Disintergration Of The Political Nation Flashcards
Several groups can be blamed for failure to reach a settlement
Charles
Parliament
- independents
- Presbyterians
Army
- officers
- rank and file
Scots
Levellers and other radicals
Why would it be difficult to reach a settlement
Army
Charles
Divisions in parliament
Score
Name the 6 major attempts to negotiate with king 1642-47 and when
Nineteen propositions - June 1642 Oxford Proposals - Mar 1643 Uxbridge proposals - Jan 1645 Propositions of Newcastle - July 1646 Head of proposals - Aug 1647 Four Bills - Dec 1647
Final attempts at negotiation following the second civil war and when
Treat of Newport - Sept 1648
Main points of the nineteen propositions
Parliament every 3 years
King to accept militia ordinance
Parliament to approve of privy councillors
Parliament to approve sixteen officers of state
Parliament to approve teachers and governors of kings children
Church government to be reformed with Parliaments advice
Existing catholic laws to be put in place
Main points of the oxford proposals
New Parliament every 3 years
King to settle (militia) w kings advice
Bishops etc abolished from church
Bishops abolished
Existing laws of Catholics to be enforced
2 royalists now to be pardoned
2 dismissals from office for life
Main points of the Uxbridge proposals
New Parliament every 3 years
Militia to be settled my commissioners named by Parliament
Parliament to nominate 13 officers of state
Church gov- bishops etc abolished- Westminister Assembly to reform
Existing laws on Catholics to be enforced
58 royalists not to be pardoned
48 dismissals from office for life
Main points of propositions of Newcastle
New Parliament every 3 years
Parliament to control militia for 20 years
Parliament to nominate 13 officers of state
Church gov - bishops etc abolished, Presbyterian church for 3 year trial
Existing laws on Catholics to be enforced
58 Royalists not to be pardoned
48 dismissals from office for life
Main points of Head of the Proposals
New Parliament every 2 years
Parliament to control militia 10 years
Parliament to nominate officers of state for 10 years
Royal family to be restored without personal constraints
Church gov- bishops cannot coerce; no Presbyterian church
Existing laws on Catholics enforced
7 royalists not to be pardoned
Parliaments enemies dismissed from office for 5 years
Main points of 4 bills
New Parliament every 2 years
Parliament to control militia for 20 years
Church gov - Bishops etc abolished- Presbyterian church for 3 year trial
58 royalists not to be pardoned
48 dismissals from office for life
Issues dividing parliament 1646
Presbyterian v independents
Overview
During war peace party evolved into Presbyterian party, mainly as a result of Scottish alliance.
Leader =Holles
At end of war - Presbyterians were the dominant group in HOC
Independent party evolved out of War Party 1643
In reaction against Scottish alliance which ‘war party’ negotiated
Their name came from their support for ‘independent’ religious sects and from their opposition to Scottish interference.
Main power in independents was not in parliament but the new model army
Issues dividing parliament
Key members of presbyterians and independents 1646
Presbyterians:
Holley
Manchester
Essex
Independents Saye and sele Haselrig Ireton Cromwell
Issues dividing parliament 1646
Presbyterian v independents
King
Presbyterian:
King is indispensable. Now that his evil advisors have been defeated, Charles must be given benefit of doubt and returned to power on minimal terms
Independent:
King cannot he trusted. He must be forced to accept further limits on his sovereign powers. Parliament must not surrender it’s advantage in its haste to reach a settlement
Issues dividing parliament 1646
Presbyterian v independents
Scottish
Presbyterian:
Scots are our allies. The Solemn League and Covenant is the best guarantee of social and religious stability.
Independents
The Scots are interfering in England affairs.
They are opposed to religious freedom
Issues dividing parliament 1646
Presbyterian v independents
Taxes and the army
Presbyterian
Lower taxes. The nation needs to get back to normal ASAP. We must not limit the power of the country committees and return the country to traditional forms of government.
-disband he new model army. The national cant afford maintaining it. It is dangerous - radical religious sects such as levellers. Complaints from all over the country about soldiers lack of discipline
Independents:
Higher taxes will have to be endured for time being. We must not falter at the last hurdle.
Failure to not reach s settlement is not the army’s fault. The committees set up during the war are full of corruption and prolong nation’s agony. They need to be brought to heel.
New model army is professional and has discipline
They better claim to represent people that king parliament. Some Presbyterian MPs are misrepresenting the army in parliament. They should be excluded.
Issues dividing parliament 1646
Presbyterian v independents
Religion
Presbyterian:
A Presbyterian church for the whole country. This offers the best chance of restoring religious unity, stamping out the radical sects and restoring social order. It will built religious units in the three Kingston’s of England, Ireland and Scotland
Independents:
Religious toleration for Protestants. There is not only 1 right way of worship
Parliament has accepted the sacrifices of many soldiers who fought to free the nation from religious intolerance. The Presbyterians threaten to replace one king of tyranny with another
When was the propositions of Newcastle
July 1646
Why did the propositions of Newcastle come about
Their was resentment among English parliamentarians that the king was in the hands of the Scots- tension had increased after an intercepted letter revealed that secret negotiations had passed between the king and Scot earlier in the year
Fearing alliance w Parliament = under threat.
Committee of Estates in Edinburgh instructed Scottish commissioners in London to consent to Parliament’s proposals, even thought they fell short of the Covenanters’ ideal in the settlement of religion
How many clauses did the propositions of Newcastle have
19
Name some of the newcastle propositions
King was to sign covenant and an Act was to be passed imposing it on all his subjects
Episcopacy abolished (catholic’s and arminians hate) The church in England and Ireland was to be reformed along Presbyterian lines as directed by parliament and the Assmebly of divines (independent don’t like)
The armed forces and militia were to be controlled by parliament for a period of 20 years
Strict laws against Catholics etc