evidence for inequalities Flashcards
what are the 3 pieces of evidence for working class disadvantages in the workplace
- the equality trust / the inequality briefing
- Mac an Ghaill
- Willis
1- the equality trust
inequality in workplace
- 90% of earners average income= £12,969
- top 0.1% average income= £1,000,970
Mac an Ghaill
inequality in workplace
states that deindustrialisation has led to a ‘crisis of masculinity’amongst working class males- they face unemployment
Willis
inequality in workplace
- working class males see their futures as working as basic manual labour jobs like their fathers therefore they do not aspire for more.
- this prevents social mobility
what are the 3 pieces of evidence for working class disadvantage in education?
- bourdieu
- jackson
- the department for education
- Bourdieu
working class disadvantage- in education
- education system is biased towards the culture of the dominant classes
- main function of education is social reproduction (continuing class divisions)
- education discriminates the working class due to the lack of cultural capital to succeed
- hidden curriculum
Jackson
working class disadvantage- in education
- working class ladettes adopt anti-school attitudes
- they adopt assertive femininity around smoking and arguing with teachers
- as a result- they are negatively labelled by teachers.
The Department For Education
working class disadvantage- in education
- those who can get free school meals- avg GCSE grade above a 5= 34.4%
- those not eligable= 48.3%
what are the 3 pieces of evidence for working class disadvantage in the media?
- price
- jones
- milliband (marxist)
1- Price
working class disadvantage- in the media
- developed the concept of ‘poverty porn’ to describe programmes being exploited by the media for shock and entertainment purposes.
- encourages underclass to be condemned by the hard working middle and upper classes.
2- Jones
working class disadvantage- in the media
- discusses the use of the word ‘chav’- become a way of describing
- developed the concept of ‘chavtainment’ to portray under class in a negative light
- changed views of the working class from being described as ‘salt of the earth’ to ‘scum of the earth’
- e.g. little britain, skins, fresh meat.
3- Milliband (marxist)
working class disadvantage- in the media
- states that media is the new ‘opium of the people’
- distracts us from the working class masses and struggles in the capitalist society
- media is a short form of content which is endless.
what are the 3 pieces of evidence for working class disadvantage in in relation to crime?
- Walmsley et al
- coles
- harding
1- walmsley et al
working class disadvantage- in the media
41% of prisoners are from the lowest social classes. but only 19% of the overall population
2- coles
working class disadvantage- in relation to crume
found that if you are poor, you are more likely to commit a crime
3- Harding
working class disadvantage- in relation to crime
- metaphor of ‘the street casinos’ about working class playing a game that is addictive and like gambling
- study in lambeth london on gangs
what are the 3 pieces of evidence to show elderly disadvantage within the workplace?
- the national pensioners convention
- barrow and norris
- Johnson
the national pensioners convention
elderly disadvantage in the workplace
- 1 in 5 older people live below the poverty line
- majority of these are females living alone
barron & norris
elderly disadvantage in the workplace
- suggests that the elderly are more likely to be found in the secondary labour market
- this is defined by low pay, low status, no benifits.
Johnson
elderly disadvantage in the workplace
- suggested that agesim occurs in the workplace
- it is expressed through stereotypical assumptions of ones ability of a job due to theur age
- the older you get, the harder it is to get a job.
what are the 3 pieces of evidence to suggest elderly disadvantage in health?
- greengross
- the royal college of surgeons & age uk
- human rights watch
greengross
elderly disadvantage in health
- argues that the NHS is guilty of institutional ageism because older patients are treated differently
- e.g. young people have clear care plans linked with family, elderly are offered ‘end of life plans’
human rights watch
elderly disadvantage in health
- assessors appear not to understand their disabilities and social needs.
- social care assessments often have a significant impact on older peoples health, wellbeing & independence
- because they are the gateway to services
The royal college of surgeons & age uk (2014)
elderly disadvantage in health
- in some areas of the uk- no one over the age of 75 is offered crucial surgery for breast or bowel cancer and hip or knee replacements.
- despite legalisation making this illegal.
what are the 2 pieces of evidence that suggest elderly disadvantage in crime?
- age uk (2015)
- financial times (2015)
Age UK (2015)
elderly disadvantage in crime
- of those targeted of fraud scams, the financial loss for older victims was likely to be 2x as much than a younger age group
Financial times (2015)
elderly disadvatage in crime
- the number of 60+ in jail topped 4,000- more than double last years
- the number of inmates with dementia has risen
- cases of diabetes and hypertension has risen.
what are the 3 pieces of evidence for disadvantages for elderly in the media?
- carrigan and szmigin
- digital generational gap
- Landis
Landis
elderly disadvantage in the media
- the number of stereotypes in representations of older people
- they were depicted as ‘one-dimentional’
- grumpy old man, depressed/lonely, having wisdom, mentally deficient…
digital generational gap
elderly disadvantage in the media
- causes problems with employment
- older ppl are less comfortable using technology than the young
- feel unable to cope with the changes e.g. paperless banking & social media
carrigan and szmigin
elderly disadvantage in the media
- state that older people are ignored in the media advertisement- steretyped
- presented as ‘smelly & incompitent’
- seen as dependent on others
what are the 3 pieces of evidence suggesting youth disadvantage in the workplace?
- BBC three (2020)
- Ritzer
- the equality trust
BBC three (2020)
youth disadvantage in the workplace
- under 25s are treated much more harshly in the benifits system
- they dont get the same level of support as people over 25
Ritzer
youth disadvantage in the workplace
- young people are often on 0 hor contracts
& in McJobs (unsimulating, low-wage) e.g. the service industry.
the equality trust
youth disadvantage in the workplace
young people have been in a bad situation for the past decade with increasing rental, housing & accomidation costs.
what are the 2 pieces of evidence to suggest youth disadvantage in health
- youngpeopleshealth .org.uk
- the guardian
youngpeopleshealth .org.uk
youth disadvantage in health
- 75% of MH issues start before 24
- in 2014 19.1% children in yr 6 were obese
- in 2014 41,921 young people 10-24 were admitted to hospital for SH
the guardian (2019)
youth disadvantage in health
- by 2037, we will go from 6.5 million family carers to 9 million due to our ageing population.
- young people may soon find being asked to care for parents unpaid- may impact MH
what are the 2 pieces of evidence for youth disadvantage in crime
- harding
- jacobson
Harding
youth disadvantage in crime
- working class youths in london face deprivation & turn to crime for income
- harding calls it ‘street casino’ as they gamble their lives
- street capital is gained with commiting acts of deviance.
Jacobson
youth disadvantage in crime
found that children & youths in custody-
* 3/4 have absent fathers,
* half are runaways
* from care homes
* complex backgrounds
what are the 3 examples of youth disadvantage for media
- cohen
- women in journalism
- Griffin
Cohen
youth disadvantage in the media
- discussed negative labelling of youths in media
- labelled as ‘folk devil’
- self-fulfilling prophecy where youths ‘live down to their label’
Griffin
youth disadvantage in the media
states that youths are labelled by media in 3 ways:
- dysfunctional
- suffering a deficit
- deviant
women in journalism
youth disadvantage in the media
examined how teen boys were presented in national/local newspapers
1. negative language to describe them ‘thugs, scum, ferel, inhumane’
2. few stories showed them in a good light
3. teens were wary of other teens due to these stories.
what are the 3 pieces of evidence for female disadvantage in the media
- tuchman
- ferguson
- mulvey
what are the 3 pieces of evidence in female disadvantage in crime
- everyday sexism project- laura bates
- harding
- leonard
what are the 3 pieces of evidence for female disadvantage in the workplace
- the financial times
- Adkins
- laura bates- everyday sexism project
what are the 3 pieces of evidence for female disadvantage in education
- skelton
- colley
- kelly
ferguson
female disadvantage in the media
- conducted content analysis of womens magazines and counted number of times a topic was covered
- cult of femininity
- promotes idea that excellence is achieved through caring for others (marriage and family)
Tuchman
female disadvantage in the media
- argued narrow range of roles for women lead to their ‘symbolic annihilation’ in the media
- media condemns certain social groups e.g. women
mulvey
female disadvantage in the media
- notes typical ‘male gaze’
- women in the media are viewed through the eyes of hetrosexual men
- women are presented as passive objects of the male gaze
Harding
female disadvantage in crime
- studies gangs in souch london
- girls took on roles as “fixers” - used by males to hide drugs and weapons
- subject to abuse and sexual harrassment
leonard
female disadvantage in crime
- claims that judges label females as ‘doubley devient
- judge that not only have they broken laws but broken gender roles too- given a harsher punishment
everyday sexism project- laura bates
female disadvantage in crime
over 2 women a week in the UK are killed by a current/former partner
colley
female disadvantage in education
argues that subject choices are negatively influenced by…
* perception of gender roles
* subject preferences
* learning environment
Kelly
female disadvantage in education
- suggests that science is packaged as a boys subject
- boys are allowed to dominate the classrooms
- leads girls to be disengaged
skelton
female disadvantage in education
suggests that the hidden curriculum (e.g. attitudes to teachers) negatively influences subject choices
Adkins
female disadvantage in the workplace
- evidence of horizontal and vertical segregation
- study on themeparks
- males worked as ride operators and women worked in catering ect…
- women faced regular sexual harrassment
The Financial Times
female disadvantage in the workplace
- current gender pay gap suggests that if both a woman and man in the same level job worked for 1 calender year: a woman would be working for free from november
- biggest pay gap is in financial & insurance sector
Laura Bates- everyday sexism project
female disadvantage in the workplace
- in parliment- men outnumber women by 4 to 1
- only 18/108 high court judges are female
what are the 3 pieces of evidence of male disadvantage in the workplace?
- Dermott
- Farrell
- Benatar
dermott
male disadvantage in the workplace
men work longer hours than women, regardless of their status as fathers.
Farrell
male disadvantage in the workplace
- the ‘glass cellar’ - of the 25 professions ranked lowest, 24 of them are 85%+ male dominated
- e.g. roofer, welder, sewer maintinance
Benatar
male disadvantage in the workplace
- in his book ‘the second sexism’, states that…
- the least desirable and most dangerous jobs, with the least pay, are dominated by men
what are the 3 pieces of evidence of male disadvantage in crime?
- messerschmitdt
- cambell
- faludi
Messerschmidt
male disadvantage in crime
argues that gangs act as a location for ‘doing masculinity’ which has to be ‘accomplished or proven’
Cambell
male disadvantage in crime
- by abandoning certain communities, it denies men access to legitimate masculine status through academic success/employment
- so they turn to violence and antisocial behaviour to express masculinity.
Faludi
male disadvantage in crime
- young males commiting criminal acts is not ‘deviant’ at all
- but an expression of the qualities we admire in males as society: toughness, bravery & strength.
what are the 3 pieces of evidence of male disadvantage in the media?
- sewell
- Eastthorpe
- REACH- media monitoring project
sewell
male disadvantage in the media
- black carribean boys turned to rapper rolemodels in the media due to lacking father figures
- hypermasculine negative role models lead boys to deviant antischool subcultures
eastthorpe
male disadvantage in the media
- hollywood films and computer games
- transmit the idea that masculinity is based on strength, aggression and violence
- it is biologically determined and a natural goal for boys to achieve
REACH- media monitoring project
male disadvantage in the media
- found that coverage of young black males in the news, often links them to violent crimes
- creates a negative image of black males
- provides negative stereotypes
what are the 3 pieces of evidence of male disadvantage in education?
- willis
- mitsos and browne
- department for education
Willis
male disadvantage in education
- working class ‘lads’ are fatastic about their futures becuase they follow their fathers footsteps
- leading them to low status, basic low pay jobs
- develop antischool attitudes
mitsos and browne
department for education
what are the 3 pieces of evidence for ethnic minority disadvantage in the workplace?
- GOV.UK
- wood et al
- parkin
Gov.uk
ethnic minority disadvantage in the workplace
ethnic group’s Pakistani and Bangladeshi have the lowest employment rates; being 55%.
Parkin
ethnic minority disadvantage in the workplace
- ethnic minorities use social closure to prevent ethnic minorities from reaching positions of authority and status,
- as a result, they face a concrete ceiling in the workplace.
what are the 3 pieces of evidence for ethnic minority disadvantage in education?
- Mirza
- the department for education
- Gillborn
Mirza
ethnic minority disadvantage in the education
- studied black caribbean gitls and found girls and found they faced institutional racism and negative labelling from teachers
- although, they resisted this and acheived highly.
the department of education
ethnic minority disadvantage in education
- studied gcse results with the “avg attainment 8 score”
- white british= 46.1%
- Black carribean= 39.6%
- white british outperform the carribean
Gillborne
ethnic minority disadvantage in education
- argues that black carribean boys face institutional racism at school
- they are put into lower sets- limiting their success
- this can narrow future opportunities
what are the 3 pieces of evidence for ethnic minority disadvantage in media?
- Van Dijk
- Alexander
- children now- fair play
van dijk
ethnic minority disadvantage in the media
- content analysis to study representations of ethnic groups
- found a media stereotype of black people in 5 ways: criminal, abnormal, a threat, unimportant and dependent
- suggest their cultural practices are abnormal.
Alexander
ethnic minority disadvantage in media
- asian youths in london are unfairly targeted by police and media
- myth of asian gangs where media reported violent crashes between black and asian gangs.
- asian boys criminalised due to islamaphobia
children now- fair play (2001)
ethnic minority disadvantage in media
- ethnic minorities were stereotyped in video games
- 86% of heros were white
- 86% of black female characters were presented as victims of violence.
what are the 3 pieces of evidence for ethnic minority disadvantage in crime?
- Hood
- social trends survey
- the lammy report
Hood
ethnic minority disadvantage in crime
- black men were more likely than white men to recieve custodial sentences for offences that have fines and community service
- proof of institutional racism in the police force
The lammy report
ethnic minority disadvantage in crime
- over 40% of black people in custody are from BAME backgrounds
- BAME men & women make up 25% of prisoners
- the % of BAME prisoners increased to 41% in 2016
social trends survey
ethnic minority disadvantage in crime
black people are 7x more likely to be stopped and searched than white people.