Ethnicity and Achievement Internal Factors Flashcards
Who studies Labelling and Teacher racism?
Gilborn and Youdell
What did Gilborn and Youdell find out in Labelling and Teacher racism?
Teachers hold racialised expectations of students in different ethnic groups, leading to underachievement
What did Gilborn and Youdell find out about Black students?
Teachers expect them to have more discipline problems ( Anti-authority), as a result they are placed in lower streams
What did Gilborn and Youdell find out about Asian students?
Teachers assumed they had a lower grasp of English, so often left them out of class discussions and used simplistic language to them.
Resulting in low self esteem, isolated and their names are often mispronounced.
What is an example of Labelling and Teacher racism towards Asians?
The Asian girls are seen as passive, docile and quiet
That the Chinese succeed in the ‘wrong’ way, they’re hardworking BUT passive.
What is an example of Labelling and Teacher racism towards Blacks?
High exclusion rates impacting achievement, more likely to be placed in isolation room aswell because of the stereotype.
Who did the study of Labelling and Teacher racism?
Archer
What does Archer study?
Ideal pupil identity = White middle class, heterosexual
Pathological pupil identity = Feminised, oppressed sexuality, succeeding via hard work
Demonised pupil identity = Black & White working class, hyper sexualised identity.
Who are the critics of Labelling and Teacher Racism?
Fuller Mac and Ghail
What did Fuller Mac and Ghail critique?
The black girls were placed in lower streams and achieved well despite the negative racist stereotypes.
Labelling does not always reflect a negative paradigm
Who studies the Ethnocentric Curriculum?
Tronya Williams and Ball
What did Tronya Williams and Ball find out?
That the curriculum favours white culture whilst disregarding others
Explain more about Tronya and Ball’s findings
Tronya = European languages taught more than Asian, the national curriculum is ‘specifically British’
Ball = The national curriculum creates the “Mythical age of empire and past glories”, ignoring Black and Asian history overall.
What is an example of an Ethnocentric Curriculum?
Euro languages taught more; Spanish, French and isolating others like Urdu or Greek.
Not permitting colourful hairstyles as natural fit in more with the middle class habitus
Who did the study of Ethnocentric Curriculum?
Board
What did Board study?
The curriculum produced underachievement
- Produces the inferior black people image, thus lowering self esteem, leading to failure
- The British presented as bringing civilisation to the ‘primitive’ people they colonised
What is the criticism of the Ethnocentric Curriculum?
- School’s culture day
- School’s acknowledgement of religious holidays, not just Christmas, but also Eid.
Who studies Marketisation and Selection?
Gilborn and RoithMayr