Cream Pack Flashcards
What is a Confederate?
A person who takes part in the research but is not a true participant
What is the Aim of the BPS Code of Ethics and Conduct (2009)?
It provides ethical standards which apply to all psychologists
What are the reasons why ethical issues must be considered in psychological research?
- To ensure the professional reputation of psychology is high
- To protect human participants from mental and physical harm
What is the underlying philosophical approach of the BPS Code of Ethics and Conduct (2009)?
‘Do unto others as you would be done’
What does the underlying philosophical approach of the BPS code of ethics and conduct mean for psychologists actually carrying out research on human participants?
- Ensure safety of human participants so no harm is done
- Maintain high standards of confidentiality because if they wouldn’t like it done to themselves, they shouldn’t do it to others
What are the 4 main ethical principles of the BPS code of ethics and conduct (2009)?
- Respect
- Competence
- Responsibility
- Integrity
What are the advantages of following ethical guidelines when carrying out psychological research on humans?
- Society’s moral standards are maintained - psychologists must adhere to professional values if society is to see their research as having credibility + status
- Ps protected from physical harm
- Maintains reputation of the discipline + profession
- Ethical problems in study won’t get in the way of research being replicated
What are the disadvantages of following ethical guidelines when carrying out psychological research on humans?
- Understanding of human behaviour is restricted - as can’t do covert observation of private behaviour that’s behind closed doors which reveals darker side of human behaviour
- Difficult to study extreme behaviours or controversial topics - so credibility of psychological research findings may be lowered
- Ethical guidelines constrain research in psychology and therefore reduce its validity
What are the reasons why animals should be used in psychological research?
- Research is highly reliable because of well controlled standardised lab experiments which are easily replication - animals are good participants
- Similar to humans in brain structure + neurotransmitters as humans
What are the Reasons for Conducting Animal Research in Psychology?
- Ethical Reasons
- Similarities to humans
- Animals are good participants
- Theoretical knowledge
- Practical application of animal findings
What are the Ethical Reasons for Conducting Animal Research in Psychology?
- Many experiments are unethical for human testing, but important enough to be justified for animal testing
- Van den Oever (2008) - trained rats to self-administer heroin + found that there were changes in their neurones in the prefrontal cortex which made them more likely to seek the drug again - he concluded that the medial PFC could be a potential target for therapeutic drugs to reduce relapse in heroin addicts
What are the Similarities to Humans as a Reason for Conducting Animal Research in Psychology?
- Humans are more complex animals - so, easier to study more simple organisms first then generalise to humans
- Animals + humans both have brain structure + neurotransmitters are similar
- But, animals aren’t similar enough to humans - animals have different genetic structure + different balance in senses so perceive world differently
- Also, human behaviour is more complex + they have different motivations + have superior cognitive abilities (e.g. self-awareness)
What are Animals are Good Participants as a Reason for Conducting Animal Research in Psychology?
- They’re more controllable
- Research w/ them is highly reliable as they use standardised lab experiments which are easily replicated
- Faster breeding cycles allow test to be conducted on the influence of heredity + environment on behaviour - providing useful evidence for the ongoing nature nurture debate
What is the Theoretical Knowledge as a Reason for Conducting Animal Research in Psychology?
- Animal studies have contributed to our understanding of many topics in psychology
- Such as learning theories
- E.g. from Skinner’s rats
What are the Practical Application of Animal Findings as a Reason for Conducting Animal Research in Psychology?
- The treatments + therapies based on the principles of operant conditioning - such as the token economy is used in treating schizophrenics
- The training of animal helpers - e.g. guide/police dogs all trained using learning theory principles
What are 2 Reasons Why Animals Shouldn’t be used in Psychological Research?
- Ethical reasons - animals harmed during research, e.g. boredom, pain
- Practical reasons - Animals aren’t similar enough to humans to ensure research allows valid generalisation to humans = animals have different balance in senses so perceive the world differently + they have different genetic structure to humans
What does the BPS Code of Ethics and Conduct (2009) State what Psychologists Should do when Conducting Research Involving Animals?
- Observe the highest standards of animal welfare including reduction to the minimum of any pain, suffering, distress, frustration, fear, boredom, or lasting harm
- Avoid any of these conditions which cannot be justified in adherence to the Society’s published ‘Guidelines for Psychologists Working with Animals’ (BPS 2012)
What are the 8 Ethical Guidelines in the BPS Guidelines for Psychologists Working with Animals?
- Legislation
- Replacing use of animals
- Choice of species
- Number of animals
- Procedures
- Procurement of animals
- Disposing of animals
- Animal care
What is Legislation as an Ethical Guideline in the BPS Guidelines for Psychologists Working with Animals?
- Familiarise themselves with laws regarding animal welfare
* E.g. The animals (scientific procedures) act - 1986
What is Replacing the Use of Animals as an Ethical Guideline in the BPS Guidelines for Psychologists Working with Animals?
- Use of an alternative to using a live organism in research
- E.g. video recordings from previous work
What is Choice of Species as an Ethical Guideline in the BPS Guidelines for Psychologists Working with Animals?
- Use scientifically + ethically suitable species
* Justify choice in a project license application
What is Number of Animals as an Ethical Guideline in the BPS Guidelines for Psychologists Working with Animals?
- Use smallest number of animals needed
* Achieved by pilot studies, experimental design, statistical tests
What is Procedures as an Ethical Guideline in the BPS Guidelines for Psychologists Working with Animals?
- Avoid causing pain, sufferers bf, distress, lasting harm
- Permission for this needs a project licence - more benefits than costs
- E.g. The animals (scientific procedures) act - 1986 - includes (death, harm, disease, stress, discomfort, etc)
What is Procurement of Animals as an Ethical Guideline in the BPS Guidelines for Psychologists Working with Animals?
- Common lab species (rats, mice, etc) come from Home Office ‘Designated Breeding + Supply Establishments’
- Other species from high quality suppliers
What is Animal Care as an Ethical Guideline in the BPS Guidelines for Psychologists Working with Animals?
- High standard conditions for animals to be kept in - the animals (scientific procedures) act (1986)
- E.g. caging In isolation is stressful/overcrowding is stressful
What is Disposing of Animaos as an Ethical Guideline in the BPS Guidelines for Psychologists Working with Animals?
- Animals which have been used in a procedure it’s reuse is controlled - requires home office approval
- Killing done painlessly - use analgesics to minimise pain
What are the 3Rs that the Home Office says that the Government is Committed to Regarding the Use of Animals in Scientific Research?
- Replacement
- Reduction
- Refinement
What is Replacement as 1 of the 3Rs that the Home Office says that the Government is Committed to Regarding the Use of Animals in Scientific Research?
Animals are replaced with non-animal alternatives where ever possible
What is Reduction as 1 of the 3Rs that the Home Office says that the Government is Committed to Regarding the Use of Animals in Scientific Research?
Number of animals reduced to minimum needed to achieve the results
What is Refinement as 1 of the 3Rs that the Home Office says that the Government is Committed to Regarding the Use of Animals in Scientific Research?
Procedures are refined as much as possible to minimise their suffering
What are the 3 Licenses Required by the Animal (Scientific Procedures) Act 1986 Before Testing on Animals is Permitted?
- Personal license
- Project license
- Establishment license
What is the Personal License Required by the Animal (Scientific Procedures) Act 1986 Before Testing on Animals is Permitted?
For each person carrying out procedures on animals
What is the Project License Required by the Animal (Scientific Procedures) Act 1986 Before Testing on Animals is Permitted?
For the particular program of research
What is the Establishment License Required by the Animal (Scientific Procedures) Act 1986 Before Testing on Animals is Permitted?
For the place at which the work is carried out
What does the Animal (Scientific Procedures) Act 1986 Regulate?
The use of protected animals in experimental/scientific procedures which may cause pain, suffering, distress, lasting harm to the animal
What are the Advantages of the Use of Ethical Guidelines in Psychological Research with Animals?
- Good reputation of psychological research - adhering to societies moral standards means people are comfortable w/ research being carried on animals
- Rigourous legislation + clear ethical guidelines protect animals that are otherwise unable to defend themselves
- Research can be carried out that would benefit humans without the cost of such findings being too high for animals
What are the Disadvantages of the Use of Ethical Guidelines in Psychological Research with Animals?
- Must use smallest possible number of animals so generalisability + reliability of findings must be questioned
- Licenses from home office are expensive + difficult to acquire - limiting research opportunities
- Replication might be prevented so the study cannot be repeated - reducing reliability
- Cannot use endangered species so research is limited - e.g. Bonobo apes are our closest relatives in terms of DNA - increasing generalisability but they are also an endangered species
What 3 things does the Standard 2.2 on Ethical Decision Making say a Psychologist Should do in the BPS Code Ethics and Conduct (2009)?
- Be committed to the requirements of this code
- Accept responsibility to attempt to resolve such dilemmas
- Recognise ethical dilemmas will arise in course of professional practice
What are the 4 Stages of Risk Management in Psychological Research?
- Identify the risk
- Assess the risk
- Plan response to the risk
- Implement response
What is Risk Management in Psychological Research?
Forecasting + evaluation of ethical risks w/ the identification of procedures to avoid or minimise their impact
When do Ethical Dilemmas in Psychological Research Arise?
When the aims of the study + how it is planned clash w/ the needs + welfare of the participants
What is Cost-Benefit Analysis in Risk Management?
- A systematic process for comparing the benefits + costs of an ethical decision
- We are asking whether ‘the ends justify the means’ - is it worth it
What are Costs in a Cost-Benefit Analysis in Risk Management?
The potential negative consequences of the research for:
•Participants involved
•Sometimes for wider society
•The academic discipline of psychology
What are Benefits in a Cost-Benefit Analysis in Risk Management?
The potential positive consequences of the research for:
•Participants involved
•Sometimes for wider society
•The academic discipline of psychology
What is Reliability?
Research finding is produced consistently over many investigations
What is Replicability?
Repeating a study to check on its overall reliability
What are Standardised Procedures?
Set of events that occur in the same way every time data is collected for a study - used to minimise variation
What is Internal Validity?
Extent to which a test/measure of human behaviour accurately measures what it is supposed to
What are the 2 Types of External Validity?
- Population validity
* Ecological validity
What is Ecological Validity as a Type of External Validity?
Extent that a research finding obtained in 1 environment or situation can be generalised to a different environment/situation
What is Objectivity?
Ability to carry out an investigation + collect data without any personal interruption or bias to influence the process
What is Subjectivity?
Tendency to allow personal opinions + beliefs to influence the way the data is collected + how it can be interpreted
What is Generalisability?
Extent to which findings of a piece of research can be applied beyond the research itself
When can we be sure a Research Finding from a Study is Reliable?
- If it’s produced consistently over a number of investigations
- So if a study can be replicated to give similar findings, it indicates consistency over time, so it’s reliable
Why are Standardised Procedures Important in Psychological Research?
- They are used to minimise variation in what each participant experiences + what each researcher does
- Used to ensure replication of the methodology used so makes research valid
What are the 4 Types of Internal Validity?
- Face validity
- Concurrent validity
- Predictive validity
- Construct validity
What is Inter-Observer Reliability?
The extent to which different observers produce the same records when they observe the same sequence of behaviour
What is an Inference?
A logical conclusion which is based on available evidence
What is Face Validity as a Type of Internal Validity?
The extent to which a measure appears - on the face of it - at the surface to measure what it is supposed to measure
What is Concurrent Validity as a Type of Internal Validity?
A way of assessing validity by comparing the results of a measure with another already established measure of the same behaviour
What is Predictive Validity as a Type of Internal Validity?
How well a test or measure predicts future behaviours
What is Construct Validity as a Type of Internal Validity?
A way of assessing validity by showing that the test is measuring a phenomenon that actually exists
What is Population Validity as a Type of External Validity?
Extent to which results can be generalised to groups of people other than the sample of participants used
Why are Lab Experiments considered to have Low Ecological Validity?
- Results are obtained in artificial environments w/ tight control of variables
- The tasks for participants are often not related to real life
- So, the artificial settings + tasks mean that lab-based experiments lack mundane realism
What Factors can Influence the Generalisability of a Psychological Research Finding?
- Development differences - generalisability to other age groups
- Cultural context of the research - generalisability to other cultures
What is Quantitative Data?
The form of numbers + quantifies the behaviour being studied through measuring it on a numerical basis
What is Qualitative Data?
- Form of words + aims to give a complete account of what people think or feel based on what they say or what they write
- Data emphasises the description + meaning of behaviour
What are the Disadvantages of Qualitative Data?
- Analysis of data can be open to interpretation + so more subjective - decreasing validity
- Can be difficult to analyse - difficult to identify trends + themes in the data + reach conclusions
What are the Advantages of Qualitative Data?
- Rich + detailed info about the behaviour being studied - represents the true complexities of human behaviour which increases validity
- Data gives info about the meanings of behaviour - this tends to increase validity of research
What are the Disadvantages of Quantitative Data?
- Lack richness + detail about the behaviour under investigation - decreasing validity
- Doesn’t give full picture of what we’re studying - it’s lacking validity
- Reduces + oversimplifies complex behaviour to a set of numbers - reductionism in measuring behaviour can reduce validity as it doesn’t provide an accurate reflection of the behaviour
What are the Advantages of Quantitative Data?
- Easy to analyse-statistical tests can be used to allow objective comparisons between groups
- More reliable as the research producing the data tends to be easier to replicate
- More objectivity - researcher bias in interpreting the data is lower + can make data more accurate in measuring the behaviour - so validity can be increased
What is Primary Data?
Data gathered by the researchers themselves using research methods such as experiments, observations, questionnaires and interviews
What is Secondary Data?
Data gathered from already existing sources such as previously published research on the same topic, newspapers, films, books, websites, organisational records, etc
What is the Key Advantage of Primary Sources of Data?
The researcher is in control of the quality of the research as they designed the research + then collect + analyse the data themselves