2. QUESTIONS BASED ON THE SOCIOLOGY OF HEALTH BOOK Flashcards
- What is Sociology a scientific approach of?
- it is a Scientific Approach to understanding people in society
- What do social structures exert on individuals?
- they exert influence over our behaviour
- What do Sociological Perspectives on Health emphasise?
- they emphasise that it is vital to understand the social
- this allows us to understand health and illness to a much better extent
- What do Sociological Perspectives on Health emphasise?
- they emphasise that it is vital to understand the social
- this allows us to understand health and illness to a much better extent
- What does the Sociological Imagination invite us to do?
- they invite us to think beyond our own subjective perceptions
- Why are Sociological theories useful?
- they are useful in moving away from common-sense understandings of society
- What is Sociology concerned with?
- the study of human society
- specifically key issues: such as the change and distribution of power between different social groups
- it looks at the interactions between individuals and groups
- as well as the interaction between groups and other groups
- What is Sociological imagination?
- it is a way of thinking that requires you to adopt a critical and questioning approach to even the most mundane aspects of social life
- What is Sociological knowledge based on?
- it is based on the scientific approach
- this approach is built upon evidence to support theoretical perspectives
- What does the term Society refer to?
- it refers to the structural factors that influence our beliefs and our behaviour
- these factors establish some predictability and regularity in our lives
- What does socialisation into the norms and values of a particular society bring about?
- it enables us to predict and make sense of the behaviours of others and of ourselves
- What does Society provide us with?
- it provides us with cultural resources to live in the social world
- it teaches us patterns of behaviour, responses and ways of behaving
- these teachings exist outside any one individual, and were invented a very long time ago
- What is present with most human encounters within a specific society?
- there are roles to be played out
- responses to be predicted
- cues to be acted upon
- What determines how people act?
- the way we act is not our own personal invention
- it emerges out of the society in which we live
- the ways we act, behave and think are shaped by a number of subtle, direct and indirect processes over our whole lives
- What kind of relationship exists between individuals and the society or structure in which they live?
- a specific and distinct one
- Will each person in the same social class category have identical experiences?
- NO
- What are two things that can be determined based on social class?
- morbidity rate
- mortality rate
- What allows us to justifiably place people in specific groupings?
- the sufficient amount of similarities in patterns of health within the social class
- In which fields of life can these similar experiences be seen in?
Name 5
- income levels
- availability of local resources
- availability of doctors in their geographical locations
- their physical environment
- patterns of expenditure
- What two terms explain the relationship between society and the individual?
- structure
- agency
- What is the concept of agency?
- this concept determines the way in which we are shaped by society
- and how we can then shape society
- Provide a definition of an agent?
- an agent is an individual engaging with the social structure
- Within biology and medicine, what factors do we look at when examining a person’s state of health?
- we look at the state of the person
- the risk of infection of the person
- an ability to fight the infection
- genetic predispositions
- Within sociology, what factors do we look at when examining a person’s state of health?
- social and environmental factors
- age
- social class
- gender
- How is sociology relevant to the health?
- it helps us understand and explain health
- in terms of how health is related to and affected by a person’s social structure
- What does a sociological understanding of health consider?
- it considers structural and social factors
- rather than just biological explanations of health and disease
- Is the discipline of sociology modern or an older teaching?
- it is fundamentally a modern one
- this is because it is always trying to explain, anticipate and alter a rapidly changing world
- Where are the structures and relationships of sociology derived from?
- industrialism
- Who are the four Founding Fathers of Sociology?
- Comte
- Durkheim
- Weber
- Marx
- What us the underlying motivation of sociology?
- to reveal the reality of social relationships
- What kind of explanations are sociological ones?
- rational
- empirical
- What is the basis of scientific explanations?
- they are consistent
- they can contradict themselves at times
- they must accord with evidence
- the explanation itself must be changed if evidence disproving it is found
- What is one crucial difference between sociological and scientific explanations?
- the methods employed to uncover evidence are completely different
- natural sciences can use an experimental method to find evidence as their subject matter can be simply measured
- sociologists cannot use experimental methods as they are testing human society, human behaviour, actions and their meanings, consciousness
- Why is the study of sociology liberating?
- it teaches the appreciation of cultural variety
- it allows an insight into the working of social institutions
- What does Social Imagination urge us to do?
- it urges us to think outside of our own experiences
- to depart from what is referred to as common-sense explanations
- What are common sense explanations?
- an explanation of phenomena based on limited observations of human behaviour
and on our own limited experiences of the social world
- What 3 Fundamental Questions does Sociological Imagination bring about?
- What is the structure of this particular society?
- Where does this society stand in human history?
- What varieties of men and women now prevail in this society and this period?
- What is ensured when these questions are asked and answered?
- there are no assumptions made about what is being studied
- that the context, both cultural and historical, is taken into account when considering any explanation of what is observed
- What is a fundamental concern of Sociology?
- the distribution if power in society
- and it’s consequences
- What is the product of inequality in terms of Health?
- it is literally a matter of life and death
- it is a result of social disadvantage
- What is a Theory in common-sense terms?
- it is a set of ideas or propositions used to explain and predict social phenomena
- it is derived from a particular perspective or worldview
- it only permits certain kinds of explanations
- usually rational and scientific ones that do not tolerate explanations that cannot be evidenced
- they can sometimes be heavily based on opinion rather than on facts
- What is a paradigm?
- it is a description of the interactions of human beings within any society
- paradigms are broad viewpoints or perspectives that permit social scientists to have a wide range of tools to describe society,
- they can use this to build hypotheses and theories
- Should sociological explanations share characteristics with scientific explanations?
- yes
- they should both be consistent
- they must accord with evidence
- they must change if evidence can be found to refute them
- What are sociological theories characterised by?
- the need to be consistent
- the need to be evidenced
- What is the difference between a sociological and a common-sense theory?
- a sociological theory goes beyond what we can see and measure
- this allows us to explain phenomena in which we have no direct experience
- What is the medical model of health about?
- it has a mechanistic (purely physical) view of the body
- it has a reliance on biological causation to explain illness
- What does the social model of health provide?
- it provides a holistic approach
- it stresses that health and illness can only be explained by analysing the social
- What are the limits to the social model of health?
- it can overemphasise the role of the social
- it can forget that health is experienced in the human body
- What do theories of wellbeing attempt to capture?
- they attempt to capture a holistic and rounded account of people’s lives
- they go beyond the binaries of health and illness
- What do Traditional medicine and Alternative therapies provide?
- they provide other models and ways of thinking about health and well being
- What does the Sociological Imagination urge us to do when it comes to health and well being?
- it urges us to think of health and well being in a radically more different and open minded manner
- What is Biomedicine?
- a principle way of understanding health and illness in a global culture
- it is widely accepted by the medical profession and the lay
-the lay: non-professional population
- How many defining characteristics are there to the medical model of the explanation of health?
- Five
- Name the 5 defining characteristics to the medical model of the explanation of health?
- Mind-Body Dualism
- Mechanical Metaphor
- Technological Imperative
- Reductionist Tendency
- Doctrine of Specific Aetiology
- What does Mind- Body Dualism refer to?
- it refers to an acceptance of the mind and the body as 3 separate entities when it comes to treating the patient
- the subject of the medicine is the physical body
- the focus is not placed on what may be the “problematic” mind
- What does Mechanical Metaphor refers to?
- it refers to the idea that medicine is said to refer to the body as a machine
- the belief that the functioning of the body is determined by biological and scientific laws
- knowing how the body functions allows medical practitioners to repair any disfunction
- What does Technological Imperative refer to?
Imperative= of vital importance
- the significance attached to medical methods of intervention in treating the body
- intervention can be surgical or pharmacological
- In Biomedicine, what is usually overemphasised?
- the curative (able to cure disease) element of biomedicine
- this takes away focus from the beneficial contributions of lifestyle changes (dietary or environmental changes)
- What does the Reductionist Theory refer to?
Reductionist= analysing and describing a complex phenomenon in terms of its simple or fundamental constituents
- there is a tendency in BioMedicine to reduce all explanations of the physical workings of the body
- the medical model of health tends to not acknowledge both the social and psychological factors that influence health
- What does the Doctrine of Specific Aetiology refer to?
Doctrine= a belief or set of beliefs held and taught by a Church, political party, or other group
Aetiology= the cause, set of causes, or manner of causation of a disease or condition
Causation= the action of causing something
- the belief that all disease originates from specific and knowable causes
- What is a criticism aimed at the Medical Model of Health?
- that it can do both good and harm
- What is the concept of Iatrogenesis?
Iatrogenesis= relating to illness caused by medical examination or treatment
- this refers to any harm caused by a doctor
- this means that the patient would not have been harmed had they not experienced medical intervention
- What is ‘Clinical’ Iatrogenesis?
- the harm caused to a patient through drug therapies, doctors or hospital
- What is ‘Cultural’ Iatrogenesis?
- a dependence on medicine to cure and to care for people
- this causes people to no longer take responsibility for their own health problems and the diagnosis of these
- patients no longer seek out alternative explanations or remedies for their health
- What is the result of ‘Cultural’ Iatrogenesis?
- it leads to a situation called a ‘medical nemesis’
- this means that the harm caused by medicine is difficult to eliminate
EXCEPT by suggesting further medical intervention - this results in even more harm
- it becomes a vicious cycle
- How has medicine prolonged the lives of people?
- through radical interventions (such as organ transplants)
- through elimination of pain that is caused by minor ailments (such as headaches and period pains)
- this is why there is such a reliance and dependency on medicine
- What has been the most beneficial aspect of medicine?
- it has transformed yesterday’s killers into today’s modern nuisances
- What is the medical model?
- a specific way of thinking about and explaining diseases
- it is based on biological factors
- What does the fluid nature of Medical Knowledge result in?
- it results in some elements of the medical model changing importance over time
- What causes the fluidity of medical knowledge and its changes over time?
- this is, in part, due to the socially constructed nature of medical knowledge
- What is Social Constructionism?
- it is an emphasis on the extent to which society is actively and creatively produced by human beings
- What are Social Worlds?
- they are interpretive nets woven by individuals and groups
- What does the term Paradigm refer to?
- it refers to a model or mode of thought
- it is a particular way of seeing the world
- it sets boundaries to what we see, how we record and measure information
- it helps us understand which factors are significant and which are not
- How has Medical Knowledge about Health and Disease become more specialised?
- the focus is first on the whole person
- then specific parts of the body are examined
- finally, the construction of cells is analysed
- Which is currently more important in medicine: theoretical/learned knowledge or experimental knowledge?
- theoretical/learned knowledge
- What happens when there is a paradigm shift?
- there is a shift in the nature of the relationship between the practitioner and the patient
- What distinguishes diseases from the past from the conditions of today?
- the conditions of today have social causes
- What does it mean when Sociologists say that: “diseases and poor well being are caused by social aspects”?
- it means that various aspects of the societies that we live in are not good for our health or our well being
- these aspects include: inequality, racism, sexism, lack of control, lack of purpose and lack of meaning
- Can you name 4 Risk Factors that are biologically proven to negatively affect a person’s health?
- poor diet
- smoking
- lack of exercise
- drinking too much
- What fraction of a person’s health is determined by these biological risk factors.
- only a third
- the other 2 thirds are a result of society in which we live
- What is the main aim of the Social Model of Health?
- it is to place health into a social context
- it is to understand health as something that emerges from many different processes and influences that include and go beyond the purely biological
- What does Sociology suggest when it comes to what makes an individual have poor health?
- it is not just the individuals lifestyle choices that lead to them having good or bad health
- it also comes down to the society the individual lives in and how this affects them
- How does the society in which we live have an affect on our health?
- various social processes create the context in which we exist
- this then provides us with resources
- this then decides the opportunities we have
- it faces us with challenges that either enable or prevent us from living a healthy, rewarding and fulfilling life
- What can sociologists who follow the social model tend to overemphasise?
- they overemphasise the social to the point where they forget that there are fleshly, biological bodies
THAT EXPERIENCE pain, discomfort and illness
- What do many Sociologists suggest we develop with regards to health models?
- they suggest we develop more nuanced models of thinking about health
- models that capture the richness and depth of all the multiple processes which shape our health
- What can the Social Model of Health be overly critical of?
- the medical profession
- What are 4 challenges that have led to the Medical Profession losing power over time and being more prone to open Criticism?
- Patient’s knowledge on their diseases
- Alternative Practitioners
- Clinical Autonomy
- Private Pharmaceutical Corporations
- How does a patient’s knowledge on their disease negatively affect the Medical Profession?
- patients are generally better informed about their conditions than they were in the past
- especially those with chronic illnesses
- they can discredit the information the medical practitioner gives them
- How do Alternative Practitioners negatively affect the Medical Profession?
- they raise serious questions about the effectiveness of conventional treatments
- they question the potentially damaging long-term effects of conventional treatments
- How does Clinical Autonomy negatively affect the Medical Profession?
- Clinical Autonomy comes from Governments
- they seek to regulate medical and other health professions
- this can limit the creativity and the free will of the doctor
- How do Private Pharmaceutical corporations negatively affect the Medical Profession?
- they influence and set the health agenda
- this can be very biased towards a specific goal
- What is the Hedonic Approach to well being?
- well-being is a result of living a happy and pleasurable life
- the aim is to maximise happiness and to dispense negative feelings when they arise
- health is a result of living a satisfactory life, with an abundance of positive moods and an absence of negative ones
- Provide a definition foe Hedonic Psychology?
- it is the study of what makes experiences and life pleasant or unpleasant
- it is concerned with feelings of pleasure and pain
- it is also concerned with boredom, joy, sorrow, satisfaction and dissatisfaction
- What is the Eudaimonic Approach to health?
- this views health as a result of achieving happiness in the long run
- it believes happiness in a life-long task
- it about reaching out to others and finding meaning in what one does
- this may involve the individual to forgo short term pleasure and happiness in pursuit of a long term deeper sense of self
- What is crucially stated by the Eudaimonic approach to well being?
- negative states are not to be avoided
- they are to be accepted if they are necessary in gaining a fuller life
- life is a project
- where deeper moments of self-realisation and self-confirmation are necessary
- these are achieved by engaging in meaningful endeavours and activities
- How is well being viewed in the Eudaimonic approach?
- it is viewed as a process
- it is something we do together
- it recognises that well being and environment are interlinked
- What is “Disneyfication”?
- it is a form of criticism of the Hedonic and Eudaimonic views of health
- it claims that these views of health emphasis a false emotional self
- where all is wonderful and optimistic
- this overlooks and ignores natural negative emotions which do not neatly fit into these views
- these emotions are not dealt with and are treated as though they do not exist
- this can do more harm than good
- What is Californication?
- it is a form of criticism of the Hedonic and Eudaimonic views of health
- is judges the belief that everyone is meant to be happy and balanced all the time
- and if you are not, then there is a severe issue with you
- which the psychiatrist must deal with at once
- What is it to have a Eurocentric mindset?
- it is to believe that western medicine is the only way of treating others
- to believe that western customs are superior to those of traditions and cultures elsewhere
- What view point do both traditional and alternative medicines share?
- they view treatment as a holistic understanding of what it wrong with the patient
- they look holistically at what causes poor and good health
- how external circumstances affect the health of a person
- How would one describe Traditional Medicine?
- it is typically found in the global south
- it draws deeply on experiences, beliefs and the culture of a particular society
- it has a very long history
- it is the sum total of the knowledge, skill and practices based on the theories, beliefs and experiences that are indigenous to different cultures
- even if these beliefs are explicable or not
- these medicines are used in the maintenance of health, as well as the prevention, diagnosis, improvement or treatment of physical and mental illness
- How would one describe Alternative Medicine?
- it is typically found in the global north
- it is popular among people who are dissatisfied with conventional medicine
- they often draw on information from other traditional medicines, but they lack the cultural roots in the society in which they are adopted
- What causes variations in the form of Traditional medicines used?
- the traditional medicine tactics used vary by country and region
- there is always an emphasis on some sort of holism
- as well as a belief in spirits or magic
- What do Traditional healer’s look at?
- they look at the cause of a patient’s misfortune/illness
- they look at it in the context of social, natural and spiritual environments
- Where are the remedies used in Traditional Medicines derived from?
- they are derived from medicinal plants
- from herbs
- from animal sources
- Can there be a cross-over between alternative and traditional medicines.
Provide an example.
- yes there can be
- Ayurvedic medicine is a traditional medicine used in India, where it originated
- it is a holistic approach that focuses on balancing life forces, exercise and diet
- it is also commonly used in Europe and North America
- these places lack the roots, heritage and culture to this traditional medicine that they have adopted
- therefore, it is seen as alternative medicine
- Why do people choose traditional care?
- it may align with their cultural beliefs
- accessing medical doctors may be impossible due to poor infrastructure, lack of roads and lack of transport services
- visiting a doctor is very costly
- their is a relationship between socio-economic status and orthodox health care usage
- a decreased level of income results in a reliance on traditional healers
NB: both traditional medicine and orthodox health care can be used by a patient simultaneously
- What did the World Health Organisation’s (WHO) Traditional Medicine Strategy of 2014-2023 propose?
- we should harness the potential contribution of traditional medicine to health, wellness and people centred health care
- we should promote safe and effective use of traditional medicine by regulating, researching and integrating traditional medicine products, practitioners and practice into appropriate parts of the health care system
- How can Complementary and Alternative Medicine be defined?
- it describes any practices that fall outside the boundaries of conventional medicine
- they deal with the unity of the mind, body and spirit
- it is a non-conventional medicine that can be used in conjunction with western biomedicine rather than as a radical alternative
- What are the categories that Complementary and Alternative Medicine can be divided into?
- physical
- psychological
- paranormal
- practices that demand high training
- do it yourself and at home practices
- How has BioMedicine sought out to emphasise a further distinction between itself and alternative medical practices?
- it has asserted supremacy of science over superstition
- it has committed itself to dealing only with scientific methods which are free from social or political bias
- How has BioMedicine positioned itself to be viewed as the “truth”?
- it is based on scientific observation of natural phenomena
- it conducts tests and research on these phenomena
- this brings about accurate results that can be repeated
- this repetition of the result values brings about validity
- this allows laws facts to be written and proved about these natural phenomena
- alternative medicine cannot produce the same kind of testing
- Can BioMedicine and Alternative Medicines both be accepted and why?
- yes they can
- they are equally valid conceptions of the body, health and disease
- they just have criteria that the other does not
- List 4 differences between Alternative Medicine and BioMedicine.
1.
Alternative Medicine: health is viewed as a balance of
opposing forces within the body
BioMedicine: health is viewed as an absence of the
disease
2.
Alternative Medicine: the disease indicates that there is a
presence of negative, disruptive
forces within the body.
symptoms are a product of the
body’s attempt to get rid of toxic
substances
BioMedicine: disease is defined in relation to a specific
part of the body.
diseases are a deviation from the normal
functioning of the body
- Alternative Medicine: ‘reading’ the body, examining the
dietary habits, lifestyles and
constitution types help to bring
about a diagnosis with regard to the
patient’s health
BioMedicine: a diagnosis is achieved by examining the
form and structure of the specific organism
and the degree to which the presence of the
disease indicates a deviation from normal
functioning - Alternative Medicine: the therapy is based on an attempt
to strengthen vitalising, positive
forces within the body
BioMedicine: therapy consists of attempts to destroy or
suppress disease
- What are some reasons why Contemporary and Alternative medicine are being favoured instead of BioMedicine?
- people are less likely to put their effort into communal goals and activities, such as a communal orientation to health
- people are more likely to seek private solutions to their problems
- alternative and contemporary medicine fits this trend as the individual seeks out the solution for themselves
- people are not fond of the unequal power relationships between the patient and the doctor in BioMedicine
- alternative and contemporary medicine brings about a more equal power sharing relationship between practitioners and patients because the practitioners pay attention to the patient’s personal circumstances
- BioMedicine has medicalised many aspects of human existence in an inhumane way
- Seeing the disease as a purely biological entity is not always beneficial.
- it does not satisfy the patient’s need to understand why they have developed the illness
- people are now preferring natural remedies over chemically produced ones
- What are the limits of BioMedicine?
- biomedicine is unable to cure certain diseases
- it does not place enough emphasis on the causes of illness
- it is preoccupied with relieving symptoms
- the side effects of biomedical treatment are potentially harmful
- biomedical treatments can be too drastic and too invasive
- What are the benefits of alternative medicine?
- they provide an explanation of the causes of ill health
- they put the disease in context of a person’s individual lifestyle
- they provide a more egalitarian (equal) relationship between the patient and the practitioner
- they offer an alternative to high tech medicine
- they treat the person as a whole
- they encourage individuals to take greater responsibility for their health
- How is Alternative Medicine portrayed in a sense of post modern society?
- it expresses a greater desire for self determination and choice
- it challenges the cultural dominance of biomedicine
- it reflects a more general trend for maintaining the body through purchase of consumer goods and services