Ethics / law Flashcards
what are the four ethical principles / pillars?
- Autonomy: the patient has the right to make their own decisions and act upon them
- Beneficence: act in the patient’s best interest
- Non-maleficence: do no harm
- Justice: ensure fairness (distribute resources, including your time and skill, equitably)
Describe what questions you would ask yourself in each of the 4 ethical principles?
- Autonomy: does the patient lack capacity? can the decision be deferred? the patient has the right to refuse treatment?
- Beneficence: think both medical for the patient and also for others around them, family? friends?
- Non-maleficence: should treatment be forced upon a patient if it is the “right” thing to do? does this lose trust in doctors?
- Justice: bear in mind other patients and staff?
What is paternalism?
- the idea that “the doctor knows best”
Species used in biomedical research…
What are some of the arguments FOR vaccines?
What are some of the arguments AGAINST vaccines?
Describe sources that a doctor could use to get information on the different medications that a patient may be taking
- Ask relatives
- Contact the GP
- Contact their local pharmacist
- Check patient’s own list of medication
- Examine previous hospital notes if applicable
Describe act certainty vs omission possibility in the case of using animals in biomedical research.
- Act certainty vs omission possibilty: animals will surely suffer by the act, humans might suffer without the research
What are the 5 rules of ethical (human) research?
Mother worried about vaccine, she asks “is it 100% safe?”, how should a doctor answer this truthfully?
- All vaccines carry some degree of risk, but evidence for this vaccine suggests that it is safe
Describe four ways in which Wakefield’s paper was ethically problematic.
- He falsified information claiming it had been approved by a research ethics committee
- The procedures involved were invasive and not clearly justified
- The justification for the research was not clear
- Wakefield had an undisclosed conflict of interest
Describe the legal elements of capacity
- Being able to understand information
- Retain information
- Process information
- Communicate one’s decision
- (Relate to a specific moment in time)
A patient is not deemed to have capacity, a family member phones the doctor and wishes to be given information about the patient, how should the doctor address the patient’s confidentiality in this scenario?
- If the patient lacks capacity, then the doctor must act in the patient’s best interest (beneficence)
- In determining the patient’s best interest, the doctor is under a duty to consult with the patient’s next of kin
When addressing concerns about safeguarding, describe four ethical issues that clinical teams should consider when sharing clinical or personal information
- The patient’s consent to disclose
- The patient’s capacity
- The patient’s autonomy
- The relationship between the patient and their carer
- Consequences of disclosure (best interest of patient)
Describe three key principles of a palliative care approach
- Provides relief from pain
- Intends neither to hasten or postpone death
- Integrates the physical, psychological, and spiritual aspects of patient care (holistic)
- Offers a support system to help the family cope