Ch6 Flashcards
What can English only education cause an EL? (2)
Cultural suppression
Discrimination
In schools it is not only important that the EL become bilingual, it is important that they become ___
Bicultural
What is interrupted when an EL leaves a bilingual program too early?
cognitive development
Most bilingual programs promote __ __ to English only classes
early exit
Is being in a bilingual program a risk factor for dropping out?
No, other factors are much more significant
What is true about learning two languages?
Students achieve at a higher level
What came together to form bilingualism in the US
Historical precedents, federal legislative initiatives and judicial fiats
Who leads how is bilingualism implemented?
The states
Bilingualism progressed on these 3 fronts
- Cultural: accepted during good economic times
- Federal Legislation: depends on the vagaries of the states
- Judicial: Ruled EL’s deprived of proficiency in English must receive compensatory services
How many colonial languages were spoking in Manhattan in 1664?
At least 18
What 2 languages other than English do the Continental Congress publish docs?
German and French
In the early to mid 1800’s what three populations used a language other than English or bilingual education
- Cherokee: Language
- Louisiana: French-English or both on parent request
- New Mexico: Spanish-English bilingual
In 1900 4% of the US population was receiving at least partial instruction in ___?
German
What was done in 1879 to Native American children?
Forced to attend English only school off the reservation
What was the language requirement in the new territories of the Philippines and Puerto Rico?
English
What two language restrictions occurred in some areas of the US?
- German was criminalized
- 15 states legislated English as the language of instruction
What happened to Japanese schools during WW II?
Closed
What was true until 1960 in Rio Grande Valley Texas?
Detention for using Spanish
Bilingual education was virtually eradicated by ___
1930
After WW II, language-minority students were labeled, “culturally deficient” and “linguistically disabled” blaming (3)
- Inadequate English skills
- Lower-class values
- Failure of parents to stress educational attainment
After WW II, what was used as the basis for placing EL’s in classes for the educationally handicapped?
IQ tests administered in English
What caused the rebirth of bilingualism in the US in 1960
Cuban immigrants fleeing the 1959 revolution
What was the objective for bilingualism for the Cuban immigrants in 1960?
Fluency in both languages
The Bilingual Education Act of 1968 was not set up as an innovative approach to language instruction. Why was it set up?
As a remedial education to compensate for the handicap of not speaking English
When did the goal of bilingual education shift to developing native language proficiency?
1998
In the 1980s during a concern with new immigration, what were the goals of the English-as-the-Official-Language Movement? (3)
A movement sought to:
1) Install English as the official language
2) Repeal laws mandating multilingual ballots
3) Restrict bilingual funding to short-term transitions
Those who believe in “one language, one nation” have difficulty accepting Spanish ___ in public
signs
What 6 counties have multiple “official” languages?
Canada, Belgium, Finland, Cameroon, Peru, Singapore
What has bilingualism and multilingualism become in our world
A fact of life
What is true about proficiency in more than one language
It is a desired trait
The use of languages other than English, especially schools, has been affected by cycles of ___ and ___
liberalism, intolerance
What 3 entities have supported bilingual education
Congress, State and Federal Courts
When and what did the original Bilingual Education Act support?
- 1968
- Exploratory programs for children 3-8
What did the $85,000,000 from the Bilingual Education Act (1968) support? (4)
- Support education programs
- Train teachers
- Develop and disseminate instructional material
- Encourage parental involvement
In 1970, the US Civil Rights Office mandated these 4 things for districts with > 5% national origin minority
- Special language instruction
- Prohibited assignment to handicap classes based on English skill
- Prohibited vocational track placement in place of teaching EL skills
- Mandated communication with parents in a language they understand
Lau vs. Nichols (1974) What was significant about their finding and what happened in 2001 and 2004?
- Lawsuits could be brought over discriminatory effect, without having to prove intent
- Struck down
- Reinstated with “intent”
The Bilingual Education Act (1974) (a) affirmed that the federal government has a special and continuing obligation to ensure state and local schools provide …
(b) Include the use of students’ …
(c) ___ no longer a requirement
(d) ___ were eligible
(a) equal opportunity for EL’s
(b) native language
(c) Poverty
(d) Native Americans
Rios vs. Read (1977) was a lawsuit brought not for the lack of a bilingual program, but for a lack of …
a cultural component
Pyler vs. Doe (1982): A state cannot deny enrollment to children …
of illegal immigrants
The 1984 reauthorization provided for two types of bilingual programs, transitional and developmental. This was the first time this goal was legislated.
The goal of competence in two languages
In 1994, the “Improving America’s Schools Act (IASA) did these 4 things
- Reinforced professional development
- Improved research and evaluation
- Supplied additional funds
- Modified eligibility to include EL’s
No Child Left Behind (2001 ESEA) stated that EL’s would be held to …
the same high standard as non-EL students
What are 4 “failures” of No Child Left Behind?
- Emphasis on short-term test results
- Lack of funding to achieve goals
- Punitive sanctions
- Pressure to abandon successful EL programs
What are some states more concerned about than the federal mandates?
Protecting states rights
In 1998, CA with Prop 227 rejected bilingual education with 2 provisions
- Students must learn English taught in English
- EL’s in sheltered learning for a period not > 1 year
What states also proposed a dismantling of federal directives after CA’s Prop 227 that dismantled bilingual education?
AZ, MA, CO and FL
What is the most extensive set of state mandates?
Florida Consent Decree
What was the problem with many of the state initiatives to dismantle bilingual education?
Dismantling bilingual programs and expecting children to master English in a year flies in the face of research.
What group has the highest dropout rate among bilingual students?
Hispanics: M/F 20% / 17%