Wales
sample of 50,000 households randomly selected
measuring crime
strengths of victim surveys
provides more information on the dark figure of crime
more consistent then official stats- 2006/07 official suggested 2% decrease where survey showed 3% increase
good sample size
measuring crime
weaknesses of victim surveys
uses retrospective data of the last year
doesn’t record victimless crime
sample drawn only from those with postal address-bias sample
measuring crime
offender surveys
conducted every year 2003-2006 in England and Wales
aimed to increase knowledge about young people and criminal behaviour
as well as measuring self-reported offending it looked at indications of re-offending, drug and alcohol use, role of co-offending and relationship between offender and victim
measuring crime
strengths of offender surveys
provide insight into hoe many people are responsible for certain offences
asking offenders about the offences can give a picture of reasons for their behaviour
best chance on raising the dark figure as they know what crime might occur and when
measuring crime
weaknesses of offender surveys
self-report impacts reliability
lack of accuracy in answers
unreliable responses: offenders may want to conceal some of the more serious crimes committed
historical explanation
lombroso
hisoritcal explanation
lombroso
criminals are separate species shape of face and head determine criminals based on homeless criminals used postmortoms atavistic atavistic form
lombroso
atavistic
the reappearance of a characteristic after several generations of absence
lombroso
atavistic form
certain individuals are born with a criminal personality which is a throwback to primitive forms
historic explanation
turvey
18 different characteristics
innate make up causes criminals
lombroso assumption
historical explanation
different features are related to different crimes
thin lips-muder
big nose-robber
hairy-sex offender
lomboro research
50000 bodies
383 italian criminals 21% has 1 atavistic trait and 43% had 5
strengths of lombroso historical explanation
can be studied scientifically
started research into criminals
weaknesses of lombroso historical explanation
androcentric-women are less evolved
not a representative sample-italian males
not reliable-subject
somatotypes
sheldon
endomorphic
mesomorphic
ectmorphic
somatotypes
endomorphic
short and fat
deceptive/violent
somatotypes
mesomorphic
tall and muscular
violent crimes
somatotypes
tall and skinny
petty thieves
strengths of somatotypes
supportive research Glueck and Glueck
Cortes and Gatti
supportive research on somatotypes
Glueck and Glueck
60% of delinquent sample were mesomorph and 31% of non-delinquent sample were mesomorph
supportive research on somatotypes
cortes and Gatti
57% of 100 delinquents were mesomorph compared with 19% of controls
weaknesses of somatotypes
assumes correlation was linked to causality (become mesomorph in prison/ select crime because of body type)
subjective
feldman
weaknesses of somatotypes
feldman
relationship can be explained by expectations
mesomorphs may catch police attention more/ influence sentencing