1-4- Swift & Marzluff 2015 Flashcards
What happened in the 72 hours after observing novel humans paired with a dead crow, a red-tailed hawk or a hawk with a dead crow?
Crows mobbed and increased the time to approach food
On the day the stimulus was presented, the number of trials that resulted in mobbing and
avoidance of the food was strongest when what happened?
On the day the stimulus was presented, the number of trials that resulted in mobbing and
avoidance of the food was strongest when crows were presented a hawk with a dead crow
Crows use the proximity of a human to predators, to dead conspecifics and to
predators with dead conspecifics as cues to learn to recognize and subsequently scold the associated
human after only one training event, and that this association can last how long?
6 weeks
Which animals congregate around dead conspecifics?
Black-billed magpies, western scrub-jays, chimpanzees, african elephants and bottlenose dolphins
Which animals respond to dead conspecifics in the absence of artificial distress calls?
Western scrub-jays
following carcass removal, what did scrub-jays show?
following carcass removal, scrub-jays show
reduced feeding activity in the area for 24 h.
How can fear be extinguished?
Fear can be extinguished, however, through repeated exposure to the conditioned
stimulus without reinforcing its predictive value of the unconditioned stimulus
what was experiment 1?
To test
danger learning, we conducted three experiments on wild crows. In
experiment 1, we examined (1) whether the sight of a dead
conspecific is sufficient to elicit alarm calling and recruitment, or
whether the presence of an unconditioned predator is also necessary, (2) whether crows learn areas associated with these dangers
and subsequently avoid them, (3) whether crows use dead conspecifics to identify novel predators and, if so, how this process
compares to conditioned learning when novel predators are paired
with unconditioned stimuli (hawks), and (4) whether fear extinction can be achieved with a minimum of three additional exposures.
What was experiment 2?
For experiment 2, we determined whether a dead conspecific
is a more salient source of dangerous information than a similarly
sized, dead heterospecific
What was experiment 3?
In experiment 3, we compared responses of rock pigeons and crows to dead conspecifics.
what were the three phases of each experiment?
conditioning, stimulus presentation and post-exposure
We assumed that no more than ___ adult birds occupied each territory, as helping behaviour occurs infrequently in crow populations
in the northwestern United States
We assumed that no more than two adult birds occupied each territory, as helping behaviour occurs infrequently in crow populations
in the northwestern United States
Crows received a 2:1 mix of what?
Crows received a 2:1 mix of raw, unshelled peanuts and cheese puffs
Pigeons received a 2:1 mix of what?
Pigeons received a 2:1 mix of
birdseed and crumbled white bread.
After providing food, the observer monitored the food pile from ____ m away, for up to ____, and measured the birds’ latency to approach within ___m of
the food pile (‘food discovery time’).
observer monitored the food pile from 15-25 m away, for up to 2.5 h, and measured the birds’ latency to approach within 2 m of the food pile (‘food discovery time’).
What was the conditioning phase?
Once the birds at each site approached the food within the 2.5 h observation period for 3 consecutive days (in most tests, birds met
the criterion in 3 days; in seven tests, birds took up to 10 days to meet the criterion), we began the stimulus presentation phase on the following day (day 4).
During the stimulus presentation phase, we _____ _____ ____ _____, after which a volunteer ______________________
During the stimulus presentation phase, we provided food as normal, after which a volunteer exposed an experimental or a control stimulus 2 m from the food pile
Volunteers
wore one of six ______ _____ with _____ _____
Volunteers
wore one of six realistic facemasks with neutral expressions
Why did volunteers wear a white sign
around their neck that read ‘UW CROW STUDY’?
to limit interruptions by pedestrians or police
During stimulus presentation,
the data collector recorded instances and durations of _____ and
typical crow ____ ____, and the number ____ _____ ____ _____
During stimulus presentation,
the data collector recorded instances and durations of scolds and
typical crow contact calls, and the number of birds present within
25 m of the stimulus
what was mob formation?
the presence of
more than two scolding individuals within 25 m of the stimulus.
what was mob size?
We calculated mob size as the maximum number of individuals
present during the stimulus event.
why did they not determine
whether all individuals within a mob actively scolded beyond the
three-bird minimum?
Because mobs are highly mobile and most birds were not individually marked
The volunteer removed the stimulus ___min after the first bird perched within __ m of the stimulus and was
observed gazing towards the experimental set-up (‘stimulus discovery time’).
The volunteer removed the stimulus 30 min after the first bird perched within 25 m of the stimulus and was
observed gazing towards the experimental set-up (‘stimulus discovery time’).
Following stimulus removal, for up to __h, the
observer recorded the birds’ latency to approach within __m of the
food pile (‘food discovery time’).
Following stimulus removal, for up to 2.5 h, the
observer recorded the birds’ latency to approach within 2 m of the
food pile (‘food discovery time’).
We removed all but a small
amount (_____) of food after ___-h
We removed all but a small
amount (five pieces) of food after 2.5 h
. If birds approached the pile
in the presence of the stimulus, we recorded the food discovery
time as ___s
. If birds approached the pile
in the presence of the stimulus, we recorded the food discovery
time as 0 s.
The observer used ____, ____, ___and ___ ___ to discriminate between hatch-year and older birds
The observer used plumage, profile, voice and mouth
lining to discriminate between hatch-year and older birds
Only birds
older than 1 year of age were counted for what?
Only birds
older than 1 year of age were counted for stimulus discovery time,
food discovery time and mob or group size.
During the post-exposure phase, on days __-__, we split the
experiment into two trial types
During the post-exposure phase, on days 5e7, we split the
experiment into two trial types
what was trial type A
In trial type A, we
continued to provide food (as described above) to test for site
aversion.
what was trial type B?
In trial type B, following standard feeding by the observer
(as during conditioning), a volunteer wearing the same mask as
seen during the stimulus exposure phase arrived and stood 2 m
from the food pile.
What was the difference between A and B?
n trial type B, following standard feeding by the observer
(as during conditioning), a volunteer wearing the same mask as
seen during the stimulus exposure phase arrived and stood 2 m
from the food pile. The experimental procedure during test trial B
otherwise matched that of the stimulus exposure phase, allowing
us to test for novel predator learning and to evaluate the influence
of varying levels of exposure to danger on fear extinction
which experiment used both trial types?
experiment 1
what trial type did experiments 2 and 3 use?
Experiments 2 and 3 used trial
type A during the post-exposure phase.
marked individuals were banded __ years before the
onset of the present experiment.
marked individuals were banded 5 years before the
onset of the present experiment.
Experimental locations were
established ___-___m from nest sites to limit nest disturbance.
Experimental locations were
established 35-45 m from nest sites to limit nest disturbance.
How many sites were there and how many territorial pairs?
In 2013 and 2014, we selected 17 independent sites and, within
each site, identified seven to nine territorial pairs
In
April-June, we used ___ ___ to define the _____ for tests,
and established specific test locations ___-___m from the nest tree
In
April-June, we used nesting areas to define the locations for tests,
and established specific test locations 35-45 m from the nest tree
During July-September, we identified test _____by the presence of ____ ____or the consistent ____ ___ ____ ____ ____
During July-September, we identified test locations by the presence of fledged young or the consistent presence of an adult pair.
American crow territories in the urban core are smaller than what?
American crow territories in the urban core are smaller than their
suburban counterparts
what was the minimum distance between two test locations?
90m
what was the median distance between two test locations
430m
During the stimulus presentation phase of the experiment, birds
received one of five stimuli . what were they?
3 dangerous:
- dead crow + mask
- hawk + mask
- dead crow + hawk + mask
2 control:
- person in mask
- food only
Between sites, why did they vary the
sequence of stimulus presentations ?
Between sites, we varied the
sequence of stimulus presentations so that the order of control and
dangerous stimuli were counterbalanced.
. In 2014, what was not used?
. In 2014, the mask-only
control was not used
what happened because the mask only control was to used in 2014?
. In 2014, the mask-only
control was not used, and thus fewer sites were tested in 2014
than in 2013.
how many taxidermy crows and hawks were there?
We used three identically prepared taxidermy mounts of crows (randomized across trials) but only a single, mounted redtailed hawk.
Because of time constraints, in ___ of cases, birds were present
during the stimulus set-up and witnessed the unmasked volunteer
interact with the avian stimuli.
Because of time constraints, in 43% of cases, birds were present
during the stimulus set-up and witnessed the unmasked volunteer
interact with the avian stimuli.
why did they not believe witnissing the set-up biased the response?
Given that humans were common at
each site and that their presence with or near dangers was already
an element of our experimental design,
what happened (more detail) in trial type A?
in trial type A (N =74, which
included 17 food-only controls), we provided food as during the
conditioning phase.
what happened (more detail) in trial type B?
In trial type B (N =57), after the observer
provided food, a colleague wearing the same mask used during the
stimulus presentation phase immediately arrived and stood 2 m
from the food pile.
how did they test longevity of response?
scolding, diving
or mobbing the masked person, or refusing to approach within 2 m
of the food pile for the full 2.5 h after the masked person’s departure
We administered up to ___ weekly
tests (longevity tests 1-6),
We administered up to six weekly
tests (longevity tests 1-6),
because of time constraints, only ___
of the 17 sites (one each from Redmond and Kirkland, and all nine
Seattle sites; 77 of 114 potential territories) were tested beyond the
first longevity test.
because of time constraints, only 11
of the 17 sites (one each from Redmond and Kirkland, and all nine
Seattle sites; 77 of 114 potential territories) were tested beyond the
first longevity test.
when were tests discontinued?
Tests were discontinued prior to completing all
six tests if the birds became unresponsive.